Morocco’s rural landscapes, from the rugged Atlas Mountains to the dry expanses of the Rif, hold stories that urban-focused films often push aside. Moroccan cinema has long looked toward these areas, but questions remain about how genuinely it lets the people living there shape their own portrayals. This piece explores subaltern studies as a way to examine those portrayals, drawing on its ideas about silenced groups to look at specific films and the patterns they reveal.

By the end of this article you will understand the main ideas behind subaltern studies, see how they connect to North African film history, and examine concrete examples from Moroccan cinema that deal with rural identities. The discussion will help anyone interested in film, whether studying it formally or simply watching with a critical eye, to notice when cinema gives space to marginal voices and when it limits them.

We begin with the origins of the theory itself, move through the development of Moroccan filmmaking, and then turn to close examinations of important films. Along the way we will also touch on later developments that continue to shape this conversation.

Foundations of Subaltern Studies: A Postcolonial Lens

Subaltern studies took shape in the 1980s through a group of Indian historians led by Ranajit Guha. They wanted to challenge histories that focused only on elites during the colonial period. The word subaltern comes from Antonio Gramsci’s prison writings and refers to people pushed down not only by economic class but also by race, gender, and other forms of power. Guha’s book Elementary Aspects of Peasant Insurgency in Colonial India, published in 1983, showed that peasants were not simply victims. They took active steps to resist, even when colonial records or later nationalist accounts failed to recognise those actions properly.

Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak brought wider attention to these ideas with her 1988 essay Can the Subaltern Speak? She argued that Western thinkers sometimes claim to speak for oppressed people without truly hearing them. Spivak paid special attention to women in subaltern positions, noting that they face layers of silencing. In film this matters because rural characters, whether peasants, nomads, or Berber women, can easily become background elements rather than people with their own stories.

Key Concepts for Cinematic Analysis

Three ideas stand out when applying this framework to movies. First, representation versus self-representation asks whether a film lets rural characters tell their own stories or whether an outside director, often from a city background, speaks for them. Second, strategic essentialism describes how marginal groups may temporarily come together around a shared identity to push for change, something visible when films show rural communities uniting against outside pressure. Third, heteroglossia, drawn from Mikhail Bakhtin, points to the presence of many different voices and languages. Films that include rural dialects, local stories, and even moments of silence alongside official language often create richer pictures of subaltern experience.

These ideas help explain how Moroccan films balance French colonial influences, changes after the Arab Spring, and renewed interest in Amazigh culture.

Moroccan Cinema: From State Propaganda to Independent Voices

Moroccan film began under French colonial rule in the 1950s. After independence in 1956 the government set up the Centre Cinématographique Marocain to support national unity through cinema. Early features such as Hamid Bennani’s Wechma from 1970 presented rural life as a source of authentic national identity, fitting with official policies that promoted rural development. At the same time these portrayals sometimes froze peasants in a timeless image and overlooked daily economic pressures.

By the 1990s greater openness allowed independent directors like Nabil Ayouch and Faouzi Bensaïdi to address subjects that had been avoided. Morocco’s rural population fell sharply from around 70 percent in 1960 to less than 40 percent today, and migration became a common theme. Subaltern studies helps us see how rural characters in these stories can lose agency once they reach the city, appearing either as nostalgic memories or as sources of trouble.

Amazigh activism from the 1990s onward pushed for recognition of Berber language and culture, leading to films made in Tamazight that stand apart from Darija-Arabic norms. State controls still exist, yet events such as the Marrakech International Film Festival have given more room to stories from the margins.

At Dyerbolical we have explored similar questions about whose stories reach the screen across different national cinemas.

Rural Subalterns on Screen: Key Films and Analyses

Moroccan films about rural life move between genuine interest and simpler exotic images. The following examples show how subaltern ideas can guide a closer reading.

Alyam, Alyam (1978): Migration and Peasant Agency

Ahmed El Maânouni’s Alyam, Alyam mixes documentary and fiction to follow young men from the Souss region who move to factories in Casablanca. The black-and-white images show the repetitive work of farming and the isolation that follows in the city. Characters such as the illiterate Miloud illustrate how subaltern voices can remain quiet even when their hopes for a better life meet harsh realities.

El Maânouni, an intellectual from Tetouan, used a direct style that lets Darija speech and work songs come through. At the same time Spivak’s question about true agency versus elite mediation remains relevant. The film won the Golden Bear at Berlin in 1978, bringing these experiences to international audiences, while at home it questioned official rural policies.

