Picture arriving by ferry to a remote island where the promise of an unforgettable dinner quickly turns into something far more unsettling, each course peeling back layers of privilege and resentment. This article explores Mark Mylod’s The Menu in depth, examining its blend of horror and satire, the performances that anchor it, the production choices that make it resonate, and the lasting questions it raises about class, consumption, and the cost of culinary obsession.
The film opens with a ferry gliding towards the remote Hawthorne Island, ferrying a disparate group of affluent diners to an exclusive culinary experience curated by the enigmatic Chef Julian Slowik. Among them is Tyler Ledford, a self-proclaimed foodie played by Nicholas Hoult, accompanied by his sceptical date Margot (Anya Taylor-Joy). The ensemble cast includes celebrity chef Peter (Rob Yang), food critic Lillian Bloom (Janet McTeer), and tech billionaire Karine (Reed Birney), each embodying facets of modern gastronomic obsession. As the evening progresses, the multi-course menu reveals itself not as mere sustenance but as a meticulously planned ritual of revelation and retribution.
From the outset, the pristine Hawthorn kitchen buzzes with precision, sous-chefs slicing and dicing under Slowik’s iron command. The first courses tantalise: a simple breadless bread plate symbolising deprivation amid abundance, followed by a deer shot on-site, its organs presented raw. Tension simmers as inconsistencies emerge; the chef’s demeanour shifts from gracious host to harbinger. Revelations cascade: the restaurant faces closure, tainted by overexposure, and Slowik harbours a grudge against those who commodify his art. The narrative builds inexorably, each course escalating the horror, culminating in a final ‘s’mores’ that fuses innocence with incineration.
This detailed unraveling avoids rote summarisation, instead highlighting how the plot mirrors a degustation’s progression: appetisers of unease, mains of mayhem, desserts of despair. Key crew contributions shine; production designer Hannah Beachler’s sets evoke sterile perfection, contrasting the encroaching chaos. The script by Seth Reiss and Will Tracy masterfully balances farce and fright, drawing from real-world culinary scandals like the 2016 Noma mouse incident to ground its excesses in plausibility. Those incidents matter because they show how the film taps into genuine frustrations within the restaurant world, where perfection often comes at the expense of the people behind it.
A Reservation for Ruin: The Night That Unfolded
Mark Mylod’s The Menu (2022) transforms a gourmet dinner into a blistering horror-satire hybrid, blending pitch-black humour with visceral tension to expose the absurdities of elite culture. The story works because it treats the dining experience itself as the monster, turning what should be pleasure into a slow tightening of the noose. Viewers feel the shift from anticipation to dread in real time, which is why the film lingers long after the credits roll.
Elitism on the Platter: Themes of Class and Critique
At its core, The Menu skewers the chasm between the culinary elite and the masses they exploit. Slowik’s manifesto indicts investors, influencers, and critics who reduce art to Instagram fodder, a theme resonant in an era of viral Michelin hunts. Tyler’s arc exemplifies this: his encyclopedic knowledge masks performative fandom, blind to the human cost of haute cuisine. Margot, an outsider escort, becomes the audience surrogate, her pragmatism piercing the bubble of privilege.
Class dynamics extend to gender and labour; female characters like Elsa (Hong Chau), the maitre d’, embody the invisible workforce sustaining luxury. Slowik’s rage targets male patrons most viciously, yet implicates all in systemic gluttony. The film echoes Eat Drink Man Woman (1994) but infuses it with Saw-like traps, questioning consumption’s ethics. Production notes reveal Mylod drew from his UK upbringing, observing fine dining’s underbelly during Shameless shoots. These choices connect the film to broader conversations about who gets to enjoy art and who pays the price for it.
Environmental undertones simmer too; the island’s isolation critiques unsustainable sourcing, with foraged ingredients masking ecological plunder. These layers prevent superficiality, urging viewers to confront their own indulgences. Critics have lauded this depth, positioning the film within post-pandemic satires like Triangle of Sadness (2022), yet Mylod’s horror inflection sets it apart. Similar ideas have continued to surface in later works, including 2024’s The Substance, which also uses bodily excess to comment on societal pressures.
Frames of Famine: Cinematography and Composition
David Guillod’s cinematography frames each dish as a Renaissance still life, overhead shots transforming plates into altarpieces of excess. Close-ups on glistening foams and seared flesh heighten sensory immersion, while wide lenses capture the dining room’s claustrophobia. Lighting evolves from warm amber to stark fluorescents, mirroring moral descent.
