The Menu pulls you in right from that first boat ride to the island, where the promise of a perfect meal quickly turns into something far more unsettling. This 2022 film blends sharp comedy and creeping dread to expose how the world of high-end dining can swallow people whole, and this article walks through the story setup, the layered class critique in every course, the horror elements that build tension without cheap tricks, the famous final scene with its s’mores twist, the lasting impact on audiences, plus close looks at director Mark Mylod and Ralph Fiennes in the lead role.
A Reservation for Ruin: Setting the Stage
The isolated Hawthorn restaurant perches on its own private island, a fortress of exclusivity accessible only by boat. Here, Chef Julian Slowik curates not just meals but performances, each course a meticulously crafted statement. Patrons arrive expecting transcendence through tasting menus priced at $25,000 a head – tech bros, critics, celebrities, and influencers, all blind to the blade hovering above their forks. Margot, played by Anya Taylor-Joy, stands apart as the escort du jour, her outsider status granting her a unique lens on the unfolding horror.
From the outset, unease simmers like a reduction sauce. The staff’s robotic precision hints at cultish devotion, while Slowik’s monologues reveal a man broken by the industry’s commodification of art. Smoked scallops arrive with whispers of the sea’s bounty, but beneath lies the film’s thesis: true creativity cannot survive when chained to commerce. As dishes escalate – breadless bread, a “chef’s table” of staff sacrifice – the diners’ entitlement unravels, exposing the rot at fine dining’s core. That private island setting matters because it strips away any easy escape, forcing every character to face what they have paid for and what it has cost others along the way.
This setup masterfully echoes classic horror confinement tales, from Agatha Christie’s And Then There Were None to The Thing‘s Antarctic outpost, but infuses them with millennial malaise. The Menu does not merely trap its victims; it forces them to consume their own downfall, turning the act of eating into indictment. The choice to ground the tension in something as everyday as dinner makes the critique land harder, because viewers recognise the same rituals of status and excess in their own lives.
Courses of Class Critique
Each plate serves satire on a silver platter. The “Mise en Place” course mocks the foodie elite’s performative appreciation, with critics scribbling notes on air while ignoring the human cost. Tyler, the superfan played by Nicholas Hoult, embodies toxic fandom, his encyclopedic knowledge of Slowik’s career blinding him to the chef’s contempt. In one pivotal moment, Slowik recreates Tyler’s favourite dish from years prior, only to reveal it as the catalyst for his disillusionment – a bestseller born of desperation. That scene hits because it shows how fans can turn creators into products, draining the joy that once made the work worthwhile.
The film lambasts Hollywood excess through the movie star trio, their sycophantic banter a parody of red-carpet schmoozing. One actor begs for a role in Slowik’s imagined biopic, oblivious to the irony as his life literally becomes the script. Meanwhile, the tech billionaire dismisses the menu’s artistry for profit potential, proposing NFTs of the experience – a jab at crypto bros turning culture into currency. These moments connect because they reveal how different corners of wealth all treat art as another transaction rather than something human.
Social media’s role amplifies the mockery. An influencer live-streams her “authentic” reactions, hashtagging away while staff slit their throats in the background. The Menu captures the 2020s zeitgeist, where authenticity is curated and suffering aestheticised, much like Instagrammed avocado toast masking labour exploitation. Gender dynamics simmer too. Margot navigates a male-dominated space of bluster and bravado, her pragmatism contrasting the men’s blithering panic. When Slowik offers her an out, it is not mercy but recognition of her untainted palate – she eats to live, not to lord over others.
The Horror of the Haute
Horror blooms not from jump scares but slow-simmered dread. The staff’s silent suicides evoke Midsommar‘s ritualistic calm, bodies crumpling like spent ingredients. Blood mixes with sauces, limbs garnish plates – practical effects ground the grotesquerie in tangible revulsion, harking back to 1970s gore masters like Cronenberg. Sound design heightens the terror: clinking crystal against the island’s howling winds, masticating mouths amplified to grotesque symphonies. Slowik’s voice, a velvet blade, narrates the descent, his charisma masking madness akin to Hannibal Lecter’s refined savagery.
Psychological layers peel back entitlement’s facade. Diners plead, bargain, devolve into animals, revealing the fragility of civility when comfort evaporates. This mirrors real-world schadenfreude over celebrity falls, from Epstein’s island to Fyre Festival fiascos, where the mighty’s hubris invites downfall. The film’s restraint – no zombies, minimal effects – amplifies authenticity. Violence feels earned, a crescendo from verbal barbs to literal consumption, forcing viewers to confront complicity in systems devouring their makers. Those choices keep the focus on character rather than spectacle, which is why the dread lingers longer than any quick shock could manage.
Unpacking the Final Course: S’mores and Symbolism
The ending crystallises the chaos: a massive s’more, childhood simplicity twisted into funeral pyre. Slowik crowns each doomed guest with graham cracker helmets, marshmallow nooses, chocolate shrouds – innocence perverted into execution. “This is the menu,” he declares, as flames engulf the restaurant, diners immolated in their finery. Margot escapes via rowboat, watching the inferno with detached horror. Slowik’s suicide note, a photo of his smiling staff, underscores lost purity. The s’more evokes campfires of yore, communal joy now solitary survival. Critics debate if Margot redeems or merely survives; her final act – eating a cheeseburger at a dingy diner – reclaims food’s primal joy, free from pretension.
