Substack Journalism Explained: How Independent Reporters Are Rebuilding Media Through Direct Audience Connections
Picture a single writer sitting at a kitchen table, typing out a detailed investigation into how streaming platforms shape what films get made, then sending it straight to thousands of readers who chose to support that work. This scene captures a real shift happening in journalism today. Substack has become a key platform for solo reporters who want to work without the constraints of large media companies. The result is a fresh wave of independent voices, especially in areas like film criticism and media analysis, where thoughtful commentary can reach engaged readers directly.
This piece walks through the story of Substack journalism in clear steps. You will learn the background of traditional journalism’s changes, how the platform actually works, examples of writers who have succeeded with it, and practical ways to begin your own publication. By the end, the goal is to give you a grounded understanding of why this model matters for anyone studying or working in media and film, along with concrete ideas you can apply right away.
Whether your interest lies in examining blockbuster patterns, following smaller film events, or looking closely at how content reaches audiences, the platform offers a way for individual perspectives to find space. The question it raises is straightforward: can focused, independent reporting build a lasting place for itself in today’s media environment?
The Decline of Traditional Journalism and the Rise of Independents
Journalism’s stronger period in the middle of the twentieth century often featured reporters working on their own or in small teams, such as Woodward and Bernstein with their Watergate reporting that showed what sustained investigation could achieve. Newspapers and magazines at the time provided the time and support needed for careful research. From the 1990s forward, the move to digital publishing changed the economics. Free access to articles online reduced advertising income, which led companies to combine operations, reduce staff, and become more cautious in their editorial choices.
During the 2010s many established organisations moved toward shorter, shareable pieces to compete for attention. In film and media coverage this often meant fewer extended examinations and more quick reaction pieces. Staff reductions affected outlets including The Guardian and The New York Times, while some smaller publications closed. People trying to enter the field frequently found only short-term freelance work that paid very little.
Substack appeared in 2017, started by Chris Best, Jairaj Sethi, and Hamish McKenzie. It offered writers a simpler arrangement where they could keep ownership of their readers and receive payment straight from them. There were no layers of editors shaping every angle and no platform algorithms deciding visibility. This approach connected with ongoing conversations in media studies about who controls information and how authentic reporting can be maintained. The timing aligned with growing doubts about coverage during and after 2020, including questions around pandemic reporting.
Understanding Substack’s Model: A Primer for Media Creators
Substack functions mainly as an email newsletter service that includes tools for charging readers. Writers post articles, longer essays, audio, or video, and these reach people who have signed up. Free posts help draw an audience, while paid options, often around five to ten pounds a month, give access to extra material such as additional writing or question sessions.
The financial setup stays uncomplicated. Substack keeps ten percent of subscription money, and Stripe takes roughly three percent for handling payments, so creators receive about eighty-seven percent. There are no advertisements or sale of reader information. This setup differs from platforms that rely on advertising revenue shares or less transparent systems, which suits writing that needs room for careful media discussion rather than quick attention-grabbing content.
Key Features for Solo Reporters
Subscribers sign up with the writer rather than the platform, which reduces the risk that changes in algorithms will cut off access to readers. A dashboard shows how many people open posts and click links, giving writers data similar to tracking audience numbers for a film release. Audio features allow film reviews or recorded talks about media developments, and a notes section supports shorter updates that help keep readers involved in ongoing conversations.
Students working in film can see clear parallels with independent production. The entry point stays low, funding comes straight from interested readers in a way that resembles other direct-support models, and the writer keeps control over the direction of the work. All that is required to begin is a computer and a subject to explore.
The Solo Reporter Renaissance: Profiles in Independence
The platform has allowed some writers to reach substantial earnings and has given others a way to continue their work after leaving larger organisations. Bari Weiss left The New York Times in 2020, citing concerns about internal pressures, and developed a newsletter with around fifty thousand subscribers focused on culture and media topics. Matt Taibbi’s publication Racket examines issues within corporate media and has attracted roughly twenty thousand paid readers. In film and media spaces, writers such as Will Menaker combine political discussion with analysis of popular culture.
Film and Media Stars on Substack
Anne Helen Petersen runs Culture Study, a newsletter that examines celebrity culture, film audiences, and common ideas about media. With more than fifteen thousand paid subscribers, she writes essays that combine ideas from media theory with specific examples, such as the influence of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Working independently lets her choose topics like the final season of Succession without needing approval from others.
