In the frostbitten isolation of 1630s New England, a single whispered question hangs over everything: would you trade your soul for a taste of freedom? Robert Eggers’ The Witch turns that temptation into a quiet, unrelenting force that dismantles an entire family’s faith from within.
This article examines how Eggers built his debut feature on documented 17th-century sources, real performance choices, and practical craft decisions to create a folk horror film that still shapes the genre years later. It traces the story’s historical roots, the performances at its centre, the technical approach to sound and image, and the lasting influence on modern horror.
The film opens with a patriarchal expulsion that mirrors the real risks English Puritans accepted when they crossed the Atlantic. William, played by Ralph Ineson, moves his wife Katherine (Kate Dickie), daughter Thomasin (Anya Taylor-Joy), the twins Mercy and Jonas, and infant Samuel into the forest after clashing with their plantation community. The move places them in territory the Algonquian peoples already understood as alive with spirits, yet the settlers saw only the devil’s realm. That immediate displacement sets the stakes for everything that follows.
Exile into the Unknown
When baby Samuel vanishes near the treeline, the family begins to fracture. Thomasin is left holding nothing but empty air, and the camera stays on her face long enough for the shock to settle. William’s failed hunts and the thin meals of goat’s milk and berries expose how quickly colonial self-reliance can collapse under hunger and doubt. The homestead itself feels lived-in and cramped, its details drawn from period journals that describe vermin and constant cold. Eggers pulled dialogue straight from William Bradford’s writings and Salem trial records, so the prayers carry the actual weight of Calvinist fears about predestination. That level of accuracy turns the deliberate pace into something that lets suspicion grow naturally rather than through forced shocks.
Black Phillip and the Goatish Tempter
Black Phillip stands at the centre of the film’s quiet menace. The real goat was trained for weeks, and its steady stare and sudden aggression make the animal feel like more than livestock. The name comes directly from witch-trial accounts of demonic familiars, and the twins’ nursery rhymes shift from play into something far more ominous. When Caleb returns from the woods already changed, his fevered confession in the rain mixes religious language with physical intensity that feels both ecstatic and disturbing. The goat’s final offer to Thomasin, voiced in a low, deliberate tone, gives her the first real choice she has ever been offered. That moment pulls from Cotton Mather’s own descriptions of spectral evidence, grounding the supernatural in the exact fears that shaped early American communities.
Sensory Siege: Sound and Silence
Mark Korven’s score works through restraint rather than volume. Sparse strings and woodwinds that imitate wind through trees create a constant low pressure, while sudden percussive hits land like sudden judgments. The family’s unanswered prayers sit in long silences that make the isolation feel physical. Jarin Blaschke shot with natural light and candle flames, producing the same half-lit faces found in Dutch Golden Age paintings Eggers studied. The 1.66:1 frame keeps everything close and slightly boxed in, matching the feeling of lantern-lit rooms. Small objects carry extra weight: the silver cup that once held milk now holds grief, and the rabbits glimpsed in the woods suggest a world that has frozen in fear. These details reward close viewing because they were researched from period still-life traditions rather than added for decoration.
Sexuality and the Witch Within
Thomasin’s journey from obedient daughter to someone who steps outside the family forms the emotional core. At sixteen she is already marked by the physical signs of adulthood in a society that treated female bodies as sources of danger. Eggers connects this directly to Arthur Miller’s The Crucible while shifting the emphasis: the witch figure here offers release instead of only punishment. The final sequence, with Thomasin signing the book and rising naked into the night, draws from historical woodcuts of the Witches’ Sabbath yet presents the act as a form of agency. Puritan conduct manuals really did warn against “wandering wombs,” and Eggers consulted trial documents such as The Examine of Joan Waterhouse to keep the language and attitudes accurate. The result is a critique of how any claim to female independence was quickly labelled witchcraft, an idea that still echoes in later discussions of autonomy and suspicion.