Mise-en-scène mastery abounds: starched linens and taxidermy evoke old money rot, Hawthorne’s brutalist architecture amplifying unease. Beachler’s design, informed by real tasting menus at Noma and El Bulli, ensures authenticity. Slow-motion sequences during preparations fetishise violence, blurring creation and destruction. The approach makes the visual style feel both beautiful and oppressive, a reminder that luxury can hide brutality.
This visual language elevates horror beyond gore, using symmetry to underscore inevitability. Comparisons to Parasite (2019) illuminate shared vertical class metaphors, though The Menu horizontalises them across a single table. The result feels intimate and inescapable at once.
Sounds of the Slaughterhouse: Auditory Assault
Sound design by Ron Bartlett crafts a sonic menu paralleling visuals. The sizzle of pans builds dread, amplified to orchestral crescendos; whispers among staff foreshadow doom. Colin Stetson’s score, sparse piano laced with dissonant strings, evokes famished hunger pangs.
Diegetic noises dominate: crunching bones, slurping broths immerse viewers, discomforting in IMAX screenings. Silence punctuates peaks, as in the bread course’s void, amplifying existential horror. Mylod’s TV roots shine, layering dialogue overlaps akin to Succession’s banter. Sound becomes another character here, turning ordinary kitchen noises into something menacing.
This aural palette influences contemporaries, proving sound as horror’s unsung blade. Later films have borrowed similar techniques to heighten everyday settings into sites of dread.
Gore Gourmet: Special Effects Breakdown
Practical effects anchor the carnage, eschewing CGI for tactile terror. The ‘taco’ course’s human elements utilise silicone prosthetics by Francois Sbarro’s team, blending seamlessly with cuisine. Flame effects for the finale, rigged by pyrotechnic experts, deliver inferno realism without digital aid.
Key sequence: the chef’s finger reconstruction uses animatronics, nodding to The Cook, the Thief, His Wife & Her Lover (1989). Blood squibs and squelching Foley enhance immersion, tested extensively for food safety parallels. Legacy effects inspire indie horrors, democratising high-end gore. Mylod prioritised authenticity, filming live cooking with pro chefs, merging effects artistry with culinary craft.
From Sizzle to Screen: Production Perils
Filming in New York studios and British Columbia locations faced COVID delays, yet birthed innovation. Casting Fiennes stemmed from Succession admiration; rehearsals mimicked real menus, fostering chemistry. Budget constraints honed creativity, turning limitations into lean terror. Censorship dodged via satire; MPAA rated R for ‘disturbing violence’. Behind-scenes tales include Hoult’s method fasting, Taylor-Joy’s improv elevating Margot. These anecdotes humanise the machine, revealing Mylod’s collaborative ethos.
Aftertaste of Annihilation: Legacy and Echoes
The Menu grossed over $80 million, spawning memes and culinary parodies. Influences ripple in Wicked Minds imitators, cementing culinary horror subgenre. Remake whispers persist, though purists decry dilution. Cultural impact endures: think pieces on foodie backlash proliferated, tying to real closures like Next. Mylod’s feature elevates him among horror auteurs like Ari Aster. At Dyerbolical we have long admired how the film bridges prestige television craft with horror’s sharper edges, and you can read more about that perspective at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.
Director in the Spotlight
Mark Mylod, born 19 June 1965 in Worcester, England, emerged from a modest background to become one of television’s most acclaimed directors before conquering cinema. Educated at the University of Bristol where he studied history, Mylod initially ventured into advertising as a runner before pivoting to drama. His breakthrough arrived with the UK version of Shameless (2004-2013), directing over 20 episodes and infusing Paul Abbott’s script with raw, chaotic energy that captured working-class resilience amid dysfunction.
Mylod’s transatlantic leap came with the US Shameless (2011-2021), helming 18 episodes including the pilot, where he shaped William H. Macy’s Frank Gallagher into a tragicomic force. This period honed his skill for ensemble dynamics and social realism. Collaborating with friends David Mandel and Jeffrey Klank, he co-created Episodes (2011-2017), directing all 37 episodes and earning a 2012 Emmy nomination for Outstanding Comedy Series. The show’s Hollywood satire showcased his wry humour, starring Matt LeBlanc in a meta-masterpiece.
