In the quiet moments before the first candle gutters out in a Puritan farmhouse, before a miniature house reveals its secrets in the dead of night, and before two men begin to circle each other like trapped animals on a storm-lashed rock, something ancient stirs. These three A24 films do not simply scare. They pull viewers into spaces where personal loss collides with forces far older than any single life, and they ask what remains when every familiar structure collapses.
This article examines Robert Eggers’ The Witch (2015) and The Lighthouse (2019) alongside Ari Aster’s Hereditary (2018). It explores how each picture builds its atmosphere from historical detail and raw emotion, how they share themes of isolation and inheritance, and how their craft continues to shape conversations about horror long after the credits roll. Along the way it considers the directors’ methods, the performances that anchor the terror, and the wider influence these works have exerted on the genre.
Puritan Shadows: The Witch’s Slow Unravelling
The narrative of The Witch unfolds in 1630s New England, where William (Ralph Ineson) and his devout family face exile from their plantation for ideological defiance. Settling at the edge of a foreboding wood, they subsist on pride and prayer until calamity strikes: their infant son Samuel vanishes while under the watch of eldest daughter Thomasin (Anya Taylor-Joy). What follows is a meticulously paced descent, as crops fail, twins Mercy and Jonas succumb to eerie songs, and father William’s patriarchal authority crumbles under accusations of witchcraft.
Eggers drew from primary sources like trial transcripts and diaries to build a world where the supernatural arrives not as spectacle but as insidious doubt. Thomasin’s arc from dutiful daughter to suspected witch mirrors the era’s misogynistic hysterias, her body becoming both battleground and site of uneasy liberation. The Black Phillip, that towering goat embodying satanic temptation, whispers promises of butter and finery, seducing with earthly delights forbidden by Puritan rigour. The film’s climax, a ritualistic profession of faith twisted into infernal pact, leaves audiences questioning agency amid predestination.
Mise-en-scène amplifies this tension. Stark, desaturated palettes evoke period authenticity, while the wood’s encroaching darkness symbolises repressed desires. Lighting, often natural and flickering, casts elongated shadows that blur human forms into the demonic. Eggers’ commitment to historical linguistics, with dialogue pulled verbatim from 17th-century texts, immerses viewers in alienation and makes every prayer feel like a possible curse. The result is a film that resists easy supernatural labels and instead probes religious fanaticism’s self-fulfilling prophecies, where fear manifests the feared. Its restraint helped set the tone for the slow-burn horror wave that followed.
Grief’s Demonic Inheritance: Hereditary’s Familial Rupture
Hereditary centres on the Graham family, shattered by matriarch Ellen’s death. Annie (Toni Collette), a miniaturist crafting dollhouse replicas of trauma, navigates her mother’s occult legacy alongside husband Steve (Gabriel Byrne), son Peter (Alex Wolff), and daughter Charlie (Milly Shapiro). Charlie’s decapitation in a freak accident unleashes a grief so visceral it fractures reality, revealing Paimon, a kingly demon craving male hosts, as the architect of their doom.
Aster weaves inheritance literally and figuratively. Ellen’s cultish manipulations echo through generations, with Annie’s sleepwalking seances and Peter’s possession culminating in a basement ritual of decapitation and coronation. The film’s power lies in its granular depiction of mourning. Annie’s dioramas evolve from art to omen, symbolising futile attempts at control over chaos. Charlie’s tongue-clicking tic and allergic shock presage the horror, blending mundane tragedy with mounting unease. Cinematography by Pawel Pogorzelski employs extreme close-ups to trap viewers in familial tension, while Dutch angles warp domestic spaces into labyrinths. The slow zoom on Charlie’s floating crown in the treehouse coda lingers as one of horror’s most haunting images, evoking inevitable doom. Aster’s script, informed by his own losses, transforms personal catharsis into universal terror, where therapy fails against inherited maledictions. Unlike slashers, Hereditary weaponises silence and ritual, its third act erupting in violence that feels earned through prior restraint.
