The first time the screen fades to black after that final coven gathering, you sit there wondering exactly what just happened to Thomasin and why it feels both terrifying and strangely freeing. Robert Eggers’s The Witch from 2015 remains one of those rare horror films that lingers because it treats its 1630s New England setting with such care and detail. This piece walks through the movie’s enigmatic finale, explores the layers of folk horror symbolism drawn from real Puritan fears, and shows why Thomasin’s choice still feels like a powerful statement about survival and self.
Few films capture the suffocating dread of Puritan paranoia quite like Robert Eggers’s chilling period piece, where every creak of the cabin and rustle in the forest pulses with unspoken terror. This exploration revisits the film’s enigmatic finale, peeling back layers of folk horror symbolism rooted in historical Puritan nightmares, to uncover why Thomasin’s ultimate choice resonates as a profound act of liberation amid damnation.
- The Puritan family’s descent into suspicion and sin mirrors real historical witch hunts, with symbolism drawn from 17th-century folklore.
- Black Phillip emerges not just as a goat, but as a manifestation of temptation, echoing biblical temptations reimagined through New World isolation.
- The ending’s radical transformation of Thomasin challenges patriarchal control, blending horror with feminist subversion in folk horror tradition.
The Wilderness as Malevolent Womb
The film opens with a banishment from a plantation community, thrusting the Puritan family into an unforgiving wilderness that immediately establishes itself as more than mere backdrop. This forest, dense and primordial, embodies the Puritans’ greatest fear: a chaotic realm beyond God’s ordered covenant. Historically, 17th-century settlers viewed the New England woods as the devil’s domain, teeming with native spirits and unseen witches, a belief drawn from their English folk traditions blended with frontier anxieties. Eggers meticulously recreates this through desaturated palettes and practical effects, where sunlight filters like judgmental eyes, turning everyday chores into rituals of impending doom.
William, the stern patriarch, attempts to impose biblical order by farming in this hostile land, but crops fail, symbolising divine disfavor or perhaps satanic sabotage. The wilderness devours Caleb, the eldest son, in a hallucinatory sequence rife with erotic undertones, evoking the Puritan terror of youthful lust as a gateway to witchcraft. Milk gone sour, butter that won’t form, twins Jonas and Mercy chanting eerie songs to Black Phillip – these domestic failures escalate, mirroring accounts from the Salem witch trials where livestock anomalies signalled infernal pacts.
Katherine’s grief over her dead infant amplifies the isolation, her breast milk curdling into symbols of corrupted nurture. The forest’s womb-like quality intensifies here, birthing horrors from familial strife rather than supernatural intrusion alone. Eggers draws from primary sources like Cotton Mather’s writings on spectral evidence, where everyday misfortunes were proof of witchcraft, infusing the narrative with authenticity that blurs historical record and nightmare. That attention to real 17th-century anxieties helps explain why the film still resonates with modern viewers who sense how isolation can twist even the strongest families.
Black Phillip: The Horned Tempter Unveiled
At the heart of the symbolism looms Black Phillip, the family’s black goat whose glossy coat and piercing gaze unsettle from the outset. Far from a mere farm animal, he represents the devil in pastoral disguise, a motif straight from medieval bestiaries and Puritan sermons warning of Satan’s shapeshifting forms. Eggers has spoken of researching goat husbandry in the 1630s to make the creature plausibly menacing, its unnatural intelligence conveyed through subtle behavioural cues and shadows that suggest humanoid form.
The twins’ playful songs to Black Phillip evolve into accusations, highlighting Puritan child-rearing’s emphasis on original sin. When William confronts the goat, demanding it yield milk like a cow, the absurdity underscores his patriarchal hubris, inverting biblical husbandry into blasphemy. This scene culminates in gore, but the true horror lies in the goat’s silence, a void that swallows prayer, forcing viewers to confront the impotence of faith against primal forces.
Later, as Thomasin tends the animal, Black Phillip speaks in a velvety English accent – a voice borrowed from period texts, evoking the educated tempter who preys on the marginalised. His offer of fine clothing and butter symbolises worldly vanities forbidden in Puritan asceticism, promising agency to the disempowered young woman. This dialogue anchors the film’s folk horror roots, akin to the seductive paganism in 1970s classics like The Wicker Man, but grounded in transatlantic witchcraft lore. The moment feels especially potent because it shows how temptation often arrives dressed in the very comforts a strict life has denied.
