Pendle Hill Witch Trials 1612: Family Rivalries, Coerced Confessions and the Royal Fear That Sent Ten to the Gallows
In the spring of 1612 a teenage girl asked a traveling peddler for a few pins on a quiet Lancashire road. When he refused, the moment spiraled into accusations that ended with ten people dead on the gallows. This article traces exactly how that single quarrel grew into one of England’s largest and best documented witch trials, examining the families involved, the legal pressures they faced, and the wider climate that made such outcomes possible.
The events remain anchored in the surviving record kept by court clerk Thomas Potts, whose 1613 pamphlet The Wonderfull Discoverie of Witches in the Countie of Lancaster still supplies most of what we know. Potts worked under Judge Edward Bromley at the Lancaster Assizes, and his account shows both the evidence presented and the speed with which suspicion turned into capital convictions. Readers can follow the same sequence of arrests, confessions and sentences that unfolded between March and August that year.
Historical Context: A Perfect Storm of Superstition
Early seventeenth-century England treated witchcraft as a real and dangerous crime. The Witchcraft Act of 1604, passed soon after James I took the throne, made invoking evil spirits a hanging offence. In the remote Forest of Pendle, where roads were poor and harvests often failed, people already swapped stories about local healers who could help or harm with a muttered word. Those stories gained extra weight because the region still held strong Catholic sympathies while the state pushed Protestant conformity. Justices of the peace such as Roger Nowell therefore approached any hint of secret gatherings with extra caution, seeing possible links between religious dissent and darker threats.
Poverty sharpened the tension. Two families in particular, the Demdikes and the Chattoxes, survived on casual labour, begging and the small fees they charged for healing or curses. Neighbours who gave them bread one week could turn suspicious the next when crops failed or livestock sickened. The same economic strain that made charity necessary also made the recipients convenient targets when something went wrong. Nowell’s inquiries began in that atmosphere of scarcity and mutual distrust.
The Spark: Alizon Device’s Curse and Confession
On 18 March 1612 Alizon Device, roughly eighteen years old, stopped peddler John Law and asked for pins. Law refused. Within hours he suffered a sudden lameness that he blamed on her. He reported the incident to Nowell, who brought Alizon in for questioning. Under sustained pressure she described meeting a black dog that turned into a devil and demanded her soul. She also admitted using witchcraft against Law. Once that statement existed on paper, Nowell summoned her grandmother Elizabeth Southerns, known as Old Demdike, and her mother Elizabeth Device. Both women offered further confessions that named other local people. The pattern was simple: one admission produced names, those names produced more admissions, and the circle widened quickly.
The Chattox Family Dragged In
Attention soon turned to the rival Chattox household. Anne Whittle, called Old Chattox, and her daughter Anne Redfearne were questioned next. Old Chattox described a figure that looked like a man yet demanded her soul in exchange for the power to kill. She admitted causing three deaths, including that of a child. These statements, given after days of isolation and repeated questioning, supplied the names that filled the cells at Lancaster Castle. By April nine suspects were already held there, and conditions were harsh enough that one of them, Katherine Hewitt, died before any trial could begin.
Malkin Tower: The Plot to Free the Witches
The most dramatic claim concerned a meeting at Malkin Tower, the Device family home, on Good Friday. Elizabeth Device later said family members and Chattox relatives gathered there for a meal of stolen mutton and discussed blowing up the castle with gunpowder to free the prisoners. Her son James added that he attended with his own familiar, a black dog named Dandy, and that the group had talked of killing the king. Some accounts even described women turning into horses to carry the devil. Later historians note that the gathering may simply have been a worried family trying to decide what to do after several arrests; the more sensational details emerged only after further interrogations.
The Trials: Lancaster Assizes and Judge Bromley
Judge Edward Bromley opened the Lancaster Summer Assizes on 9 August 1612. Potts recorded the testimony in detail. Alizon Device repeated her account of cursing Law and the peddler himself was brought into court to show his limp. James Device described harming cattle and a man through his familiar. Old Demdike had already died in prison, so her earlier confession was read aloud. Elizabeth Device spoke of clay images and a brown dog named Ball. Anne Redfearne’s own mother testified against her. Alice Nutter, a woman of some property and a known Catholic recusant, refused to confess yet was still convicted. Nine people from the Pendle group received guilty verdicts for witchcraft and murder. A tenth, Jennet Preston from Yorkshire, was tried separately at York for bewitching a child and plotting against the king.