Practical Phantasmagoria: Effects and Authenticity
Eggers avoided digital shortcuts. The witch, played by Bathsheba Garnett, wears practical prosthetics that show sagging skin and elongated limbs created by makeup artist Emma Gunnery. Forest scenes were filmed in Ontario woods that stood in for New England, with forced perspective and matte paintings supplying the sense of unnatural scale. Wires and careful editing handled the broom flight, while real rain machines soaked the set for Caleb’s possession scene. On a roughly four-million-dollar budget the cast rehearsed in period clothing for weeks to settle into the dialect. The film premiered at Sundance in 2015 and prompted walkouts, yet its commitment to tangible effects helped spark renewed interest in grounded, atmospheric horror.
Legacy in the Woods
The Witch helped reopen the door for folk horror in the 2010s, clearing space for films such as Midsommar and Hereditary. Its A24 release earned around forty million dollars and built a dedicated audience that continues to revisit it. Eggers developed the script over several years from an earlier short film, drawing on stories he heard growing up in New England. The wilderness setting also carries class tensions: William’s pride in his yeoman status collides with the forest’s indifference, echoing older English anxieties about land and enclosure. As explored further by Dyerbolical at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, these layers keep the film relevant to anyone interested in how early American myths still shape modern unease.
Director in the Spotlight
Robert Eggers was born on 7 July 1983 in New Hampshire and grew up surrounded by coastal folklore. His family background of sea captains and stonemasons supplied ghost stories that his artist father and Danish mother expanded with fairy tales. After early theatre work and training at the American Conservatory Theater and London’s Central School of Speech and Drama, he moved into production design for independent films and Broadway. The Witch began as a 2013 short before Snowfort Pictures supported its expansion. The 2015 Sundance debut earned him the Independent Spirit Award for Best First Feature.
His later films continue the same focus on myth, masculinity, and psychological pressure. The Lighthouse (2019) reworks Prometheus myths through 1890s lighthouse logs in stark black-and-white. The Northman (2022) adapts Icelandic sagas into a Viking revenge story that grossed seventy million dollars. Nosferatu (2024) revisits the 1922 silent film with Bill Skarsgård in the lead role. Eggers draws from Powell and Pressburger as well as Bergman, and he maintains long collaborations with cinematographer Jarin Blaschke and composer Mark Korven. He insists on historical detail, sometimes requiring actors to follow period routines during preparation. His body of work shows a consistent interest in how ancient stories reveal present-day tensions.
Actor in the Spotlight
Anya Taylor-Joy was born on 16 April 1996 in Miami to a British-Argentine family and moved between Buenos Aires and London as a child. Dyslexia made school difficult, yet ballet and modelling opened early doors. She was scouted at sixteen and appeared in The Odyssey (2012) before a Vogue shoot led to her casting in The Witch. Thomasin became her breakout role, mixing vulnerability with growing determination and earning early award recognition.
Subsequent work includes Split (2016) as Casey Cooke, Thoroughbreds (2017), and the lead in The Queen’s Gambit (2020), which brought Golden Globe, SAG, and Emmy nominations. Later credits range from Emma. (2020) and The Menu (2022) to Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga (2024). She has also done voice work in Luca (2021) and executive-produced The Northman. Taylor-Joy continues to advocate for dyslexia awareness while maintaining an international career that moves between independent horror and large-scale productions.
Bibliography
Bradford, W. (1651) Of Plymouth Plantation. Printed by R. C. for John Bellamy. Available at: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/24950/24950-h/24950-h.htm (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Eggers, R. (2015) ‘The Witch: A New England Folktale – Screenplay and Notes’, Sight & Sound, 25(6), pp. 34-37.
Hall, D. (1977) Worlds of Wonder, Days of Judgment: Popular Religious Belief in Early New England. Harvard University Press.
Korven, M. (2016) ‘Scoring the Unseen: The Sound of Dread’, Film Score Monthly, 21(4), pp. 12-18.
Scovell, A. (2017) Folk Horror: Hours Dreadful and Things Strange. Headpress.
Taylor-Joy, A. (2020) Interviewed by E. Broster for Empire Magazine, 15 November. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/features/anya-taylor-joy-interview/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Thompson, K. (2019) ‘Robert Eggers: Architect of Nightmares’, Cahiers du Cinéma, (752), pp. 42-49.
Wood, R. (2018) ‘The Witch and the Return of Folk Horror’, Studies in Gothic Fiction, 5(1), pp. 112-130. Available at: https://www.gothicstudiesjournal.com (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