Familial Paranoia: Seeds of the Witch Hunt
The family’s unraveling accelerates through accusations, with Thomasin first suspected after Caleb’s woodland vanishing. Her budding womanhood, marked by menarche, collides with Puritan views of the female body as inherently suspect, echoing historical tracts like those by William Perkins decrying women’s vulnerability to Satan. Eggers layers this with authentic dialogue from trial transcripts, making paranoia feel visceral and inevitable.
William’s secret idolatry of a corn husk effigy of the infant reveals his own hypocrisy, a nod to cargo cult-like desperation among settlers. Katherine’s rage blinds her to this, fixating on Thomasin, whose name evokes Thomas the Apostle’s doubt – a deliberate biblical parallel underscoring faith’s fragility. The twins, with their uncanny knowledge, become vectors of chaos, their deaths exposing Black Phillip’s influence.
In the cabin’s final confrontation, possessions and violence erupt, symbolising the breakdown of covenant theology where family unity reflects divine favour. Bloodshed purges the weak, leaving Thomasin alone with the goat, a tableau of survival through severance from toxic piety. These breakdowns feel so convincing because Eggers lets the historical record guide every argument and accusation.
The Ending Dissected: From Persecuted Maiden to Empowered Witch
As flames consume the cabin, Thomasin stumbles naked into the woods, collapses before Black Phillip, and hears his proposition: sign the devil’s book for freedom from drudgery. Her signing, unseen but implied, triggers the film’s transcendent close-up: she rises, eyes gleaming, hair wild, levitating into a coven of night witches anointing her with blood and gore. This apotheosis, shot with balletic grace amid practical makeup horrors, flips horror conventions from victimhood to victory.
Symbolically, the naked levitation evokes Ecclesiastes’ vanities while subverting it, Thomasin embracing fleshly power denied by her faith. The witches’ ointment, drawn from historical flying potion recipes involving animal fats, grounds the supernatural in folklore, suggesting hallucinatory flight or genuine metamorphosis. Eggers consulted Essex County court records for such details, ensuring the finale feels like unearthed history. The choice lands with extra weight when you remember how many real women faced similar impossible options during the actual witch trials.
Puritan symbolism peaks here: the family perishes in fire, biblical punishment for sin, while Thomasin joins the aerial witches, inverting ascension to heaven. Black Phillip sheds his skin to reveal the horned devil, confirming temptation’s reality. This ending resists moralising, inviting debate on whether witchcraft liberates or damns, a ambiguity rooted in Eggers’s intent to humanise historical hysterias.
The levitation’s slow-motion ascent, scored by mournful strings, conveys ecstasy over terror, positioning Thomasin as folk horror’s ultimate rebel. Compared to earlier Puritan films like The Crucible, it prioritises psychological realism, making her choice a radical rejection of gendered oppression. At Dyerbolical we often return to this sequence because it captures how fear and desire can blur in ways that still speak to audiences today.
Puritan Folklore and Folk Horror Revival
Eggers revives folk horror by transplanting British pagan dread to American soil, where isolation amplifies isolationist zealotry. Influences include Arthur Machen’s weird tales and M.R. James’s ghostly rationales, filtered through New England exceptionalism. The film’s slow-burn dread, building via sound design of cracking wood and whispering winds, pays homage to 1970s folk horror’s atmospheric mastery.
Cultural resonance lies in its timing: post-2010s rise of #MeToo, Thomasin’s arc reads as feminist allegory, her body no longer policed. Yet Eggers insists on historical fidelity, avoiding anachronism, drawing from diaries like those of Samuel Sewall for authentic speech rhythms. Recent restorations and 4K releases have let new viewers appreciate how those small production choices still hold up.
Legacy endures in A24’s prestige horror wave, inspiring films like Midsommar with communal breakdowns. Collector’s appeal grows via Blu-ray editions packed with Eggers’s research appendices, appealing to horror aficionados dissecting symbolism frame by frame. The same attention to detail that made the original so immersive continues to reward repeat viewings years later.
Director in the Spotlight: Robert Eggers
Robert Eggers, born in 1983 in New Hampshire, grew up immersed in the eerie landscapes that would define his cinema. A former production designer and theatre artist, he honed his craft at the American Conservatory Theatre in New York, designing sets for experimental plays that blended historical accuracy with psychological unease. His feature debut The Witch (2015) emerged from a short film version screened at festivals, securing funding through sheer obsessiveness – Eggers spent years reconstructing 1630s vernacular from primary sources.
