In the sterile glow of an operating room a single slip can echo for years, and that is exactly where The Killing of a Sacred Deer begins its slow, merciless descent into moral horror. This 2017 film from Yorgos Lanthimos takes an ancient idea of sacrifice and drops it straight into a modern Kentucky suburb, leaving audiences to wrestle with questions of guilt, justice, and what any parent would actually do when every option is unthinkable.
The Killing of a Sacred Deer (2017) stands as a towering achievement in modern moral horror, a film that twists the knife of ethical dilemmas into the heart of domestic bliss. Directed by Yorgos Lanthimos, this unsettling tale draws from ancient Greek tragedies to probe the depths of human accountability and retribution. As surgeon Steven Murphy grapples with a vengeful curse unleashed by a troubled boy named Martin, the narrative builds to a finale that forces viewers to confront uncomfortable truths about survival, innocence, and the cost of atonement.
The film’s ending reveals a harrowing lottery of death, where randomness underscores the impartial cruelty of moral reckoning. Martin’s curse, rooted in biblical and classical vengeance, transforms personal guilt into collective punishment. Lanthimos masterfully employs sterile visuals and stilted dialogue to amplify the horror of inescapable fate.
Unpacking the Curse: Retribution’s Cold Grip
The Killing of a Sacred Deer opens with a mesmerising sequence of open-heart surgery, performed by Steven Murphy with cold precision. This clinical detachment sets the tone for a story where medicine, the supposed saviour of life, becomes entangled with forces beyond rational control. Colin Farrell’s Steven embodies the archetype of the successful professional: a devoted husband to Anna (Nicole Kidman), father to teenage Kim (Raffey Cassidy) and young Bobby (Sunny Suljic). Yet, lurking beneath this facade is the ghost of a past mistake, the drunk-driving accident that claimed Martin’s father, a colleague under Steven’s scalpel. That single error matters because it turns Steven from healer into someone who must now decide who deserves to live, a reversal that sits at the centre of everything that follows.
Martin, played with eerie composure by Barry Keoghan, infiltrates this world like a spectral emissary. His polite demeanour masks a profound sense of injustice, inherited from his widowed mother who clings to Steven for solace. As Martin weaves himself into the family fabric, strange afflictions strike: Bobby’s legs fail, then Kim’s, followed by the parents. Doctors offer no answers, plunging the household into paralysis, both literal and figurative. This progression mirrors the inexorable spread of guilt, a contagion that no antibiotic can cure. Lanthimos draws heavily from Euripides’ Iphigenia at Aulis, where Agamemnon sacrifices his daughter to appease the gods after offending Artemis by killing a sacred deer. Here, the ‘sacred deer’ symbolises innocence slain unwittingly, demanding equivalent restitution. Martin’s curse stipulates that one family member must die by deliberate intent, or all perish slowly. This setup elevates the film beyond mere supernatural thriller into a philosophical chamber piece on justice’s arithmetic: one life for one life, no exceptions.
The Paralysis of Choice: Family Under Siege
As the curse tightens, the Murphy home transforms into a mausoleum of immobility. The family’s inability to stand or eat evokes the wasting sicknesses of ancient myths, where divine wrath manifests physically. Steven’s frantic searches for medical cures yield nothing, forcing him to confront Martin’s ultimatum. Attempts to murder Martin fail spectacularly, reinforcing the boy’s invulnerability and the curse’s iron rules. Dialogue in Lanthimos’s signature style, formal and almost scripted, heightens the absurdity and tension. Conversations about eyes, teeth, and hypothetical murders unfold with deadpan delivery, underscoring the surreal horror. Nicole Kidman’s Anna oscillates between maternal denial and pragmatic horror, suggesting they kill Bobby as the youngest, a chilling calculus of value. Yet Steven resists, clinging to his paternal instincts until the family’s collective catatonia breaks him. The film’s sound design amplifies this dread: muffled footsteps, laboured breathing, and Thure Lindhardt’s score of dissonant strings create an auditory cage. Cinematographer Thimios Bakatakis employs wide-angle lenses to dwarf characters in vast, impersonal spaces, emphasising isolation amid supposed togetherness.
