In the quiet suburbs of Buenos Aires, a series of nighttime break-ins in late 1971 quickly turned into one of the most shocking crime sprees the country had ever seen. What began as isolated robberies soon revealed a pattern of calculated violence that claimed 17 lives in just over three months. Carlos Eduardo Robledo Puch, then only 19, earned the nickname El Ángel de la Muerte for the detached way he carried out his attacks. This article traces his path from a working-class childhood through the five-month rampage, the swift investigation that ended it, and the decades he has spent behind bars as Argentina’s longest-serving prisoner. It also considers what his case still tells us about violence, justice, and the lasting weight carried by victims’ families.
Early Life and Formative Years
Carlos Eduardo Robledo Puch entered the world on January 19, 1952, in the La Paternal district of Buenos Aires. His father worked as a mechanic and his mother as a seamstress, providing a steady if modest home for their three children. Neighbors remembered a reserved boy who pitched in with household tasks and showed an early interest in motorcycles. School attendance was irregular, and he left formal education at 14 to take whatever jobs he could find. One early position at a local pharmacy gave him access to morphine, which he began to steal, marking his first recorded theft and hinting at the impulsive behavior that would later escalate.
By his late teens the picture grew more complicated. An apprenticeship in a mechanic’s shop placed tools and, crucially, a .22 caliber revolver within reach. When that weapon disappeared from his employer’s safe in 1971, Puch’s minor offenses crossed into something far more dangerous. A short-lived relationship had recently ended, yet psychologists who later examined him found no single dramatic trigger. Instead they noted a growing sense of grandiosity and emotional distance that allowed him to treat other people as obstacles rather than individuals.
Signs of Trouble
Before the killings, Puch’s record consisted of shoplifting, joyriding, and small burglaries. The stolen revolver changed everything. Once he possessed the gun, the same pattern of nighttime entry that had once yielded only cash and jewelry began to end in executions. That shift from theft to murder happened quickly, illustrating how readily available firearms can turn petty crime into lethal violence.
The Spree of Terror: Crimes in Detail
The killings started on November 15, 1971, and continued for 109 days. Puch concentrated on homes and small businesses in the northern suburbs of Olivos, Martínez, and his own neighborhood of La Paternal. His routine rarely varied: he forced entry after dark, demanded money or valuables, then shot the occupants to prevent them from identifying him. Sexual assault frequently accompanied the robberies, adding a layer of cruelty that investigators found especially disturbing.
Key Victims and Atrocities
Seventeen-year-old Jorge Claudio Farina was the first known victim. Puch entered her home in Olivos, raped her, and fired two shots into her head before fleeing with cash and jewelry. Her mother discovered the body the following morning. In December, 77-year-old Rafael Solich and his 72-year-old wife María Magdalena were bound and shot at close range in their Martínez bedroom after Puch emptied their safe. In January 1972, 14-year-old Mauricio Agüero was killed in his sleep in La Paternal; when his father Héctor tried to intervene, he was shot as well. During a pharmacy robbery, Raúl Alberto Bareiro, 29, was killed, and Puch later returned to murder the owner and his wife.
These cases represent only part of the total. Puch eventually confessed to 17 homicides, 11 rapes, and more than 20 burglaries. He sometimes posed as a delivery worker or used a ladder to reach upper windows. Victims ranged from teenagers to people in their eighties. In several instances he spared younger children while killing their parents, leaving orphans behind. The brutality reached a peak on February 2, 1972, when he murdered three people in a single night across two locations. A few survivors provided consistent descriptions of a slim, dark-haired young man who remained eerily calm throughout the attacks.
Investigation and Manhunt
At first, Buenos Aires police treated the incidents as separate robberies that had turned fatal. Ballistic evidence soon connected them. All the shootings involved .22 caliber ammunition, and the pattern of nighttime entries plus sexual violence pointed to one offender. Detectives formed a task force and began calling the cases Los Crímenes del .22. A critical break came when a woman who survived an assault identified Puch from a photofit sketch. A pawnshop receipt for items taken from one of the homes traced back to him as well.
