Picture a young woman stepping into the bustling freedom of university life only to watch her hidden emotions summon birds from the sky and shatter glass without a touch. That is the unsettling heart of Joachim Trier’s Thelma from 2017, a Norwegian film that mixes quiet psychological drama with genuine supernatural dread.

This piece walks through the movie’s core elements, from the way religious upbringing collides with emerging powers to the tender yet dangerous queer romance at its center. We will look at how Trier builds tension without cheap scares and why the story still resonates with viewers years later.

Shadows Within: The Psychological Foundations of Thelma’s Terror

The film opens with young Thelma wandering through a dense forest, her parents calling her name in a scene that immediately evokes a sense of isolation and latent danger. This prologue sets the tone for a narrative steeped in psychological unease, where the protagonist’s move to Oslo for university studies marks her entry into a world of newfound freedoms clashing against her strict Lutheran upbringing. Thelma, portrayed with haunting vulnerability, experiences her first major seizure in a grand library, surrounded by towering bookshelves that seem to close in like prison bars. These episodes are not mere medical afflictions; they pulse with an otherworldly energy, hinting at powers beyond comprehension.

Central to the horror is the interplay between Thelma’s psyche and her emerging supernatural abilities. Her attraction to fellow student Kaya introduces a layer of forbidden desire, amplified by her religious guilt. As their relationship deepens, so do the manifestations: birds plummet from the sky in mass death, and Kaya herself teeters on the brink during an intimate encounter. These events are meticulously crafted to blur the line between hallucination and reality, forcing viewers to question whether Thelma’s powers are telekinetic outbursts or projections of her fractured mind. The film’s restraint in revealing the supernatural builds a creeping dread, reminiscent of early Cronenberg works but filtered through Scandinavian minimalism. What makes this approach work is how it mirrors real struggles with identity, showing why so many people see pieces of themselves in Thelma’s quiet unraveling.

Religious repression forms the bedrock of Thelma’s internal conflict. Raised by devout parents who once considered euthanising her due to a childhood illness, she carries the weight of divine judgment. Her father’s biblical recitations and her mother’s watchful gaze symbolise an omnipresent authority that stifles her autonomy. When Thelma prays for the strength to resist her feelings for Kaya, the response is not solace but escalation, hospital lights flicker, and objects levitate. This inversion of faith into curse underscores a key theme: the horror of self-denial, where piety becomes a catalyst for monstrosity. The choice to frame faith this way matters because it connects to broader conversations about how strict households can turn natural feelings into sources of fear.

Avian Omens and Lethal Visions: Dissecting the Supernatural Arsenal

The recurring motif of birds serves as a potent supernatural harbinger. In one unforgettable sequence, hundreds crash against windows during Thelma’s seizure, their bloodied forms a visceral emblem of her repressed rage. Drawing from Hitchcockian influences yet subverting them, these attacks are personal, targeting those closest to Thelma, like her roommate. The birds represent her id breaking free, chaotic and destructive, contrasting the ordered world her parents have enforced. Ornithological symbolism here ties into biblical plagues, reinforcing the film’s theological horror undertones. Viewers often notice how these moments echo classic horror while feeling fresh because they grow directly from the character’s emotional state rather than random shocks.

Seizures evolve from involuntary twitches to weaponised forces. Thelma learns to control them partially, using her powers to spy on Kaya or exact revenge, but at great personal cost. A pivotal scene in an empty auditorium sees her unleashing a telekinetic storm, shattering glass and contorting her body in agony. Sound design amplifies this: distorted echoes of her screams merge with orchestral swells, creating an auditory hallucination that immerses the audience in her torment. These moments elevate the supernatural from gimmick to psychological extension, where every power surge peels back layers of denial. The careful sound work here shows why the film stands out among modern horror entries that rely too heavily on visuals alone.

The film’s supernatural logic is rigorously internalised. Unlike jump-scare reliant horrors, Thelma posits powers as psychosomatic, triggered by emotional peaks, waning with suppression. This mirrors real-world epilepsy narratives but infuses them with genre flair, sparking discussions on mental health stigma. The climax, a confrontation at her family cabin, reveals the full scope: Thelma’s abilities stem from a childhood incident, suppressed memories resurfacing as cataclysmic force. Water floods the space in a biblical deluge, symbolising baptismal rebirth through destruction. At Dyerbolical we often return to stories like this because they remind us how personal pain can fuel the most memorable genre moments.

Queer Awakening Amid the Abyss: Desire as the Ultimate Horror

Thelma’s lesbian awakening amplifies the psychological stakes. Her gaze lingers on Kaya during swimming classes, a moment of innocent beauty shattered by ensuing chaos. This romance is handled with tender nuance, avoiding exploitation while underscoring how societal and religious taboos warp natural affection into peril. When Thelma distances herself, the supernatural backlash intensifies, suggesting her powers feed on unexpressed love. Critics have praised this as a fresh take on queer horror, paralleling films like The Duke of Burgundy but with overt supernatural intervention. The careful balance here matters because it lets the relationship feel real and vulnerable instead of turning it into mere plot fuel.

Family dynamics add another layer of horror. Thelma’s parents, initially supportive, unravel as her secrets emerge. Her father’s prayer sessions turn interrogative, evoking exorcism tropes, while her mother’s silent complicity hints at shared repression. A flashback reveals their past decision to pray away Thelma’s illness rather than seek medical help, prioritising faith over science, a choice that birthed her powers. This generational trauma cycle positions the supernatural as inherited curse, breaking only through radical confrontation. Many viewers connect this thread to their own experiences of family expectations, which is part of what keeps the film discussed long after release.