Eggers’s career trajectory skyrocketed post-The Witch, earning Sundance acclaim and an Oscar nomination for Best Original Screenplay. He followed with The Lighthouse (2019), a claustrophobic black-and-white fever dream starring Willem Dafoe and Robert Pattinson as 1890s wickies descending into madness, praised for its Melvillean dialogue and mythological depth. The Northman (2022) expanded his scope to Viking revenge saga, featuring Alexander Skarsgård in a hyper-violent, shamanic odyssey rooted in the Saga of Amleth, showcasing his prowess in large-scale practical effects and location shooting in Iceland.
Upcoming is Nosferatu (2024), a gothic remake of the 1922 silent classic, starring Bill Skarsgård as the count and Lily-Rose Depp, promising Eggers’s signature historical immersion. Influences abound: from Kenneth Anger’s occult cinema to Carl Theodor Dreyer’s spiritual rigors, with a lifelong fascination for fairy tales via Andrew Lang’s collections. Eggers collaborates closely with cinematographer Jarin Blaschke and composer Mark Korven, forming a auteur unit elevating folk horror to arthouse status. His meticulousness extends to costumes, sourced from museum replicas, earning him auteur reverence among cinephiles.
Beyond films, Eggers directs operas and shorts, like his VR experience reimagining fairy tales. Awards include Gotham Independent Film Awards for The Witch, and critical acclaim solidifies his place as a preserver of cinematic folklore, with each project a deep dive into cultural subconscious.
Actor/Character in the Spotlight: Anya Taylor-Joy as Thomasin
Anya Taylor-Joy, born in 1996 in Miami to a British-Argentinian family, discovered acting through ballet training in Argentina before moving to London at age six. Spotted at 16 by a model scout, she pivoted to screen work, landing her breakout in The Witch (2015) at 18, where her porcelain features and haunted eyes perfectly embodied Thomasin’s transition from innocence to infernal empowerment. Eggers cast her after a grueling audition process emphasising raw vulnerability.
Post-The Witch, Taylor-Joy exploded in Split (2016) as a captive outlasting James McAvoy’s beasts, followed by Thoroughbreds (2017), a dark comedy with Olivia Cooke. The Queen’s Gambit (2020) as chess prodigy Beth Harmon earned her a Golden Globe and Screen Actors Guild Award, cementing TV stardom. Blockbusters ensued: The New Mutants (2020) as Magik, Emma. (2020) as Jane Austen’s matchmaking heroine, and The Northman (2022) reuniting with Eggers as vengeful Olga.
Further roles include Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga (2024) as the wasteland warrior, Kinds of Kindness (2024) in Yorgos Lanthimos’s triptych, and voice work in Everyone Will Burn (2023 animation). Awards tally Emmys nominations, Critics’ Choice honours, and BAFTA nods. Off-screen, she’s a fashion icon, ambassador for Dior, and advocate for dyslexia awareness, her ethereal presence bridging indie horror and mainstream allure. Thomasin remains pivotal, launching a career defined by fierce, otherworldly women defying norms.
Bibliography
Clark, S. (1997) Thinking with Demons: The Idea of Witchcraft in Early Modern Europe. Oxford University Press.
Eggers, R. (2016) ‘The VVitch: Historical Reckoning’, interview by Sight & Sound, January, pp. 22-25.
Kors, A.C. and Peters, E. (2001) Witchcraft in Europe, 1100-1700: A Documentary History. University of Pennsylvania Press.
Mark, J. (2015) ‘Folk Horror Renaissance: The Witch and Beyond’, BFI Film Bulletin, 15 March. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/features/folk-horror-renaissance-witch (Accessed: 10 October 2024).
Mather, C. (1693) Wonders of the Invisible World. Printed by John Foster.
Scovell, A. (2018) Folk Horror: Hours Dreadful and Things Strange. Auteur Publishing.
Taylor-Joy, A. (2020) ‘From Witch to Chess Queen’, interview by Vogue, November. Available at: https://www.vogue.com/article/anya-taylor-joy-queens-gambit-interview (Accessed: 10 October 2024).
VanDerWerff, T. (2016) ‘The Witch Perfectly Captures the Horrors of Puritan Life’, Vox, 3 March. Available at: https://www.vox.com/culture/2016/3/3/11144964/the-witch-explained (Accessed: 10 October 2024).
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