Spinning the Bottle: Randomness as Divine Will
The climax does not rely on a literal bottle spin but on a far more human and devastating process of elimination. After failed attempts to break the curse, the family must confront the reality that one of them has to die. Each member is asked who should be sacrificed, and the answers reveal raw self-preservation: Anna suggests Kim, Kim suggests Bobby, and Bobby suggests Kim. Steven ultimately chooses his daughter, taking her life with a heavy object in the kitchen while the others remain frozen nearby. The off-screen sounds confirm the act, and mobility returns to the survivors almost immediately. Martin appears at a later dinner, raising a glass as if balance has been restored. This sequence matters because it strips away any illusion of noble sacrifice and shows instead the mechanical, soul-destroying violence required to survive. Moral horror resides here: the ending explained as a perversion of justice. Is killing an innocent equivalent to the original sin? The film posits no redemption arc; Steven’s act restores order but stains his soul indelibly. Viewers grapple with complicity and wonder whether they would choose differently. Lanthimos leaves no catharsis, only the lingering question of whether survival justifies savagery.
Moral Reckoning: Guilt’s Arithmetic
The film’s meaning unfurls in its refusal of easy answers. Martin’s vengeance, while disproportionate, stems from paternal loss mirroring Steven’s negligence. Yet the curse’s impartiality indicts blind retribution. Biblical echoes abound: an eye for an eye escalates to familial annihilation, questioning retributive justice’s viability in modern ethics. Cultural resonance amplifies this. Post-2010s austerity, amid economic curses on families, the film reflects collective anxieties. Its moral horror lies in exposing utilitarianism’s underbelly: sacrificing one for many feels logical until it is your child. Critics praise this as Lanthimos’s evolution from absurdist comedy to tragedy, blending Greek fatalism with suburban sterility. Overlooked aspects include gender dynamics: Anna’s early willingness to sacrifice contrasts Steven’s hesitation, subverting patriarchal protector tropes. Kim’s budding sexuality, hinted via her boyfriend, adds layers of innocence tainted by adolescence, ripe for sacrificial myth. As explored once at Dyerbolical, these tensions continue to reward repeat viewings because they connect classical myth to the quiet dread of ordinary family life.
Visual Poetry of Doom: Lanthimos’s Aesthetic Arsenal
Bakatakis’s visuals obsess over symmetry and scale. Slow zooms on frozen faces evoke portraiture of the damned, while tracking shots through empty halls build claustrophobia. The deer’s killing in the opening, a hunter’s casual shot, foreshadows the human toll, blood pooling like abstract art. Production design by Jess Gonchor favours muted palettes of greys and whites, evoking hospital morgues. This sterility critiques medical hubris, where Steven’s god complex crumbles against primordial forces. Legacy-wise, the film influenced arthouse horror like Midsommar (2019), inheriting folkloric curses but grounding them in psychological realism. Its Cannes Best Screenplay win cemented Lanthimos’s auteur status, bridging Dogtooth’s grotesquerie with broader appeal.
Cultural Echoes: From Myth to Multiplex
Released amid #MeToo reckonings, the film probes accountability without forgiveness. Martin’s polite menace recalls The Babadook’s grief incarnate, but with colder calculus. Collecting culture ties in via Blu-ray editions, coveted for 4K restorations capturing every pallid frame. Fan theories proliferate: is Martin supernatural or a psychosomatic manipulator? Evidence leans mythic, his immunity and precise curse mechanics suggesting otherworldly agency. This ambiguity fuels rewatches, a collector’s delight for hidden details like recurring deer motifs in decor. In retro horror context, though modern, it evokes 1970s slow-burn terrors like The Wicker Man. The film endures as a modern classic, its ending dissected endlessly for moral fissures.
