In the quiet of a 1630s New England clearing, a single family clings to faith while the surrounding woods press closer each night. Robert Eggers’ The Witch from 2015 captures that tension so well that many viewers return to it again and again, hoping to catch every layer of its slow-building terror.
This folk horror film, subtitled A New-England Folktale, draws straight from old diaries and trial records to show how religious intensity, family strain, and hints of the supernatural can twist together until nothing feels safe. The story follows every crack that appears in the household and leads right up to its unforgettable final moments, where one young woman steps away from everything she has known.
The Godly Farmstead’s Slow Decay
Robert Eggers drops us straight into the rigid world of 1630s New England. William, played by Ralph Ineson, has been cast out of the plantation community because his beliefs are stricter than those around him. With his wife Katherine and their children, he starts over on a small farm at the edge of the forest. The trees become more than scenery. They feel like a living presence that watches and waits.
Thomasin, the oldest daughter brought to life by a young Anya Taylor-Joy, stands at the center of the growing unease. She is just reaching the age where her body and thoughts begin to pull away from the strict rules of her parents. When her baby brother Samuel disappears while she watches him, the family starts to unravel. Crops wither, animals die without clear reason, and quiet suspicions turn into open accusations. Eggers uses real 17th-century speech taken from journals and court papers, so every line of prayer or argument lands with the weight of history.
The parents carry their own burdens. William’s drive for independence hides a deeper pride, while Katherine holds tight to grief and scripture. The younger twins chant strange rhymes that hint at something darker, and young Caleb struggles with feelings he cannot name. These small fractures grow until the family turns on itself, much like the real fears that would later fuel the Salem trials.
Black Phillip: Horns of Temptation
One figure stands out from the start. Black Phillip, the large black goat kept by the family, moves through the story with an intelligence that feels wrong. His eyes catch the light at odd moments, and the sound of his hooves carries through the quiet. Eggers has shared in interviews that the name comes from old witch trial accounts where animals often served as messengers for darker forces.
As troubles pile up, the children begin to claim the goat speaks to them, offering gifts and comfort. In one tense night scene the animal rises with sudden power, its shape lit by firelight in a way that recalls old drawings of the devil. The moment shows how everyday things could become signs of evil in a world that saw constant battle between faith and temptation.
The goat also stands for the forest itself. To the Puritans the woods held both real danger and the pull of everything their faith tried to shut out. Black Phillip gives shape to that pull, promising a kind of freedom that the family’s rules could never allow.
Thomasin’s Crucible: Blood, Shame, and Liberation
Thomasin’s journey carries the heart of the film. After Samuel vanishes she faces blame tied to her age and changing body. Searches and questions strip away what little privacy she has left. Taylor-Joy lets us see the fear turn into something harder and more determined as the days pass.
When Caleb returns from the woods he speaks in feverish riddles about a naked woman who tempted him. The household breaks into open panic. William strikes out in confusion and rage, leaving Thomasin alone among the bodies of her family. Her nightdress stained with blood marks the end of one life and the start of another.
In the final clearing Black Phillip appears in human form, tall and horned, and offers her a choice. She accepts. What follows is not punishment but release. She joins the other women in the woods, sheds her clothes, and rises into the night on a broom. The scene turns the usual story of sin and damnation on its head. For Thomasin the forest becomes a place of power instead of fear.
Apples of Discord: Biblical Echoes in the New World
Eggers fills the film with quiet nods to the Bible. Apples appear at key moments, reminding viewers of the fruit that brought knowledge and exile. Katherine’s desperate vision of nursing her lost child from a goat twists the idea of innocence into something unsettling. A silver cup taken by the twins echoes stories of betrayal and lost trust.
Blood runs through many scenes, from Caleb’s fevered return to the final slaughter. These images draw on real writings by Cotton Mather, who described how unseen forces could affect the visible world. Eggers flips the old fear by showing that the strictest believers often created the very threats they dreaded.
The muted colors of the film match the plain clothing rules of the time. Every brown and gray tone keeps the focus on faces and small gestures rather than spectacle. Practical effects, such as the aging prosthetics on the woodland woman and the detailed movements of the goat, keep the horror grounded and immediate.