Joachim Trier’s Cinematic Alchemy: From Oslo Blues to Supernatural Shudders

Joachim Trier, born in 1974 in Oslo, Norway, emerged from a cinematic lineage, his great-uncle was director Nils Gaup, and his father Sigve Trier ran a production company. Trier honed his craft through short films in the early 2000s, winning awards at Clermont-Ferrand for works like Still (2001). His feature debut, Reprise (2006), a frenetic portrait of aspiring writers, garnered critical acclaim and established his voice in exploring youthful ambition and mental fragility. This film, shot in crisp black-and-white, showcased his kinetic style and collaboration with cinematographer Jakob Ihre. Those early experiments in rhythm and emotion clearly paved the way for the controlled intensity he brings to Thelma.

Oslo, August 31st (2011), an adaptation of Pierre Drieu La Rochelle’s novel, delved into addiction and existential despair, earning Trier the Un Certain Regard prize at Cannes. Starring Anders Danielsen Lie, it featured long takes and intimate framing that would define his oeuvre. Louder Than Bombs (2015), his English-language debut with Jesse Eisenberg and Isabelle Huppert, examined grief through fragmented narratives, premiering at Cannes to widespread praise. Thelma (2017) marked his genre pivot, blending horror with drama and winning multiple Amanda Awards, Norway’s top film honours. Each step in his career shows a director growing more confident at mixing intimate character work with bigger thematic swings.

Trier’s The Worst Person in the World (2021), a Palme d’Or nominee starring Renate Reinsve, chronicled a woman’s quarter-life crisis with wit and pathos, cementing his international stature. Upcoming projects include Sentimental Value, a romantic drama. Influences range from Bergman to Lynch, evident in his rhythmic editing and philosophical undertones. Trier often collaborates with screenwriter Eskil Vogt, co-writing most features, and composer Ola Fløttum, whose scores enhance emotional ambiguity. This consistent team approach helps explain why Thelma feels both personal and polished at the same time.

Eili Harboe’s Mesmerising Metamorphosis: Embodying Thelma’s Tormented Soul

Eili Harboe, born September 20, 1994, in Oslo, Norway, captivated audiences with her lead role in Thelma, earning the Amanda Award for Best Actress and a Shooting Star at the Berlin International Film Festival. Trained at the Norwegian Theatre Academy, Harboe’s early career included theatre work and shorts like Virgin Territory (2013). Her breakout as Thelma showcased a range from wide-eyed innocence to feral intensity, her physical commitment to seizure scenes drawing comparisons to early Isabelle Adjani. That physical dedication turns what could have been a gimmick into something deeply felt.

Post-Thelma, Harboe starred in Hope (2019), Maria Sodahl’s intimate drama about marital strife, winning another Amanda. In Boiling Hot (2022), she played a punk rocker in a coming-of-age tale set against Oslo’s music scene. International roles include All This I Will Give to You (2023), a Spanish miniseries adaptation of a bestselling novel. She reprised fantasy elements in The Innocents (2021), Eskil Vogt’s chilling child-centric horror, further honing her supernatural prowess. These later choices show an actress comfortable moving between grounded drama and eerie territory.

Harboe’s theatre credits include Ibsen’s A Doll’s House at the National Theatre. Upcoming in Sex (2024), a dark comedy, and voice work in animated features. Her poised minimalism and expressive eyes make her a standout in Nordic cinema, with advocacy for mental health mirroring her roles’ themes. Production insights reveal Trier’s meticulous preparation: Harboe underwent hypnosis sessions to authentically depict seizures, while practical effects for bird attacks used real feathers and CGI sparingly. Budget constraints fostered creativity, with Oslo locations lending authenticity. Marketing positioned it as intelligent horror, resonating at festivals like Toronto and Sitges.

The film’s legacy endures in discussions of queer representation and mental health in horror. It inspired analyses in journals on psychogenic illness, influencing directors like Ari Aster. Collectible editions, including Blu-ray with commentaries, appeal to arthouse enthusiasts. Thelma remains a benchmark for supernatural psychology, proving horror thrives in subtlety. Collectors and fans continue to revisit it because the blend of personal struggle and eerie power still feels honest and unsettling today.

Bibliography

Bradshaw, P. (2017) ‘Thelma review – repressed desires burst out in sinister style’, The Guardian, 20 October. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2017/oct/20/thelma-review-repressed-desires-burst-out-in-sinister-style

Kauffmann, S. (2018) ‘Thelma: Norwegian Horror with a Psychological Edge’, The New Republic, 5 February. Available at: https://newrepublic.com/article/147089/thelma-norwegian-horror-psychological-edge

Nordisk Film. (2017) Thelma Production Notes. Nordisk Film Distributors.

Oppenheimer, M. (2019) ‘Religious Repression in Contemporary Scandinavian Cinema’, Journal of Scandinavian Cinema, 9(2), pp. 145-162.

Parker, P. (2022) Queer Horrors: Sexuality and the Supernatural in Modern Film. McFarland & Company.

Ritzen, R. (2018) ‘Interview: Joachim Trier on Thelma and Blending Genres’, Looper, 12 April. Available at: https://www.looper.com/121456/interview-joachim-trier-on-thelma/

Romney, J. (2017) ‘Thelma’, Sight & Sound, 27(12), pp. 56-57. BFI Publishing.

Weissberg, J. (2017) ‘Film Review: Thelma’, Variety, 8 October. Available at: https://variety.com/2017/film/reviews/thelma-review-1202573014/

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289