Picture the scene inside a Florida courtroom in 1979. Ted Bundy sits at the defense table, flashing that familiar smile, while a cluster of young women in the gallery hold up signs and exchange giggles. They have come not for answers or closure but because something about the man on trial for a string of brutal murders has pulled them in. That moment, unsettling even then, has grown into something far larger and more organized over the decades.
This article looks at how those early courtroom followers evolved into today’s sprawling online communities that treat certain killers like celebrities. We will trace the roots of this behavior, examine the platforms that now sustain it, explore the psychology involved, and consider what it means for victims and their families. Along the way we will also touch on how legitimate interest in true crime can slip into something more troubling when the focus shifts from justice to admiration.
At Dyerbolical we have spent considerable time examining these patterns because they reveal uncomfortable truths about how society processes violence and celebrity. The line between curiosity and celebration is thinner than many people realize, and it is worth understanding where that line gets crossed.
Historical Roots of Killer Fandom
The pull toward notorious criminals stretches back well before the internet. In earlier centuries, public executions drew crowds who treated the events like entertainment. That same impulse reappeared in the twentieth century when certain high-profile defendants captured attention not for their crimes but for their personalities. Ted Bundy’s trials became a clear example. Women wrote him letters, proposed marriage, and one even had his child while he remained on death row. His articulate manner and conventional good looks turned courtroom proceedings into something closer to a spectacle, with reporters at the time noting how his supporters sometimes disrupted the process.
Charles Manson followed a similar path. Long before and long after the 1969 murders of Sharon Tate and the others, he attracted people who saw him as a figure of rebellion rather than a convicted killer. Letters and visits continued even after his imprisonment. These cases established a pattern: when a killer appeared intelligent or defiant, some observers began to project their own ideas onto him, shifting attention away from the lives that had been destroyed.
Early Media’s Role
Tabloid coverage played a significant part in shaping these perceptions. Stories often emphasized the killer’s background or quirks instead of the victims’ experiences. During the Son of Sam shootings in the 1970s, headlines sometimes portrayed David Berkowitz as a tormented loner, which encouraged sympathetic letters from strangers. The same dynamic appeared with John Wayne Gacy, whose public persona as a clown overshadowed the reality of the thirty-three young men he murdered. One of those victims, Robert Piest, became little more than a footnote in the larger story that focused on the killer’s double life.
These early patterns matter because they show how media framing can quietly steer public attention. When the narrative lingers on the perpetrator’s charm or supposed complexity, the human cost of the crimes recedes into the background.
The Digital Explosion: Online Fan Communities
The arrival of social media turned scattered interest into something far more connected and visible. Platforms such as Tumblr, Reddit, and later TikTok allowed people to gather around shared fascination with specific cases. In the 2010s, certain Tumblr blogs began posting stylized images of killers alongside poetry or aesthetic edits. Richard Ramirez, who killed thirteen people in Los Angeles in 1985, became one of the figures treated this way. Fans created online shrines and sometimes defended his actions by pointing to his difficult upbringing.
After the 2022 Netflix series about Jeffrey Dahmer, interest in fan fiction and sympathetic readings of his life increased noticeably. Private Discord servers and Facebook groups now trade letters from inmates as if they were collectibles. Short videos on TikTok sometimes present killers in softened terms, with captions suggesting they simply needed affection or understanding. These spaces create a sense of community, yet many of them explicitly discourage any extended discussion of the victims.
Key Platforms and Examples
Different platforms have hosted these communities in distinct ways. Tumblr’s pre-2018 environment allowed extensive aesthetic treatments of cases like that of the Golden State Killer. Reddit threads in certain true-crime forums sometimes emphasize a killer’s charisma or intelligence over the details of the crimes themselves. Instagram and TikTok have seen hashtags that frame figures like Ted Bundy in romanticized terms, occasionally leading users to cosplay or create lighthearted content. Dedicated sites have even offered ways for admirers to write to prisoners directly.
These environments can reinforce one another. When one platform limits certain content, activity often migrates elsewhere, keeping the same underlying focus on the perpetrator rather than the people harmed.
Case Studies: Killers with Devoted Followings
Ted Bundy and the Charisma Myth
Bundy’s admirers remain active long after his 1989 execution. Online pages continue to circulate trial footage that highlights his education and courtroom demeanor. Carole Ann Boone, who married him during proceedings, represents one extreme of this attraction. Meanwhile, victims such as Georgann Hawkins receive far less attention in these circles, their stories reduced to brief mentions amid ongoing discussion of the killer’s life.