Jason Bailey, previously associated with FilmStage, moved toward longer pieces supported through Substack on topics like film restoration and directors who work outside the mainstream. He also writes about earlier independent critics, including Pauline Kael’s distinctive reviews for The New Yorker and how that approach continues today.
Heather Havrilesky’s Ask Polly has expanded into advice about media work, and film podcaster Alison Willmore uses the platform to share additional material connected to her Vulture contributions. These examples show one advantage of independent work: the ability to respond quickly. Established outlets may require months to publish a longer article, while writers on Substack can post regularly and develop a closer connection with readers.
Available figures indicate that leading writers can reach six-figure incomes. Substack reported three million paid subscriptions across more than twenty thousand publications by 2024, with particular growth in media-related topics at a time when surveys such as the Edelman Trust Barometer placed trust in journalism around fifty percent worldwide.
Practical Strategies: Launching Your Substack in Film and Media
Anyone ready to start should begin by identifying a focused area of knowledge. Film students might choose topics such as overlooked thrillers from the 1990s or close looks at how streaming services operate. The main steps involve deciding on a consistent approach to writing, publishing several free posts to build interest, sharing the newsletter on platforms like X, Letterboxd, or relevant Reddit communities, offering paid extras such as early festival reports or video discussions, and responding to reader comments to maintain engagement.
Additional tools can help, including embedding trailers from YouTube or using simple design programs for post headers. Checking the dashboard numbers each week allows adjustments, much like reviewing footage during editing.
Challenges and Pitfalls
Independent work brings its own demands. Writers must maintain discipline without the structure of a newsroom, and isolation can lead to fatigue over time. Finding new readers remains difficult because recommendation systems often favour established names. Some observers point out that subscription requirements can limit who sees the work, although many writers keep a portion of content free to address this.
From a media studies perspective, the model can reinforce existing viewpoints when writers operate without external review. At the same time, the open disclosure of funding sources can create a different kind of reliability that some readers find missing from larger organisations.
Broader Implications for Digital Media and Media Courses
The growth of Substack points to a change comparable to the introduction of accessible video editing software in the 1990s, which opened film production to more people. It supports a wider range of perspectives, including critics writing from regions outside the main industry centres or those offering analysis of representation in mainstream cinema. Media programmes have begun including material on creator-based economies that combine reporting skills with audience-building techniques.
Students focused on production can draw connections to direct distribution methods that bypass traditional gatekeepers, similar to independent films that reach viewers without festival premieres. Looking ahead, tools that assist with tasks like transcription may appear, yet the need for human judgment in shaping stories stays central. Further connections with video services could turn some writers into creators of mixed-format work. Writers outside the United States, such as George Monbiot in Britain addressing environmental topics or journalists in Australia covering local film production, show how the approach travels across borders.
At Dyerbolical we have seen similar patterns in how independent voices build audiences around specialised film topics, which aligns with the broader movement described here.
Conclusion
Substack journalism brings back elements of earlier reporting by giving writers control over their audience and income. The path from earlier industry changes to current examples shows how digital tools can open space for individual work. The main points include choosing a clear focus, building direct connections with readers, and adjusting based on feedback.
For continued learning, review Bari Weiss’s statements at the time of her launch, look at the platform’s lists of active publications, or begin a free test version yourself. Media courses that cover creator platforms provide useful background, and books such as Trust Me, I’m Lying by Ryan Holiday offer context on how attention works online. Reading established newsletters like Anne Helen Petersen’s can also show effective ways to organise longer pieces.
The opportunity is open: select a film, a pattern in media, or a story that has not received enough attention, and begin reporting on your own terms.
Bibliography
Edelman. (2024). Edelman Trust Barometer. Edelman.
Holiday, R. (2012). Trust Me, I’m Lying: Confessions of a Media Manipulator. Portfolio.
Petersen, A. H. (ongoing). Culture Study. Substack.
Substack. (2024). Company reports and subscription data. Substack Inc.
Taibbi, M. (ongoing). Racket. Substack.
Weiss, B. (2020). Launch statements and subsequent publications. The Free Press/Substack.
Woodward, B., & Bernstein, C. (1974). All the President’s Men. Simon & Schuster.
Bailey, J. (ongoing). Film-related Substack publication. Substack.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