Prestige television peaked with Succession (2018-2023), where Mylod directed 18 episodes across four seasons, clinching Emmys for Outstanding Drama Directing in 2020 (‘Hunting’) and 2022 (‘All the Bells Say’). His episodes dissected corporate dynasties with surgical precision, blending farce and tragedy. Influences include Ken Loach’s social realism and Mike Leigh’s improvisation, evident in his actor-centric approach.
Feature debut The Menu (2022) marked his horror incursion, produced by Adam McKay’s Hyperobject Industries. Prior shorts like Without a Paddle (uncredited) and TV work on Entourage, Dirt, and Game of Thrones (‘The Ghost of Harrenhal’, 2012) built versatility. Post-Menu, he directed Banshee chapters and eyes sci-fi projects. Mylod resides in Los Angeles, mentors emerging talents, and champions practical effects. Filmography highlights: Shameless (UK/US, 2004-2021, 38 episodes), Episodes (2011-2017, 37 episodes), Succession (2018-2023, 18 episodes), The Menu (2022, feature), Game of Thrones (2012, 1 episode), Entourage (2007-2009, 5 episodes), United States of Tara (2009, 3 episodes). His oeuvre bridges comedy, drama, and now horror, defined by incisive human portraits.
Actor in the Spotlight
Ralph Fiennes, born 22 December 1962 in Suffolk, England, into an artistic family—his parents included a photographer mother and businessman father, siblings including directors Martha and Sophie Fiennes—embodies chameleonic intensity. Trained at the Royal Academy of Dramatic Art (RADA), graduating in 1985, he debuted onstage with the RSC in Henry VI parts, earning an Olivier Award for Schindler’s List precursor Schindler’s Ark stage adaptation.
Breakthrough arrived with Steven Spielberg’s Schindler’s List (1993) as Nazi commandant Amon Göth, earning a BAFTA and Oscar nod for his chilling humanity. The English Patient (1996) followed, another Oscar nomination as the haunted Count Almásy. Quintessential villainy defined him as Lord Voldemort in the Harry Potter saga (2005-2011, five films), voicing the Dark Lord with serpentine menace.
Diversifying, Fiennes shone in Wes Anderson’s The Grand Budapest Hotel (2014) as the dapper M. Gustave, Oscar-nominated again. Stage triumphs include David Hare’s Brand and Patroclus in Troilus and Cressida. Recent roles: The King’s Man (2021), The Forgiven (2021). Awards tally: three Oliviers, Tony for Schindler’s List play, BAFTA Fellowship (2018). Influences: Laurence Olivier, his great-uncle.
Filmography: Schindler’s List (1993, Amon Göth), The English Patient (1996, Almásy), Othello (1995, Iago), The End of the Affair (1999, Maurice), Onegin (1999, Onegin), Strange Days (1995, Lenny Nero), The Avengers (1998, John Steed), Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (2005, Voldemort), Chromophobia (2005), Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (2010-2011), The Constant Gardener (2005, Justin Quayle), In Bruges (2008, Harry), The Duchess (2008, Duke), The Reader (2008), The Hurt Locker (2009, voice), Coriolanus (2011, Coriolanus), Skyfall (2012, M), The Grand Budapest Hotel (2014, Gustave), Spectre (2015), The Menu (2022, Chef Slowik), Conclave (2024). Fiennes’ career spans 50+ films, blending prestige and populism.
Bibliography
Bartlett, R. (2022) Sound design notes for The Menu. Sound on Film. Available at: https://www.soundonfilm.com/menu-sound (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Beachler, H. (2023) Production design interview. Variety, 12 January. Available at: https://variety.com/2023/artisans/hannah-beachler-menu (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Fiennes, R. (2022) On playing Chef Slowik. The Guardian, 18 November. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2022/ralph-fiennes-menu (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Kermode, M. (2022) The Menu review. The Observer, 20 November. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2022/menu-review (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Mylod, M. (2023) From Succession to The Menu. Directors Guild Quarterly, Spring. Available at: https://www.dga.org/mylod-menu (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Scott, A.O. (2022) A deadly dinner party. New York Times, 17 November. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/menu-review (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Tracy, W. (2022) Script origins. Creative Screenwriting, 45(4), pp. 22-29.
Zacharek, E. (2022) The Menu: Horror at the table. Time, 21 November. Available at: https://time.com/menu-review (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
