When an American dancer steps through the doors of a prestigious ballet academy in divided Berlin, she enters a world where movement itself becomes a conduit for ancient evil. This article explores the two versions of Suspiria, Dario Argento’s 1977 original and Luca Guadagnino’s 2018 remake, tracing how each film handles the same core story of a coven operating inside a dance school while revealing very different approaches to horror.

Forty-one years separate Dario Argento’s hallucinatory original from Luca Guadagnino’s brooding remake, yet both films pulse with the same dark heart: a coven of witches lurking beneath the elegance of a prestigious ballet school. This comparison dissects their divergences, pitting the 1977 film’s operatic style against the 2018 version’s psychological excavation, revealing how horror evolves from visceral spectacle to introspective dread.

Argento’s Suspiria crafts a sensory overload through lurid visuals and Goblin’s prog-rock score, prioritising aesthetic terror over coherent narrative. Guadagnino’s reinvention transforms the tale into a three-hour meditation on fascism, motherhood, and artistic ambition, embedding style within profound character studies. While the original influences generations of giallo and supernatural slashers, the remake challenges viewers to confront personal and historical traumas, reshaping the witch myth for modern anxieties.

The Coven’s Curse: Foundations of Fear

Suspiria begins with American dancer Susie Bannion arriving at the Tanz Akademie in 1970s Berlin, a rain-lashed edifice hiding ancient sorcery. Argento’s 1977 masterpiece unfolds in three acts: Susie witnesses a dancer’s grisly escape and murder, uncovers the matriarchal coven led by the imperious Mater Suspiriorum, and unleashes apocalyptic violence in a finale of collapsing architecture and impaled flesh. Jessica Harper embodies Susie with wide-eyed innocence turning to resolve, supported by a multinational cast including Alida Valli as the steely Frau Tanner and Udo Kier in a fleeting but memorable pathologist role. Goblin’s synthesisers wail over the chaos, while cinematographer Luciano Tovoli bathes scenes in saturated reds and greens, evoking a fairy tale twisted into nightmare.

Guadagnino expands this to a six-act epic set in 1977 divided Berlin, where Susie (Dakota Johnson) flees Ohio’s religious repression for the same academy. Here, the witches, headed by the ailing Helena Markos (Tilda Swinton under layers of prosthetics), vie for power amid psychokinetic dances that shatter bodies and psyches. Johnson’s Susie grapples with suppressed memories, her arc intertwined with Patricia (Chloë Grace Moretz), a rebel dancer seeking psychoanalytic truth from the sceptical Dr. Klemperer (another Swinton guise as Lutz Ebersdorf). The narrative swells with subplots of Nazi hauntings, maternal betrayals, and revolutionary undercurrents, culminating in a bloodbath that merges personal catharsis with coven annihilation.

Both films draw from Thomas De Quincey’s 1845 essay “Suspiria de Profundis”, invoking suspiria as sighs from the depths, but Argento treats it as poetic licence for stylistic frenzy, while Guadagnino literalises the psychological abyss. Shared motifs, the iris-in shots, the matrons’ scheming, the dance as ritual, anchor the comparison, yet divergences in runtime, tone, and intent highlight cinema’s capacity for reinvention. The choice to keep the setting in 1977 allows Guadagnino to tie the coven’s rituals to the political tensions of that era, something Argento left largely in the background.

Argento’s Palette of Peril: Visual Opulence Unleashed

Dario Argento wields colour as a weapon in the original, drenching Freiburg’s academy (doubling for Berlin) in primaries that assault the retina. The opening murder sees a dancer flee through rain-slicked streets, shadows elongating like claws under primary-hued gels; her killer’s razor-wire dispatch sprays crimson across pastel walls, a tableau vivant of giallo excess. Argento, master of the zoom and dolly, propels viewers through keyholes and vents, turning space into a labyrinth of subjective terror. This stylistic bravura, untethered from logic, why does no one notice the screams, prioritises dream logic over realism, aligning with Italian horror’s baroque traditions from Bava to Fulci.

Goblin’s score amplifies this: throbbing bass, operatic vocals, and Moog squelches form a rock opera that drowns dialogue, making sound a protagonist. Claudio Simonetti’s keyboards evoke witchcraft’s primal pulse, influencing scores from John Carpenter to modern synthwave revivalists. Argento’s camera, fluid yet precise, captures the academy’s impossible geometries, staircases that defy physics, rooms pulsing with unseen energy, crafting a house alive with malice, akin to the Overlook in Kubrick’s later adaptation of similar themes.