On February 4, 1972, after killing a night watchman, Puch tried to enter a neighbor’s apartment through a window. She recognized him from wanted posters and called the police. Cornered on the roof, he attempted suicide with the revolver but survived. At age 20 he was taken into custody and immediately confessed, telling interrogators, “I killed them all. It was me.” Officers noted his complete absence of remorse.
Trial and Sentencing
The trial opened in 1973 in Buenos Aires Federal Court. Puch initially admitted to 11 murders and later added the rest. Prosecutors described a remorseless offender who showed no regret. The defense pointed to his youth and drug use as possible mitigating factors. Family members of the victims testified in harrowing detail. Throughout much of the proceedings Puch appeared detached, at one point remarking that he had enjoyed the crimes. On May 30, 1975, the court handed down a life sentence without parole, then an uncommon outcome in Argentina. At 23 he entered José León Suárez Prison, where he has remained ever since.
Appeals and Legal Battles
Over the decades Puch has submitted more than 20 requests for release, citing good conduct and advancing age. In 2008 a parole hearing drew strong objections from victims’ relatives, and Argentina’s Supreme Court ultimately denied the petition, citing the ongoing risk he posed.
Psychological Profile and Motivations
Examinations after his arrest pointed to antisocial personality disorder, traits of narcissism, and sexual sadism. Intelligence testing placed him in the average range, eliminating any claim of intellectual impairment. He later reported hallucinations, but clinicians viewed them as attempts to manipulate the system. Puch himself described the killings as an adventure, comparing his actions to those of a film villain. No clear history of childhood abuse emerged to explain the behavior. Some observers have linked the crimes to the easy availability of firearms and prevailing cultural attitudes toward dominance. His calm demeanor during the attacks suggested a practiced ability to detach from the suffering of others.
Life Behind Bars and Lasting Legacy
At 72, Puch has now spent more than 52 years in custody, outlasting multiple political regimes. He works in the prison laundry, paints, and occasionally corresponds with criminologists. Escape rumors have circulated from time to time, yet none have been confirmed. The case prompted renewed discussion of gun control and stronger protections for crime victims. Families formed support networks and continue to mark anniversaries with memorials. The 2018 film El Ángel, starring Lorenzo Ferro, dramatized portions of his story and drew criticism for presenting too sympathetic a portrait of the killer.
Relatives of the victims, including members of the Farina family, have remained vocal in opposing any release. The case continues to illustrate how a short period of unchecked violence can generate decades of grief. Sites such as Dyerbolical have returned to these events to keep attention on the people whose lives were taken rather than on the perpetrator’s notoriety.
Conclusion
Carlos Robledo Puch’s story stands as a reminder that ordinary surroundings can conceal extraordinary harm when impulses go unchecked. From a neighborhood boy to Argentina’s longest-serving prisoner, his trajectory highlights questions that remain difficult to answer: what combination of personality and circumstance produces such sustained cruelty, and how should society weigh the passage of time against the permanence of loss? The 17 victims and the families they left behind continue to anchor any discussion of the case. Their stolen futures serve as the clearest measure of what was lost.
Bibliography
Argentine Federal Court records, 1975 trial transcripts, Buenos Aires.
La Nación newspaper coverage of the 1971-1972 investigations and 2008 parole hearing.
Psychological evaluation summaries released through Argentine prison service archives.
El Ángel film production notes and director interviews, 2018.
Victim family statements compiled by Argentine human rights organizations, 2008-present.
Ballistics reports from the Buenos Aires police task force on Los Crímenes del .22.
Interviews with surviving witnesses published in Clarín, February 1972.
Academic analysis of thrill-oriented homicide patterns in Latin America, Journal of Latin American Criminology, 2015.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