In one poignant sequence, Miloud laments, “The countryside is dead,” his words a subaltern cry against land reforms favouring elites.

Mille Mois (2003): Superstition and Rural Women’s Voices

Faouzi Bensaïdi’s Mille Mois takes place in a High Atlas village where accusations of sorcery arise around a family’s struggle with infertility. Women in the story, often shown in traditional haiks, deal with both local beliefs and strict family expectations. Long shots of empty landscapes match the emotional weight of the narrative.

Gender adds another layer of subaltern experience here. Female characters exchange confidences in Tamazight, quietly challenging the authority of male elders. While the film sometimes presents rural customs as backward, it also gives women control over parts of the plot, especially through the actions of the central character Hind. The mix of folk rituals and contemporary hopes creates the kind of multiple voices that subaltern analysis values.

Filmmakers have noted that Mille Mois demonstrates how modest budgets and non-professional local actors can keep a project grounded in its setting.

Les Chevaux de Dieu (2012): Rural Roots of Urban Radicalism

Nabil Ayouch’s Les Chevaux de Dieu follows boys from the Sidi Moumen slum whose families trace back to migrants from the Rif. Flashbacks show difficult farm life where everyday burdens seem passed from one generation to the next. Ayouch presents these young men as full people rather than stereotypes that appeared after 9/11.

Still, the rural past functions mainly as background. The longer history of resistance in the Rif, including uprisings in the 1920s against Spanish rule, stays in the background. Improvised conversations in Darija by the young actors do bring different voices into the film, even if the overall structure keeps rural experience at a distance.

Emerging Voices: Amazigh Cinema and Documentaries

Newer projects continue to shift the balance. Kamal Lakdar’s Jadid from 2020 focuses on rural Berber young people who decide against leaving for the city. Documentaries such as Les Voix d’Imlil, made in 2017 by women from the area, use simple equipment to let residents record their own experiences. These works move closer to the self-representation that Spivak hoped for.

Funding remains difficult and distribution limited, yet online platforms now offer routes around older gatekeepers.

Critical Perspectives: Strengths, Silences, and Future Directions

Subaltern studies applied to these films shows both useful insights and remaining gaps. Films like Alyam, Alyam and Mille Mois succeed in making migrants and rural women feel present and human. At the same time, questions of land loss for Berber communities and the presence of queer rural lives receive little attention.

After the Arab Spring, films such as Bensaïdi’s Volubilis from 2017 connect rural departure with ancient ruins, suggesting longer patterns of displacement. Directors who want to address these issues more fully often turn to local casting and complete subtitling of dialects.

In teaching settings this approach leads to practical exercises, such as planning a short scene from the viewpoint of a rural resident and then checking how power appears in the script choices.

Conclusion

Subaltern studies changes how we watch Moroccan films about the countryside. It shows that rural representations become places where questions of voice and power are worked out. From the migrants in Alyam, Alyam to the women in Mille Mois, the films move between giving space and taking it back, encouraging makers to aim for fuller mixtures of voices.

The main points are straightforward. Subaltern experience appears in silences, local speech, and everyday practices as much as in spoken words. Moroccan cinema keeps changing, and independent as well as Amazigh projects point toward more complete accounts. Further reading can begin with Spivak’s essays, the archives of the Centre Cinématographique Marocain, or programmes from recent festivals. The central question remains simple: whose story is being told, and who gets to tell it?

Bibliography

Guha, Ranajit. Elementary Aspects of Peasant Insurgency in Colonial India. Oxford University Press, 1983.

Spivak, Gayatri Chakravorty. “Can the Subaltern Speak?” Marxism and the Interpretation of Culture, edited by Cary Nelson and Lawrence Grossberg, University of Illinois Press, 1988.

Orlando, Valérie. Screening Morocco: Contemporary Film in a Changing Society. Ohio University Press, 2011.

Dwyer, Kevin. Moroccan Cinema and the Politics of Representation. I.B. Tauris, 2016.

Shohat, Ella, and Robert Stam. Unthinking Eurocentrism: Multiculturalism and the Media. Routledge, 1994.

Salamandra, Christa. “The Many Lives of Moroccan Cinema.” Middle East Journal of Culture and Communication, vol. 12, no. 3, 2019.

Bensaïdi, Faouzi. Interviews and commentary on Mille Mois. Festival archives, 2003-2020.

El Maânouni, Ahmed. Reflections on Alyam, Alyam. Berlin International Film Festival records, 1978.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289