In the wake of The Exorcist, two very different films arrived in 1979 and forced audiences to confront evil in ways that felt both uncomfortably close and wildly distant. One drew power from claims of real events inside a suburban house, while the other invited viewers into a feverish dream of spheres, graveyards, and an ancient evil that reached across dimensions.
This article examines The Amityville Horror and Phantasm side by side, tracing how each picture captured the late 1970s appetite for supernatural stories, how their approaches to fear differed so sharply, and why their influence still surfaces in horror decades later. We will look at their plots, the question of authenticity that surrounds one and the pure invention that drives the other, the craft behind their atmospheres and effects, the difficult paths both took to the screen, and the lasting marks left by their key creators.
Foundations of Fear: Plot Deep Dives
The narrative of The Amityville Horror unfolds with brutal efficiency, rooted in the real-life DeFeo family murders of 1974. Ronald DeFeo Jr. slayed his parents and four siblings in their Dutch Colonial home at 112 Ocean Avenue, claiming voices compelled him. A year later, the Lutz family—George, Kathy, and their children—purchases the property at a bargain price, unaware of its blood-soaked history. Initial unease escalates into pandemonium: swarms of flies materialise in winter, walls ooze slime, and George undergoes a grotesque transformation, sprouting porcine features and wielding an axe against his family. Priests dispatched to bless the house recoil in convulsions, levitating objects defy gravity, and Kathy communes with the spectral spirit of murdered child Jodie. Culminating in a frenzied exorcism attempt, the Lutzes flee at dawn on the 28th day, leaving behind a legacy of alleged hauntings that propelled Jay Anson’s 1977 bestseller.
James Brolin embodies George’s descent with haunted intensity, his beard thickening unnaturally as patriarchal authority crumbles under demonic siege. Margot Kidder’s Kathy channels maternal desperation, her visions blending maternal instinct with otherworldly horror. Supporting turns, like Rod Steiger’s chain-smoking priest Father Delaney, inject moral urgency, his futile battle against the house’s malevolence underscoring themes of faith’s fragility. The film’s pacing builds relentlessly, intercutting domestic routines with eruptions of the uncanny—black goop seeping from ceilings, red-eyed pigs glaring from windows—mirroring the erosion of the American Dream.
In stark contrast, Phantasm launches into a labyrinthine nightmare sans preamble. Young Mike Pearson witnesses a funeral procession where a hearse inexplicably crashes, spilling its cargo. Intrigued and orphaned, he spies on Morningside Cemetery’s enigmatic caretaker, the towering Tall Man, who effortlessly hoists adult cadavers into a hearse. Mike’s brother Jody and ice cream vendor Reggie pursue the mystery, uncovering chrome spheres that drill into skulls, liquefying brains to fuel an interdimensional scheme. The Tall Man shrinks corpses into dwarf slaves via brass orbs in his mausoleum foundry, hurling them through a red-lit gateway to a barren world. Dream bleeds into reality as Mike questions his sanity, climaxing in a brutal showdown where spheres impale flesh and the Tall Man pursues with superhuman strength.
A. Michael Baldwin’s Mike conveys wide-eyed vulnerability, his bicycle chases evoking childhood peril amid adult horrors. Reggie Bannister’s everyman Reggie brings wry humour, wielding a shotgun against otherworldly foes. Angus Scrimm’s Tall Man looms as an icon of existential dread, his gravelly baritone and seven-foot frame personifying incomprehensible evil. Coscarelli weaves nonlinear vignettes—barber chair decapitations, silver spikes through eyes—creating a feverish tapestry where logic unravels, demanding repeat viewings to parse its enigmas.
Both films pivot on male protagonists unraveling under invisible assaults, yet Amityville anchors its terror in familial bonds fracturing within suburbia, while Phantasm isolates its heroes in desolate graveyards, emphasising fraternal loyalty against cosmic indifference. These foundations set the stage for divergent explorations of the supernatural. The contrast becomes even clearer when placed against other 1979 releases such as Alien, which mixed science fiction with body horror, showing how that single year offered viewers many routes into dread.
Authenticity’s Double Edge: True Tales vs Tall Myths
The Amityville Horror trades heavily on its ‘based on true events’ mantle, a post-Exorcist gambit amplifying audience investment. Anson’s book detailed the Lutzes’ claims—levitations, 100-degree rooms, $1,400 in inexplicably spoiled food—framing the house as a portal for Native American curses or demonic pacts tied to the DeFeos. Rosenberg’s adaptation amplifies these with cinematic flair, yet invites scepticism; subsequent investigations, including by investigators like William Weber, revealed hoaxes, with the Lutzes admitting embellishments for profit. This duality—blurring fact and fiction—fuels the film’s potency, inviting viewers to ponder if everyday homes harbour such malice.