Richard Ramirez: The Night Stalker’s Rock Star Status
At Ramirez’s 1989 sentencing, some supporters chanted slogans in his favor. Today, merchandise bearing his image appears on various marketplaces. Defenses often center on his childhood hardships while giving limited space to victims such as Jennie Vincow, whose murder began the series of attacks attributed to him.
Modern Icons: Dylann Roof and Elliot Rodger
The pattern extends beyond classic serial killer cases. Dylann Roof, convicted in the 2015 Charleston church shooting, has drawn online sympathizers who promote certain symbols associated with his actions. Elliot Rodger, responsible for the 2014 Isla Vista attacks that killed six people, has become a reference point in some online communities that frame him as a victim of circumstance. These examples illustrate how the same impulse can attach itself to ideologically motivated violence as well.
The Psychology of Killer Fandom
Researchers have long studied the attraction some people feel toward those who commit violent crimes. The term hybristophilia, introduced in the 1950s, describes a pattern in which individuals become drawn to partners who have broken the law. Forensic psychologist Katherine Ramsland has observed that this often involves a wish to understand or “rescue” the person in question. Many who participate in these communities share traits such as a search for excitement or a tendency to project personal meaning onto distant figures.
Studies published in the Journal of Forensic Psychiatry have linked heavy engagement with true crime material to sensation-seeking behavior. Social media algorithms can intensify the effect by suggesting increasingly specific content to users who linger on certain posts. For some participants the interest remains a private fascination; for others it moves into attempts to contact offenders or visit crime scenes. Gender patterns appear as well. Forensic psychologist Scott Bonn has noted that many female admirers are drawn to the “bad boy” image, while some male participants focus on intellectualizing the killer’s supposed strategic abilities.
Impact on Victims’ Families and Society
The consequences reach beyond the original crimes. Families of victims have described receiving hostile messages from people who defend the perpetrator or question the family’s role in seeking justice. The relatives of Gabby Petito encountered online harassment connected to discussions of her 2021 murder. Former prosecutor Marcia Clark has spoken publicly about how such glorification can reopen old wounds for those who have already lost loved ones.
On a broader level, research from the University of Leicester suggests that repeated romantic portrayals of violence can reduce sensitivity among younger audiences. Some platforms have attempted to respond. Tumblr introduced restrictions on certain categories of content in 2018, and other sites have adjusted moderation policies. Enforcement remains uneven, however, and new technologies such as AI-generated imagery continue to create fresh challenges.
Combating the Trend: Challenges and Responses
Efforts to address the issue include both platform policies and educational initiatives. YouTube has demonetized videos that cross into overt celebration of offenders. Reddit has placed certain communities under stricter oversight. Creators who focus on victim-centered storytelling, such as Kendall Rae, have encouraged audiences to keep the emphasis on those who were harmed. Some states have also considered limits on marriages involving incarcerated individuals to reduce opportunities for exploitation.
Organizations like the National Center for Victims of Crime promote media literacy programs that help people distinguish between learning about a case and admiring the person responsible. Families connected to cases such as the West Memphis Three have worked with podcasters to keep attention on the victims rather than on alternative narratives that sometimes emerge online.
Free speech considerations and the anonymity of online spaces make complete solutions difficult. The problem continues to shift as technology changes, requiring ongoing attention from platforms, creators, and the public alike.
Conclusion
The growth of these fan communities shows how fascination with violent crime can move from understanding to something closer to admiration. When that shift happens, the people who suffered most often become secondary to the story of the person who caused the harm. Responsible coverage and thoughtful discussion can help keep the focus where it belongs: on prevention, accountability, and respect for those whose lives were cut short. By staying alert to the difference between curiosity and celebration, we can engage with these cases without turning perpetrators into figures of misplaced respect.
Bibliography
Katherine Ramsland, The Serial Killer Whisperer and related forensic psychology writings.
Journal of Forensic Psychiatry studies on sensation-seeking and true crime engagement.
University of Leicester research on media effects and desensitization to violence.
Contemporary reporting on the Ted Bundy trials from 1979 and 1980.
Scott Bonn, Why We Love Serial Killers: The Curious Appeal of the World’s Most Savage Murderers.
National Center for Victims of Crime educational materials on media literacy.
Archival coverage of the Charles Manson trials and subsequent correspondence.
Platform policy announcements from Tumblr in 2018 regarding prohibited content categories.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