Director in the Spotlight: Yorgos Lanthimos
Yorgos Lanthimos, born in 1973 in Athens, Greece, emerged from a theatre background steeped in experimental performance. Influenced by his parents’ involvement in local arts, he studied film at the Stavrakos Film School, quickly gaining traction with commercials and music videos noted for their surreal detachment. His feature debut, My Best Friend (2001), a low-budget exploration of male bonding through games, hinted at his fascination with ritualistic behaviour. International breakthrough came with Dogtooth (2009), a Palme d’Or nominee that trapped a family in linguistic and sexual isolation, earning widespread acclaim for its unflinching absurdity. Funded modestly at around €300,000, it launched Lanthimos into arthouse stardom. Alps (2011) followed, delving into identity theft via grief role-playing, further honing his stilted dialogue trademark. Crossing to English-language cinema, The Lobster (2015), starring Farrell and Kidman, satirised enforced coupling in a dystopian resort, winning the Jury Prize at Cannes. The Killing of a Sacred Deer (2017) marked his darkest turn, adapting mythic tragedy to suburbia. The Favourite (2018), a baroque period comedy with Olivia Colman, Rachel Weisz, and Emma Stone, garnered ten Oscar nominations, including Best Director. Recent triumphs include Poor Things (2023), a Frankenstein-esque odyssey with Emma Stone as a reanimated woman discovering autonomy, securing four Oscars. Lanthimos’s collaborations with screenwriter Efthymis Filippou infuse Greek fatalism into contemporary tales. Influences span Luis Buñuel’s surrealism, Stanley Kubrick’s precision, and Michael Haneke’s moral rigour. His oeuvre critiques power structures through discomfort, cementing him as a visionary provocateur.
Actor in the Spotlight: Barry Keoghan
Barry Keoghan, born in 1992 in Summerhill, Dublin, Ireland, rose from troubled youth to acting via a school drama club. Early roles in Irish TV like Love/Hate (2013) showcased raw intensity. His film debut, Between the Canals (2011), led to Dunkirk (2017), where he played a stranded soldier, catching Christopher Nolan’s eye. The Killing of a Sacred Deer (2017) catapulted him as Martin, earning a BAFTA Rising Star nomination for his chilling blend of vulnerability and menace. The Banshees of Inisherin (2022) as Dominic, a socially awkward lad, snagged Oscar and Golden Globe nods. Saltburn (2023), Emerald Fennell’s gothic thriller, saw him as the seductive Oliver Quick, sparking viral discourse. Further credits include Eternals (2021) as Druig, The Batman (2022) as Joker in a reprisal cameo, and Masters of the Air (2024) miniseries. Keoghan’s wiry physique and piercing gaze excel in outsiders, drawing from personal hardships. Awards include Irish Film and Television Awards for Killing of a Sacred Deer and Banshees. His trajectory embodies resilient talent, transforming adversity into on-screen magnetism.
Bibliography
Bradshaw, P. (2017) The Killing of a Sacred Deer review – Greek tragedy with a Kentucky twang. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2017/oct/20/the-killing-of-a-sacred-deer-review-yorgos-lanthimos-colin-farrell (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Farrow, S. (2017) Interview: Yorgos Lanthimos on Greek Myths and Modern Horror. Variety. Available at: https://variety.com/2017/film/features/yorgos-lanthimos-killing-sacred-deer-interview-1202598745/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Lanthimos, Y. and Filippou, E. (2017) The Killing of a Sacred Deer: Screenplay. London: Faber & Faber.
Ramazani, J. (2019) Tragedy in Contemporary Cinema: Lanthimos and the Ethics of Sacrifice. Film Quarterly, 72(3), pp. 22-31.
Scott, A.O. (2017) When Guilt Plays by Ruthless Rules. New York Times. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/10/20/movies/the-killing-of-a-sacred-deer-review.html (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Whitty, S. (2018) Gods and Monsters: The Influences Behind Sacred Deer. RogerEbert.com. Available at: https://www.rogerebert.com/features/the-killing-of-a-sacred-deer-greek-tragedy (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