Effects pioneer Luigi Cozzi crafted practical gore with low-budget ingenuity: coathanger stabbings, maggot-infested ceilings, glass-shard pulverisation. These set pieces, visceral and unapologetic, shocked 1977 audiences, bypassing MPAA ratings for unrated infamy. Argento’s style, born of his giallo pedigree like The Bird with the Crystal Plumage, elevates horror to high artifice, where beauty and brutality entwine.

Guadagnino’s Murky Mirror: Psychological Layers Peeled

Luca Guadagnino mutes Argento’s fireworks for a desaturated palette, Sayombhu Mukdeeprom’s cinematography favouring earth tones and diffused light to evoke 1977’s political malaise. The academy looms in Berlin’s grim outskirts, its interiors cluttered with faded opulence, reflecting characters’ inner turmoils. Dances become psychosomatic rituals: limbs contort unnaturally, telekinesis flings bodies like ragdolls, symbolising suppressed rage. This reinvention shifts from supernatural spectacle to trauma’s slow bleed, with Susie’s repressed abuse mirroring Markos’s fascist ghosts.

Thom Yorke’s throbbing electronica replaces Goblin’s bombast, its whispers and glitches underscoring emotional fractures rather than propelling action. Tracks like “Suspirium” haunt with melancholy, contrasting the original’s adrenaline. Guadagnino’s three-hour sprawl allows character immersion: Johnson’s Susie evolves from naive ingénue to coven heir, her climactic levitation a rebirth through matricide. Moretz’s Patricia, riven by visions, seeks truth in therapy sessions that expose the witches’ Nazi ties, weaving historical reckonings into the supernatural.

Effects evolve to visceral realism: prosthetic contortions, hydraulic blood sprays, and a finale of flayed flesh via practical mastery from Mark Bridges. Yet gore serves psychology, Markos’s tumour-riddled form embodies decaying power, elevating body horror to metaphor, echoing Cronenberg’s somatic obsessions but grounded in European arthouse restraint.

Style Over Soul? Narrative and Character Clash

Argento’s Susie remains archetypal, her agency surfacing abruptly in the finale; supporting figures like Harper’s roommate Sarah exist for slaughter fodder, their arcs truncated by style’s demands. Narrative ellipses abound, who are the Three Mothers, prioritising mood over exposition. This purity thrills in short bursts but frustrates on revisit, as puzzles dissolve into pyrotechnics.

Guadagnino fleshes out psyches: Klemperer’s arc, haunted by his wife’s Holocaust survival, parallels Susie’s maternal void, culminating in mutual absolution amid apocalypse. Political subtext, Baader-Meinhof echoes, patriarchal collapse, enriches the witch myth, critiquing authoritarian maternities from fascism to cults. Johnson’s subtlety, Swinton’s transformative grotesquerie, outshine Harper’s earnestness, though the remake’s length tests patience.

Both probe female power: Argento’s witches revel in matriarchal dominance, their rituals erotic and empowering; Guadagnino complicates with victimhood cycles, Susie’s ascension bittersweet. Gender dynamics shift from campy villainy to nuanced trauma, reflecting #MeToo-era introspection. The remake’s willingness to linger on these questions gives it a different kind of staying power for viewers who want more than spectacle.

Gore and Grandeur: Effects in Evolution

Argento’s practical effects, rudimentary yet iconic, prioritise shock: the blind pianist’s impalement, bat swarms from ceilings. Cozzi’s ingenuity maximised limited budget, influencing Friday the 13th‘s splatter lineage.

Guadagnino blends CGI subtlety with prosthetics, Markos’s pulsating mass, dancers’ innard-spilling levitations, serving thematic weight over titillation. The climax’s mass flaying, a writhing tableau, evokes Midsommar‘s ritual excess but internalises horror.

This evolution marks horror’s maturation: from 1970s sensation to 2010s cerebration, style yielding to substance without sacrificing impact. Later films such as The Witch and Hereditary owe something to the way Guadagnino let dread build through character rather than constant visual assault.

Echoes Through Eternity: Legacy Compared

Argento’s film birthed the Three Mothers trilogy, inspired Inferno and Mother of Tears, permeating pop culture via references in Chucky and Scream. Its style sculpted 1980s horror aesthetics.

Guadagnino’s divides fans, praised at Venice, divisive commercially, but extends influence into prestige horror like The Witch, prioritising depth. Sequels loom, yet its Berlin Wall metaphor endures amid resurgent nationalisms.

Together, they bracket horror’s spectrum: visceral thrill to intellectual haunt, proving remakes can transcend homage. At Dyerbolical we often return to these two films because they show how the same premise can speak to entirely different eras of fear.

Director in the Spotlight

Dario Argento, born in Rome on 7 September 1940 to producer Salvatore Argento and actress Maria Nicoli, immersed in cinema from childhood. Rejecting university for film journalism at Paese Sera, he scripted Sergio Leone’s Once Upon a Time in the West (1968) and Bernardo Bertolucci’s Partner (1968), honing narrative craft. Directing debut The Bird with the Crystal Plumage (1970) ignited giallo, blending thriller tropes with baroque visuals.