Executions: A Grim Spectacle on Gallows Hill
On 20 August 1612 the nine convicted at Lancaster were hanged on the moors outside the town. Old Chattox asked forgiveness for some of the acts she had confessed. Alice Nutter maintained her innocence until the end. James Device showed little remorse in his final moments. Jennet Preston was executed at York on 4 September. Potts noted that the weather stayed fine on the day of the Lancaster hangings, which he took as a sign of divine approval. Contemporary observers already found the scale of the executions striking.
Psychological and Social Underpinnings
No evidence of actual witchcraft has ever been found. The confessions match patterns seen in other pressured interrogations: sleep loss, leading questions and a shared cultural belief that such spirits existed. The Demdike and Chattox families had long been viewed as cunning folk who could be useful or dangerous depending on the need of the moment. Their poverty and the long-standing feud between the two households supplied ready material for accusations. Nine of the ten people executed were women, reflecting the wider tendency of witchcraft cases to focus on female suspects. Nowell’s energetic investigation may also have been shaped by local politics and the desire to demonstrate loyalty to a Protestant crown in a region still suspected of Catholic sympathies. King James himself never attended the trials, yet his published views on witchcraft in Daemonologie had already set the tone for how such cases should be handled.
Victim Profiles: Lives Cut Short
The ten people who died were not a uniform group. Elizabeth Southerns, known as Old Demdike, was an elderly blind woman who had worked as a healer. Her granddaughter Alizon was barely nineteen when the peddler incident occurred. James Device, Alizon’s brother, was a lame teenager described in court as having drooping eyes. Anne Whittle, Old Chattox, was another older woman who practised healing and was said to have feuded with the Demdikes over customers. Her daughter Anne Redfearne was accused of using magic to kill a child. Elizabeth Device, mother of Alizon and James, ended up testifying against relatives. Alice Nutter stood out as a woman of property who refused to confess. The remaining three, Henry Mitton, John Bulcock and Jane Bulcock, were drawn in through the widening circle of names. All of them lived on the margins of a society that offered few protections once suspicion took hold.
Legacy: From Pamphlet to Cultural Icon
Potts’ pamphlet sold well and helped shape later witch-hunting literature across England and beyond. Further trials occurred in the Pendle area in 1633 and 1634, though those cases ended differently when some of the accused child witnesses admitted they had lied. The story has continued to attract attention through historical novels, local tourism and modern memorials that mark the executions. Historians such as Robert Poole have used the records to show how ordinary disputes and official zeal could combine to produce mass convictions. The events still serve as a clear example of how fear, once given legal force, can override ordinary standards of evidence.
At Dyerbolical we have examined many such episodes from the same period, and the Pendle trials remain one of the clearest illustrations of how quickly local tensions could be turned into capital charges when authorities were already primed to see witchcraft at work. The human cost is visible in the simple fact that ten ordinary people, most of them poor and several of them elderly or unwell, were removed from their communities on the strength of confessions obtained under duress.
Bibliography
Thomas Potts, The Wonderfull Discoverie of Witches in the Countie of Lancaster (1613).
King James VI and I, Daemonologie (1597).
Robert Poole, The Lancashire Witches: Histories and Stories (Manchester University Press, 2002).
James Sharpe, Instruments of Darkness: Witchcraft in Early Modern England (University of Pennsylvania Press, 1997).
Jonathan Lumby, The Lancashire Witch-Craze: Jennet Preston and the Lancashire Witches (Carnegie, 1995).
Marion Gibson, Witchcraft: A History in Thirteen Trials (Simon & Schuster, 2023).
Records of the Lancaster Assizes, August 1612, held at the National Archives.
Contemporary accounts of the York trial of Jennet Preston, September 1612.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