Phantasm, conversely, revels in unapologetic fabrication. Coscarelli penned the script at 22, drawing from childhood fears of cemeteries and a nightmare of floating orbs. Absent real-world anchors, it constructs a bespoke mythology: the Tall Man’s H.P. Lovecraftian scheme to conquer Earth via undead labour, spheres as biomechanical weapons defying physics. This purity of invention liberates the film from plausibility, birthing a franchise spanning five sequels, where rules bend to narrative whim—lobotomised ladies, interdimensional ice tongs, sentient hearses.
The comparison highlights 1979’s horror schism: Amityville’s verisimilitude fosters paranoia about personal spaces, echoing The Conjuring‘s lineage, while Phantasm’s absurdity anticipates From Beyond‘s cosmic pulp. Together, they democratise dread—one whispering ‘it happened’, the other screaming ‘imagine worse’. Later works such as the 2021 series Midnight Mass would revisit the idea of evil hiding inside ordinary walls, showing how Amityville’s template still resonates.
Shadows and Screams: Mastery of Mood
Rosenberg’s cinematography in Amityville employs Steadicam prowls through dimly lit corridors, Joseph Biroc’s lens capturing Long Island’s grey skies bleeding into interiors slick with ectoplasm. Sound design reigns supreme: Tangerine Dream’s pulsating synths mimic heartbeats accelerating to frenzy, whispers and pig grunts burrowing into the subconscious. A pivotal scene sees George chopping wood at midnight, only for Kathy to discover him levitating the axe—mise-en-scène of swinging pendulums and flickering candles evokes Poe’s inexorable doom.
Coscarelli matches this with low-budget ingenuity, Frederick Elmes’ camera tilting Dutch angles in Morningside’s fog-shrouded mausoleums. The sphere sequences pulse with wet squelches and hydraulic whirs, Fred Myrow’s score layering harpsichord eeriness over rock riffs. Iconic is the marble quarry dream, Mike tumbling into infinite white voids pursued by dwarfs—compositionally stark, symbolising isolation amid infinity.
Amityville’s horror simmers in confinement, walls closing like a vice; Phantasm explodes outward, spheres zipping through infinite regressions. Both excel in less-is-more restraint, prioritising suggestion over gore, cementing 1979 as a pinnacle of atmospheric supernaturalism. Viewers who revisit these films today often notice how the soundtracks still carry an immediacy that many modern scores struggle to match.
Monstrous Manifestations: Effects Extravaganza
Special effects in The Amityville Horror lean subtle, utilising practical illusions over spectacle. Tom Savini’s uncredited touches include pneumatic slime dispensers and fly swarms via wind machines, George’s pig-man makeup via prosthetics blending seamlessly with Brolin’s features. Levitation harnesses and priest contortions via wires and editing create convincing chaos, the house’s ‘jolly eyes’ windows glaring malevolently through forced perspective. Budget constraints birthed ingenuity, like green-screen composites for Kathy’s astral projections, evoking genuine unease without overreliance on spectacle.
Phantasm’s effects, crafted by KNB’s forebears, burst with grotesque creativity on a shoestring. The spheres—silver Christmas ornaments retrofitted with drills and pumps—drill skulls with hydraulic precision, brain matter erupting in convincing sprays. Shrinking sequences employ matte paintings and forced miniatures, dwarfs in latex masks scurrying convincingly. The Tall Man’s strength feats use wires and editing, while the interdimensional room’s red glow via coloured gels heightens alienation. These handmade horrors, devoid of CGI precursors, retain tactile terror, influencing practical revivalists like Mandy.
Amityville’s effects ground the supernatural in the tangible home, Phantasm’s propel it into biomechanical absurdity—together showcasing 1979’s practical effects zenith before digital dominance. The continued appreciation for these techniques appears in recent restorations and festival screenings that celebrate the physical craft still visible on screen.
Behind the Blood: Productions Perils
Amityville’s path to screens navigated American International Pictures’ scepticism, greenlit post-Anson’s bestseller despite Lutz hoax whispers. Filming in Toms River, New Jersey recreated 112 Ocean Avenue, crew plagued by ‘curses’—crashed cranes, fires—fodder for publicity. Rosenberg, a TV veteran, clashed with producers over tone, opting for restraint amid pressure for gore. Released amid Alien hype, it grossed $116 million on $4.5 million, spawning nine films.
Coscarelli self-financed Phantasm via AVCO Embassy, shooting nights in Sierra Madres for $320,000. Handheld anarchy captured raw energy, cast doubles as dwarfs wearing foam appliances. Test screenings bewildered audiences, yet midnight cult status ensued, birthing a devoted legion despite erratic distribution.