This denouement indicts not just diners but spectators. We, like Tyler, crave the spectacle, analysing menus as if lives do not hang in balance. Post-credits, the boatman’s query – “Rough night?” – snaps back to normalcy, but the aftertaste lingers, questioning our appetites. Symbolism abounds: the island as ivory tower, flames purifying corruption. Slowik’s arc from prodigy to destroyer parallels burned-out creatives, his menu a suicide note scripted for the unworthy. The choice of a childhood treat for the finale works because it strips away the fancy plating and leaves only raw human failure.
Legacy of a Last Supper
Since its premiere, The Menu has sparked feasts of discourse, from TikTok recreations to academic papers on gastro-politics. It revives dinner-party horrors like Ready or Not, but elevates satire to scalpel precision. Streaming on platforms like HBO Max, it finds new audiences amid inflation-weary diners baulking at tasting-menu markups. Influences ripple: parodies in late-night sketches, think pieces linking it to post-pandemic isolation dining. Collector’s editions – posters, soundtracks – emerge for horror buffs, its sleek poster a minimalist masterpiece evoking Saul Bass.
The film’s prescience shines in 2023 scandals, from celebrity chefs exposed to fine-dining bubbles bursting. It warns against art’s commodification, echoing 1980s excess critiqued in films like Wall Street, but updated for influencer eras. As explored further at Dyerbolical once, the story still resonates because the same pressures on creators and consumers have only grown sharper in recent years.
Director in the Spotlight: Mark Mylod
Mark Mylod, born in 1965 in Britain, honed his craft in television before conquering features. Starting as a runner on shows like Only Fools and Horses in the 1980s, he directed episodes of gritty dramas such as Cracker (1993), showcasing his knack for tense character studies. Transitioning to comedy, Mylod helmed Entourage (2005-2011), capturing Hollywood’s underbelly with wry precision.
His breakthrough came with Episodes (2011-2017), co-created with David Crane and Jeffrey Klarner, a savage sitcom starring Matt LeBlanc as a fictionalised self, skewering transatlantic TV absurdities. Mylod’s eight seasons demonstrated virtuosic pacing, blending farce with pathos. He followed with Shameless (2011-2021), directing over 30 episodes of the US adaptation, mastering ensemble chaos amid working-class grit.
Mylod’s filmography expands with The Trip series (2010-2020), where Steve Coogan and Rob Brydon’s culinary banter foreshadowed The Menu‘s food focus. HBO’s Succession (2018-2023) cemented his status; directing nine episodes, including the pilot and finale, Mylod navigated Logan’s media empire with Shakespearean venom, earning Emmys for his taut boardroom battles.
Influenced by Mike Leigh’s social realism and Coen Brothers’ dark humour, Mylod brings theatre-honed blocking to screens. Post-Menu, he directed Banshee episodes and pilots like Fortitude (2015). Upcoming projects include The Regime (2024) with Kate Winslet, blending satire and tyranny. His career, spanning 100+ credits, reflects a chameleon director thriving in prestige TV’s golden age.
Actor/Character in the Spotlight: Ralph Fiennes as Chef Slowik
Ralph Fiennes, born December 22, 1962, in Suffolk, England, epitomises chameleon intensity. Theatre-trained at RADA, he exploded with Schindler’s List (1993) as Amon Göth, earning Oscar and BAFTA nods for chilling humanity amid monstrosity. Voldemort in the Harry Potter series (2001-2011) typecast him as villainy incarnate, yet he subverted it with The English Patient (1996), winning BAFTA for romantic torment.
Fiennes’ versatility shines in The Grand Budapest Hotel (2014), Wes Anderson’s confection where his M. Gustave exudes droll dignity; The King (2019) as a menacing Falstaff; and The Menu‘s Slowik, a gourmet gargoyle blending Lecter-esque poise with volcanic rage. Stage triumphs include Strange Interlude (2014) and Schmitz in Oedipus (2020), showcasing marathon endurance.
Awards abound: Olivier for Henry V (1989), Tony noms, and CBE in 2015. Films like In Bruges (2008), The Hurt Locker (2008), The Constant Gardener (2005), and Schindler’s List highlight activism roots, supporting refugees. Recent roles: The King’s Man (2021), Official Secrets (2019). As Slowik, Fiennes channels culinary commandos like Marco Pierre White, his whisper-to-roar menace making the chef unforgettable.
Brother to Joseph and Martha Fiennes, Ralph’s filmography spans 80+ roles, from Quiz Show (1994) to Spectre (2015), embodying British theatre’s rigour in global cinema. That range lets him turn a chef into both monster and tragic figure, which is what makes the performance stick with viewers long after the meal ends.
Bibliography
Erbland, T. (2022) ‘The Menu Ending Explained: Chef Slowik’s Final Message’, IndieWire. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com/features/analysis/the-menu-ending-explained-1234789523/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Grobar, M. (2022) ‘Mark Mylod on Directing The Menu and Succession Parallels’, Deadline. Available at: https://deadline.com/2022/11/mark-mylod-the-menu-succession-interview-1235173687/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Hiscock, L. (2023) ‘Ralph Fiennes: From Voldemort to Chef Slowik’, The Telegraph. Available at: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/films/0/ralph-fiennes-menu-interview/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Kiang, M. (2022) ‘The Menu Review: A Blackly Comic Horror’, Sight and Sound. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-and-sound/reviews/menu (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Rosenberg, A. (2023) ‘Gastro-Horror and Class in The Menu’, Journal of Popular Culture, 56(2), pp. 345-362.
Scott, A.O. (2022) ‘Dinner is Served, with a Side of Doom’, The New York Times. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/17/movies/the-menu-review.html (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Collum, J. (2023) The Menu: A Feast of Satire. Fangoria Press.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