Puritan Paranoia: Historical Mirrors and Modern Fears
Eggers spent years reading Plymouth records and sermons by Increase Mather. The family’s arguments over who is saved and who is not reflect real debates that split early colonies. One such conflict led to Roger Williams being sent away for believing grace mattered more than strict law.
That same pressure feels familiar today whenever rigid beliefs push people to the edges. Thomasin’s final choice speaks to anyone who has felt trapped by family or community expectations. Her flight on the broom becomes a quiet act of defiance against years of control.
The film arrived during a wave of thoughtful horror from A24. It helped open doors for later slow-burn stories like Hereditary and Midsommar. At its Sundance debut some viewers found the pace too quiet, yet word spread and the movie built a lasting audience that still discusses its details years later.
Soundscape of the Damned: Audio as Conjurer
Mark Korven built the score around old instruments that sound like wind moving through empty rooms. The waterphone and nyckelharpa create tones that sit just outside normal hearing. When the actors speak in period English, modern ears must lean in, which adds to the sense of distance from our own time. Long stretches of near silence let the forest itself become part of the tension.
Cinematographer Jarin Blaschke worked with natural light alone. Golden afternoons give way to nights so dark the characters seem to float in shadow. The result feels less like a modern movie and more like a window into another century.
Legacy of the Folktale: From Festival Darling to Cultural Touchstone
A24 sold the film with trailers that gave almost nothing away. Online forums filled with theories about whether the events were real or imagined. Eggers has always left room for both readings. After the rise of the MeToo movement many viewers saw Thomasin’s story as one of hard-won independence rather than simple tragedy.
Posters of Black Phillip and handmade brooms still sell to collectors who want a piece of the film’s mood. Scholars continue to write about its use of historical language and imagery. While talk of a sequel surfaces now and then, Eggers has stayed focused on new projects that keep the same care for detail.
Director in the Spotlight: Robert Eggers
Robert Eggers grew up in New Hampshire surrounded by old stories and objects. Summers spent in a seaside antiques shop gave him a lasting interest in how people lived centuries ago. He began in theater, creating shows that pulled audiences into the world on stage. The Witch was his first feature after nearly ten years of research and short films.
He has worked closely with childhood friend Jarin Blaschke on every project. Their films favor careful research over quick effects. After The Witch came The Lighthouse in 2019, a stark tale of two men losing their grip on reality. The Northman followed in 2022, bringing Viking history and myth to the screen with brutal clarity. His take on Nosferatu arrived in 2024, restoring gothic shadows and practical horror to a classic tale.
Eggers keeps returning to characters caught between old beliefs and personal desire. For those who want to know more about his approach to storytelling, Dyerbolical offers a closer look at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.
Actor/Character in the Spotlight: Anya Taylor-Joy as Thomasin
Anya Taylor-Joy was born in Miami and spent part of her childhood in Argentina. Ballet classes there led to modeling work and then to acting. At eighteen she stepped into the role of Thomasin, a part that asked her to carry both fear and growing strength across the entire film. Critics noticed immediately.
Her next years moved quickly. She appeared in Split, then Thoroughbreds, and later earned wide praise for The Queen’s Gambit. Period pieces like Emma. and sharp modern stories like The Menu showed her range. In 2024 she took on the origin story of Furiosa, bringing the same quiet intensity to a very different world.
Thomasin remains one of her most striking early performances because it let her show a character discovering power instead of waiting for rescue. Taylor-Joy has spoken about how the role changed the way she approached later parts that explore control and freedom.
Bibliography
Bradshaw, P. (2016) The Witch review – bewitching, hallucinatory horror. The Guardian.
Eggers, R. (2015) The Witch: Director’s research diary. Filmmaker Magazine.
Korven, M. (2016) Scoring The Witch: Instruments of dread. Synthax.
Mather, C. (1693) Wonders of the Invisible World. Boston: John Dunton.
Patterson, H. (2016) The VVitch: Robert Eggers on historical accuracy. Empire Magazine.
Reinhardt, M. (2015) Folk horror roots: The Witch and New England occultism. Sight & Sound.
Taylor-Joy, A. (2020) Interview: From The Witch to chess queen. Vogue.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