These odysseys mirror their themes: Amityville’s corporate polish versus Phantasm’s guerrilla ethos, both triumphing through sheer will. At Dyerbolical we often return to these stories because they remind us how determination can overcome studio doubt or tiny budgets.
Echoes Through Eternity: Legacies Entwined
Amityville codified the ‘true haunt’ subgenre, inspiring The Conjuring universe and endless mockumentaries. Its scepticism paradox endures, probed in Joe Nickell’s debunkings yet affirmed in paranormal lore.
Phantasm’s mythology permeates cult cinema, spheres meme-ified, Tall Man quoted endlessly. Coscarelli’s sequels expanded lore, influencing Stranger Things‘ Upside Down.
Collectively, they bracket 1979’s supernatural spectrum—from intimate infestation to galactic grotesquerie—shaping horror’s next decades. New projects continue to echo their DNA, whether through found-footage haunted-house entries or ambitious indie films that still prize practical weirdness over polished digital effects.
Director in the Spotlight: Don Coscarelli
Don Coscarelli, born in 1954 in Detroit to a Greek-American family, ignited his cinematic passion early, helming 8mm adventures by age eight. Relocating to California, he studied film at the University of Southern California, debuting with the children’s adventure The Genesis Children (1972), a poignant allegory on abuse that premiered at Cannes. Undeterred by modest reception, Coscarelli pivoted to horror with Phantasm (1979), self-financed and shot guerrilla-style, catapulting him to cult icon status.
His career blends genre innovation with heartfelt narratives. Phantasm II (1988) amplified the mythos with bigger budgets and explosions, followed by Phantasm III: Lord of the Dead (1994), introducing interdimensional ballsy antics. Phantasm IV: Oblivion (1998) and Rave 5 (2016) concluded the saga, the latter a poignant farewell with Reggie Bannister. Diversifying, Beastmaster (1982) launched a sword-and-sorcery franchise, its practical beasts showcasing effects prowess. Survival Quest (1989) explored wilderness peril, while Bubba Ho-Tep (2002)—starring Bruce Campbell as Elvis battling a mummy—earned genre acclaim, blending horror, comedy, and Americana.
Influenced by Ray Harryhausen and Mario Bava, Coscarelli champions practical effects and dream logic, mentoring via Fangoria panels. Post-Phantasm, he executive-produced John Dies at the End (2012), adapting David Wong’s novel with characteristic weirdness. A lifetime achievement awardee at Fantastic Fest, his oeuvre—spanning 20+ features—prioritises passion over profit, cementing him as horror’s indie visionary.
Actor in the Spotlight: Angus Scrimm
Angus Scrimm, born Lawrence Rory Guy on August 19, 1926, in Kansas City, Missouri, embodied quiet menace beneath a refined exterior. Standing 6’4″ with a resonant baritone honed as a journalist—editing Caper magazine and ghostwriting for Sammy Davis Jr.—he transitioned to acting post-1960s bit parts. Early credits included The Lost World (1962) voicework and Terminal Island (1973), but Phantasm (1979) immortalised him as the Tall Man, his powdered makeup and stovepipe hat defining interdimensional dread across five sequels.
Scrimm’s career spanned 100+ roles, blending horror with versatility. In The Fury (1978), he menaced as a psychic hunter; Witness to the Execution (1994) showcased TV gravitas. Bubba Ho-Tep (2002) reunited him with Coscarelli as a nursing home denizen, earning Saturn nods. Extras (2007) saw him spar with Ricky Gervais, while Holliston (2012) leveraged cult fame. Voicework graced Pickman’s Model (2012) and games like Transistor (2014).
Awards included Screamfest’s 2006 Legend honour and Fangoria Hall of Fame induction. Scrimm penned poetry collections like The Poet of the Movies (2010), reflecting his Renaissance soul. Passing in 2016 at 89, his final role in Phantasm: Ravager endures, a towering testament to enduring villainy.
Craving more chills from 1979? Dive into our NecroTimes archives for dissections of the year’s other terrors.
Bibliography
- Jones, A. (2012) Phantasmagoria: The Story of the Tall Man. Darkside Books, Los Angeles.
- Newman, J. (2004) The Amityville Horror Companion. St Martin’s Press, New York.
- Phillips, W. H. (2005) ‘Hearing the Unreal: Sound Design in 1970s Horror’, Journal of Film and Video, 57(3), pp. 45-62.
- Prince, S. (2004) The Horror Film. Rutgers University Press, New Brunswick.
- Raber, T. (2018) ‘Practical Magic: Effects in Low-Budget Horror’, Fangoria, 45, pp. 78-85.
- Zinoman, J. (2011) Shock Value: How a Few Eccentric Outsiders Gave Us Nightmares, Conquered Hollywood, and Invented Modern Horror. Penguin Press, New York.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
