The night air in New Orleans hung heavy with humidity and the faint notes of emerging jazz when the first brutal strikes fell in 1918. Families above corner groceries woke to the sound of an axe blade meeting flesh, and a city already strained by war and disease found itself facing something far more personal and unpredictable.

This article examines the series of axe attacks that struck Italian immigrant households between 1918 and 1919, the investigation that followed, the killer’s strange letter to the press, and the lasting questions that remain. We look at the facts as they stand, the social pressures of the time, and why this case still matters to anyone studying how serial violence takes shape in crowded urban neighborhoods.

Historical Context: New Orleans in the World War I Era

New Orleans in 1918 stood as a crowded port city where cultures mixed on narrow streets lined with wooden storefronts. Italian immigrants, many from Sicily, had opened small groceries that served working families, yet they also carried the weight of earlier prejudice. The 1891 lynching of eleven Italians in the city had left scars that lingered, and wartime shortages plus the Spanish flu only tightened nerves further.

These shopkeepers lived above their stores, often with doors that neighbors might recognize. An intruder who knew the layout could enter quietly, and that is exactly what happened in case after case. The choice of victims, mostly Italian grocers, points to a mix of opportunity and possible resentment, though no single motive ever surfaced clearly enough to close the file.

The Reign of Terror: A Chronology of Attacks

The first confirmed attack came on May 23, 1918. Joseph Maggio, thirty-three, and his wife Catherine, thirty-seven, were found in their flat above the grocery at 1028 Upperline Street. Joseph had been struck repeatedly on the head, and Catherine died from a deep cut to the throat after similar blows. A bloodied axe rested in the yard, and a panel had been cut from the back door with a chisel. Those two details would mark nearly every scene that followed.

Escalation Through 1918

Weeks later, on June 5, grocer Louis Besumer and his companion Harriet Anna Lowe were attacked at 624 Chartres Street. Lowe died from her injuries while Besumer survived, though his own account and later insurance questions kept police circling back to him for months. On June 27 an elderly widow named Mrs. Schneider faced the same intruder at her Rampart Street store and lived to describe a tall figure moving through the dark.

August 5 brought the Cortimiglia family tragedy at 716 Maestri Street. Charles Cortimiglia escaped harm, but his wife Rosie and their two-year-old daughter Mary were killed. Rosie reportedly called out to her husband in her final moments. September added two more survivors, John Zanca and Edward Schneider, both struck at their stores yet able to recover. The pattern of minimal theft and precise entry suggested the killer wanted something beyond money.

1919: Peak and Promise

The new year opened with the death of grocer Omer Takenhoff on January 6. In May, Anthony Badessa was killed in similar fashion. The last confirmed killing occurred on October 27 when Mike Pepitone, thirty-nine, was murdered in his flat on Corrado Street. His wife and children survived but carried the memory for life. Across twelve documented incidents at least six people died, and some researchers still debate whether earlier or later unsolved cases belong to the same hand.

The Infamous Letter: A Killer’s Taunt

On August 15, 1919 the New Orleans Times-Picayune printed a letter signed simply “The Axeman.” Written in rough language and dated from “Hell,” it claimed the writer was no ordinary man but a spirit immune to bullets. The most unsettling passage promised that on the following Tuesday night the killer would pass over the city every four hours, and that any home playing jazz would be left untouched.

New Orleans responded with music pouring from windows, phonographs, and street corners. No attack occurred that night, and the public took the letter’s accuracy as proof the writer knew the case intimately. The move turned local fear into national news and gave the killer a platform that later murderers would copy.

They have never dreamed of it because I am what you Orleanians and your foolish police call the Axeman… I am not a human being, but a spirit and a demon from the hottest hell.

Investigation: Leads, Suspects, and Frustrations

Police Superintendent Frank T. Cannizzaro and Coroner Sylvestre J. Precautions worked with limited tools. Fingerprints were still new, and the city force was stretched thin by other crises. Canvassing Italian neighborhoods produced only vague descriptions of a tall, dark-haired man. Samuel “The Butcher” Caruso was picked up on a tip and released. Louis Besumer faced trial over insurance matters and an affair but was acquitted. In 1919 widow Rosie Cortimiglia identified Joseph Mumfre as her attacker while he sat in prison; she later shot him dead in 1921, yet the evidence never rose above circumstance.

Theories ranged from Mafia enforcement to anti-immigrant vigilantism to simple robbery gone wrong. None produced enough proof to satisfy a courtroom, and when the attacks stopped the case simply faded from daily headlines.

Psychological Analysis: Profiling the Axeman

Viewed through today’s behavioral lens the attacks show both planning and impulse. The repeated chisel entry and axe choice point to someone comfortable inside these homes, perhaps a local figure who knew which doors stayed unlocked. The letter reveals a need for attention and control that goes beyond profit. Modern geographic profiles would place the offender inside a tight radius of the strikes, most likely a resident who could move without drawing notice.

Survivors and witnesses described little stolen property, which separates these crimes from ordinary theft. The focus on Italian households may reflect personal grievance or broader resentment, though the record leaves that question open. The case sits between the disorganized violence of sudden rage and the organized cunning needed to avoid capture for more than a year.

Legacy: Echoes in Culture and Criminology

The Axeman story has traveled through books such as Miriam C. Davis’s account, documentaries, and novels that explore the city’s jazz-era shadows. Bands have written songs around the legend, and New Orleans still holds occasional nights of music tied to the old promise. Criminologists note how the case foreshadowed later killers who sought publicity, from coded letters to public taunts.

At the same time the attacks exposed real fractures: immigrant families living on the edge of acceptance, a police department lacking modern resources, and a press that both informed and inflamed. Forensic advances since then, from DNA to digital mapping, make it tempting to ask what might be solved today, yet the original evidence has long since scattered.

At Dyerbolical we return to cases like this because they remind us that unsolved violence leaves families waiting for answers that never arrive. The victims, from the Maggios to the Pepitones, were ordinary people trying to build lives in a difficult city. Their stories deserve the same careful attention we give to any later tragedy.

Bibliography

Miriam C. Davis, The Axeman of New Orleans: The True Story of a Serial Killer (2017).

New Orleans Times-Picayune archives, 1918-1919 editions.

Robert Tallant, Ready to Hang: Seven Famous New Orleans Murders (1952).

FBI records on early serial offender patterns, Behavioral Analysis Unit historical notes.

City of New Orleans police reports and coroner files, 1918-1921.

Articles from the New Orleans Historical Society on Italian immigrant communities.

Contemporary newspaper coverage in the New York Times and Chicago Tribune, 1919.

Academic papers on media influence in early 20th-century crime reporting.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289