Stormbound Madness: The Lighthouse’s Monochrome Descent
Set in 1890s New England, The Lighthouse traps senior lighthouse keeper Thomas Wake (Willem Dafoe) and junior Ephraim Winslow (Robert Pattinson) on a remote islet. As storms rage, their duties, polishing the lens and tending the wick, devolve into ritualistic power struggles fuelled by Wake’s tall tales of sea mermaids and Proteus, and Winslow’s suppressed identity as murderer Thomas Howard.
Eggers shot in black-and-white 35mm, with aspect ratios shifting from 1.19:1 to 2.39:1 to mimic early cinema and heighten claustrophobia. The phallic lighthouse becomes obsession’s apex, its beam a forbidden siren call. Hallucinations proliferate: Winslow masturbates to a carved mermaid figurine, battles gulls as reincarnated souls, and imbibes Wake’s Lovecraftian phantasmagoria, culminating in a Neptune trident duel atop the tower. Dialogue, laced with 19th-century sailor jargon sourced from logs, crackles with homoerotic tension and Oedipal rivalry. Dafoe’s booming monologues invoke sea gods, blending Greek myth with New England folklore. The film’s circular structure, opening and closing with Winslow’s arrival and departure, suggests eternal recurrence and traps souls in Sisyphean labour. Practical effects ground the surreal, from real storms to period props, and the picture probes masculinity’s fragility, where isolation strips civilised veneers to reveal primal savagery.
Threads of Isolation: Shared Catalysts of Collapse
All three films hinge on isolation as horror’s engine. In The Witch the wood’s perimeter delineates faith’s frontier. Hereditary’s suburb feels besieged by intangible inheritance. The Lighthouse’s rock is absolute confinement. This quarantine amplifies internal fractures, familial in the first two pictures and fraternal in the third, forcing confrontations with suppressed truths. Patriarchy unites them as well. William’s failed husbandry mirrors Wake’s tyrannical mentorship and the Grahams’ absent father figures, supplanted by demonic patriarchy in the forms of Satan, Paimon, and Neptune. Women, marginalised yet pivotal, wield subversive power through Thomasin’s pact, Annie’s rage, and the mermaid’s allure, subverting male dominance. Cosmic indifference permeates each story. The Puritan God abandons, Paimon manipulates from afar, and sea gods mock human hubris. These entities embody an uncaring vastness that dwarfs individual striving, a sensibility filtered through personal lenses yet reminiscent of Lovecraftian nihilism. Grief as contagion binds The Witch and Hereditary, with Samuel’s loss echoing Charlie’s, while The Lighthouse grieves lost identity. Each film posits mourning as a portal to the otherworldly, where rituals invite invasion.
Symphonies of Dread: Sound and Visual Alchemy
Sound design elevates all three works. The Witch’s Mark Korven score uses medieval strings and throat singing for dissonant unease. Hereditary employs clattering miniatures and shrill shrieks. The Lighthouse drowns in foghorns and crashing waves, its 1920s-inspired score by Korven again pulsing like a heartbeat. These aural landscapes internalise terror and make silence portentous. Visually, Eggers favours tableaux vivants, frozen family portraits in The Witch and Winslow’s gull-strangled stare, while Aster opts for kinetic horror, Peter’s car crash a blur of motion sickness. Black-and-white in The Lighthouse desaturates emotion and heightens madness’s monochrome grip. Practical effects shine throughout: The Witch’s goat prosthetics, Hereditary’s headless corpse rig, and The Lighthouse’s storm tank immersions. No CGI shortcuts appear. Tactility grounds the ethereal and proves that elevated horror relies on sensory precision rather than spectacle.
Performances that Scar: Human Frailties Exposed
Toni Collette’s Annie oscillates from restrained sorrow to hammer-wielding fury, her seance convulsions a tour de force of physicality. Anya Taylor-Joy’s Thomasin blooms from innocence to empowered witch, eyes widening in revelation. Pattinson and Dafoe spar vocally, their lobster rolls and farts belying tragic depths, Pattinson’s feral unravel and Dafoe’s bombastic pathos. Supporting casts amplify the effect: Milly Shapiro’s eerie Charlie and Ralph Ineson’s stoic crumble. These turns anchor abstraction in raw humanity and make cosmic threats feel intimate. Collette’s explosive grief contrasts Eggers’ restrained naturalism, yet all three productions prioritise authenticity over histrionics.