Argento’s oeuvre spans giallo masterpieces: The Cat o’ Nine Tails (1971), a procedural whodunit; Four Flies on Grey Velvet (1972), concluding the Animal Trilogy with psychedelic flair. Supernatural pivot yielded Deep Red (1975), his pinnacle, blending mystery and psychokinesis. The Three Mothers trilogy followed: Suspiria (1977), Inferno (1980), and The Mother of Tears (2007). Later works like Tenebrae (1982), Opera (1987), and The Stendhal Syndrome (1996) explored obsession and voyeurism.

Influenced by Hitchcock, Cocteau, and Mario Bava, Argento championed female protagonists and dollies through architecture. Collaborations with Goblin, daughter Asia Argento (directing The Heart Is Deceitful Above All Things, 2004), and wife Daria Nicolodi shaped his worlds. Post-2000 output slowed, Card Player (2004), Giallo (2009), Dracula 3D (2012), amid health woes, but documentaries like Argento’s Dracula affirm legacy. A cinephile icon, his style reshaped horror globally.

Comprehensive filmography: The Bird with the Crystal Plumage (1970, giallo debut); The Cat o’ Nine Tails (1971); Four Flies on Grey Velvet (1972); Deep Red (1975); Suspiria (1977); Inferno (1980); Tenebrae (1982); Phenomena (1985); Opera (1987); The Stendhal Syndrome (1996); The Phantom of the Opera (1998); Non ho sonno (2001); The Card Player (2004); Do You Like Hitchcock? (2005); Mother of Tears (2007); Giallo (2009); Dracula 3D (2012); Occhiali neri (2022).

Actor in the Spotlight

Tilda Swinton, born Katherine Matilda Swinton on 5 November 1960 in London to Australian-born John Swinton and Scottish Judith Killen, grew up in a military family across England and Scotland. Studying Social and Political Sciences at Cambridge (1976-1983), she immersed in experimental theatre with the Traverse Theatre Group, debuting in Man to Man (1983). Sally Potter’s Orlando (1992) launched her film career, earning Venice Best Actress for her gender-fluid immortal.

Swinton’s chameleon versatility shone in arthouse: Derek Jarman’s Caravaggio (1986), Edward II (1991); she co-founded Meltdown Festival. Hollywood beckoned with Michael Clayton (2007, Oscar/Bafta win), yet indies defined her, Wes Anderson’s Moonrise Kingdom (2012), Bong Joon-ho’s Snowpiercer (2013), Okja (2017). Blockbusters included Doctor Strange (2016, Ancient One), voicing in Jim Henson’s The Storyteller (1988).

In Suspiria (2018), Swinton’s triple-threat, Madame Blanc, Helena Markos, Dr. Klemperer, earned acclaim, her prosthetics and accents dissolving self. Influences span Bowie to Wittgenstein; activist for refugees, she supports queer cinema. BAFTA Fellow (2023), her oeuvre defies genre.

Key filmography: Caravaggio (1986); Orlando (1992); Vanilla Sky (2001); Adaptation. (2002); Constantine (2005); Michael Clayton (2007); Burn After Reading (2008); We Need to Talk About Kevin (2011); Only Lovers Left Alive (2013); Snowpiercer (2013); Grand Budapest Hotel (2014); A Bigger Splash (2015); Doctor Strange (2016); Suspiria (2018); The French Dispatch (2021); Dead Man Walking (2023 TV).

Bibliography

Argento, D. (2009) Los ojos y las palabras: Dario Argento, el terror y yo. T&B Editores.

Gallant, J. (2000) Art of Darkness: Paging Through the Past in a Giallo Dreamscape. Fab Press.

McDonagh, M. (1984) Broken Mirrors/Broken Minds: The Dark Dreams of Dario Argento. Sun Tavern Fields.

Newman, K. (2018) ‘Suspiria: Luca Guadagnino interview’, Empire Magazine, 25 October. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/features/suspiria-luca-guadagnino-interview/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Schlegel, H. (2017) ‘The Radical Conservatism of Dario Argento’s Suspiria’, Senses of Cinema, 84. Available at: https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2017/feature-articles/suspiria-dario-argento/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Swinton, T. (2018) ‘Tilda Swinton on Suspiria’, The Guardian, 2 November. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2018/nov/02/tilda-swinton-suspiria-luca-guadagnino (Accessed: 15 October 2023).

Towlson, J. (2013) Suspiria. Devil’s Advocates, Auteur Publishing.

Argento, A. (2022) Occhiali neri. Film movement and international distribution notes.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289