Enduring Echoes: Legacy in Elevated Horror
A24’s trifecta catalysed the wave often called elevated horror, spawning Midsommar and Saint Maud. The Witch revived folk horror, Hereditary mainstreamed grief-centred narratives, and The Lighthouse championed experimental formalism. Remakes and homages continue to appear, yet the originals’ potency endures. Culturally they interrogate American anxieties, Puritan legacies, suburban facades, and labour alienation, themes that resonate strongly in the years following the pandemic. At Dyerbolical we have long argued that these films chart horror’s maturation by blending arthouse rigour with visceral impact, and no single picture emerges as victor when placed side by side.
Director in the Spotlight: Robert Eggers
Robert Eggers, born in 1983 in New Hampshire, immersed himself in theatre from youth and apprenticed at avant-garde venues before moving into film. A production designer on shorts, his feature debut The Witch stunned audiences at Sundance and earned acclaim for historical fidelity sourced from Essex County archives. Influences span Dreyer, Bresson, and Lovecraft, evident in his period obsessiveness. The Lighthouse followed in 2019, earning Cannes accolades for Dafoe. The Northman in 2022 delivered a Viking saga starring Nicole Kidman and Alexander Skarsgård, blending Shakespearean echoes with Norse sagas. Nosferatu arrived in 2024 as a reimagining of Herzog’s version, again starring Dafoe. Eggers’ oeuvre champions authenticity through linguistic research and practical builds, prioritising atmosphere over plot. Collaborations with cinematographer Jarin Blaschke yield painterly frames, and his private personal life has not stopped him from championing female stories within male-centric worlds.
Actor in the Spotlight: Toni Collette
Toni Collette, born in 1972 in Sydney, Australia, began in theatre and debuted on film in Spotswood in 1991. Her breakthrough in Muriel’s Wedding in 1994 showcased comedic range and earned an AFI nomination. Hollywood ascent arrived with The Sixth Sense in 1999 as a haunted mother, bringing an Oscar nomination. Hereditary cemented her horror icon status. Versatile across drama in The Boys Don’t Cry, musicals in Velvet Goldmine, and thrillers in The Turning, she also triumphed on television in The United States of Tara, winning an Emmy. Recent credits include Dream Horse, Nightmare Alley as a cunning carnival figure, and the miniseries The Staircase. Awards encompass a Golden Globe for Tara, multiple Emmy nominations, and an AACTA lifetime honour. Mother of two and an advocate for mental health, Collette’s chameleon prowess continues to define her legacy across genres.
Bibliography
Eggers, R. (2016) ‘The Witch: A New England Folktale – Director’s Interview’, Criterion Collection. Available at: https://www.criterion.com/current/posts/408-the-witch-a-new-england-folktale-a-conversation-with-robert-eggers (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Aster, A. (2018) ‘Grief and Demons: Making Hereditary’, IndieWire. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com/2018/06/hereditary-ari-aster-interview-grief-horror-1201973456/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Knee, M. (2016) ‘The Haunting Authenticity of The Witch’, Sight & Sound, 26(3), pp. 42-45.
Bradshaw, P. (2019) ‘The Lighthouse Review: Monochrome Madness’, The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/oct/31/the-lighthouse-review-robert-eggers-willem-dafoe-robert-pattinson (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Jones, A. (2020) Elevated Horror: A24 and the New Wave. New York: Bloomsbury Academic.
Harper, S. (2017) ‘Folk Horror Revival: The Witch and British Traditions’, Eye for Film. Available at: https://www.eyeforfilm.co.uk/feature/2017-03-15-the-witch-and-folk-horror-feature (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Sharf, Z. (2022) ‘How The Northman Extends Eggers’ Mythic Obsessions’, IndieWire. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com/2022/04/the-northman-robert-eggers-interview-1234712345/ (Accessed: 12 November 2024).
Macnab, G. (2024) ‘Nosferatu and the Return of Gothic Ritual’, Sight & Sound, 34(1), pp. 18-22.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
