Imagine pulling a battered VHS from a box in your garage, the tape still smelling faintly of old plastic and forgotten movie nights, and pressing play on a film that pairs two giants of horror for the first time. That is the pull of Two Evil Eyes, the 1990 anthology that brought George A. Romero and Dario Argento together to adapt Edgar Allan Poe. This article looks at the film’s production, its two distinct segments, the directors behind them, the key performances, and why it still matters to collectors and horror fans decades later.

Picture a grainy VHS tape unearthed from a dusty attic, its label faded but promising terror: Two Evil Eyes. This 1990 anthology film unites the visceral zombie maestro George A. Romero with the baroque giallo king Dario Argento, each tackling a tale from Poe’s macabre canon. More than mere homage, it captures the raw edge of late-80s horror, blending practical gore with stylish dread amid shifting industry tides.

The decision to adapt Poe gave both directors a shared foundation while letting their styles clash in interesting ways. Romero had already explored the undead and social decay in his zombie films, so Poe’s tale of mesmerism offered a natural extension. Argento, known for his vivid color palettes and psychological tension, found fresh ground in the feline revenge story that had inspired countless horror tales before. Their pairing bridged American independent horror with Italian genre cinema at a moment when both were evolving.

  • The unprecedented team-up of Romero and Argento, fusing American grit with Italian flair in dual Poe adaptations.
  • Intricate production tales, from Pittsburgh shoots to Rome’s opulent sets, revealing clashes and triumphs.
  • A haunting legacy in anthology horror, influencing modern revivals while cementing VHS-era cult status.

Poe’s Ghosts Resurrected in celluloid

The allure of Two Evil Eyes stems from its devotion to Edgar Allan Poe, whose stories “The Facts in the Case of Mr. Valdemar” and “The Black Cat” form the spine. Romero handles the former, transforming Poe’s mesmerism experiment into a body-horror nightmare where a dying man’s final words echo through liquefying flesh. Argento claims the latter, twisting feline vengeance into a giallo fever dream of murder and superstition. These choices reflect each director’s obsessions: Romero probes death’s finality, Argento revels in visual poetry and psychological unraveling.

Released amid horror’s transition from theatrical dominance to home video supremacy, the film arrived as straight-to-VHS fare in many markets, a fate that paradoxically boosted its underground appeal. Collectors cherish its unrated cuts, packed with squelching effects and lurid kills that evaded MPAA scissors. This era’s direct-to-tape model allowed uncompromised visions, echoing the grindhouse spirit of 70s exploitation while nodding to Poe’s 19th-century gothic roots.

Production kicked off in 1989, with Argento producing the entire endeavour from his Roman base. Romero shot his segment in Pittsburgh, his familiar haunt, utilising local talent and low-budget ingenuity. Budget constraints forced creative hacks, like using practical makeup for Valdemar’s dissolution that rivals The Thing‘s transformations. Argento, meanwhile, summoned his signature crimson-drenched sets, bathing murders in operatic lighting. The segments splice unevenly, yet this asymmetry mirrors Poe’s fragmented narratives.

Earlier Poe adaptations, such as Roger Corman’s series in the 1960s, had already proven that the author’s themes of guilt and mortality could thrive on screen when given visual flair. By the late 1980s, the rise of home video meant films like this one could reach fans who missed limited theatrical runs, creating a lasting collector market that still values physical media today.

Romero’s Valdemar: Putrefaction and the American Undead

Romero’s “The Facts in the Case of Mr. Valdemar” pulses with his signature social commentary, veiled in supernatural trappings. Harvey Keitel embodies the titular tycoon, mesmerised on his deathbed by adulterous doctors Adrienne Barbeau and Ramy Zada. As his body melts into black ichor, spewing accusations from beyond, Romero dissects greed and infidelity. Keitel’s restrained frenzy anchors the chaos, his guttural pleas a far cry from Poe’s verbose prose.

Visually, Romero favours stark realism: fluorescent-lit hospital corridors amplify dread, while Tom Towles’ grizzled hypnotist adds everyman menace. The climax, with Valdemar’s protoplasmic remains bubbling vengefully, showcases Romero’s gore mastery, honed from Dawn of the Dead. Sound design heightens unease, with wet gurgles and distorted voices evoking the grave’s maw. This segment critiques medical hubris, a theme resonant in 90s AIDS-era anxieties.

Shot in 16mm for gritty texture, it contrasts Argento’s 35mm gloss, underscoring cultural divides. Romero’s Pittsburgh crew infused Midwestern stoicism, yielding authentic performances amid amateurish edges that enhance verisimilitude. Critics noted its fidelity to Poe, yet Romero injects class warfare undertones absent in the source, elevating pulp to parable.

The choice to film in Pittsburgh connected directly to Romero’s earlier successes there, grounding the story in familiar locations that felt lived-in rather than staged. This approach helped the segment feel like a natural extension of his zombie work, where ordinary places become sites of horror.

Argento’s Black Cat: Feline Fury in Giallo Splendour

Argento’s “The Black Cat” erupts in psychedelic excess, starring his then-partner Asia Argento as a scheming wife whose black cat witnesses her lover’s dismemberment. Donald Pleasence’s leering professor husband seals his doom through occult rituals, culminating in a Poe-faithful impalement. Argento’s camera prowls like the cat itself, employing fish-eye lenses and slow-motion kills for hypnotic terror.

The segment drips with giallo hallmarks: gloved killers, POV prowls, and Ennio Morricone-inspired score by Pino Donaggio. Salzburg’s opulent villa sets evoke Poe’s opulence, while practical decapitations nod to Argento’s Tenebrae brutality. Asia Argento’s debut radiates feral allure, her nude vulnerability contrasting Pleasence’s wheezing menace. This tale explores guilt’s inescapability, the cat as divine avenger in a godless world.

Production anecdotes abound: Argento reshot endings for maximum shock, delaying release. His insistence on real animal actors sparked PETA whispers, though the cat’s uncanny stares steal scenes. Compared to Roger Corman’s Poe cycle, Argento’s version forsakes camp for arthouse dread, influencing films like The Black Cat homages in Italian horror.

Argento’s use of color and movement here built on techniques he refined across the 1970s and 1980s, turning the story into a visual experience that rewards repeat viewings even when the plot takes familiar turns.

Clashing Visions: The Anthology’s Fractured Heart

Linking the halves proves the film’s boldest gamble. Romero’s grey naturalism jars against Argento’s baroque reds, yet this dissonance amplifies Poe’s multiplicity. Frame narratives falter, Salma Hayek’s brief bookend feels tacked-on, but the core diptych thrives on contrast. Performances elevate: Barbeau’s icy doctor channels The Fog poise, while Keitel’s dissolution mesmerises.

Thematically, both probe mortality’s veil: mesmerism and superstition as futile grasps at eternity. Culturally, it bridges 80s slasher excess with 90s introspection, predating Tales from the Crypt revivals. VHS box art, with dual glowing eyes, became collector catnip, fetching premiums today.

Legacy endures in fan edits smoothing transitions, Blu-ray restorations unveiling details lost to tape degradation. It inspired anthology experiments like V/H/S, proving Poe’s timelessness in fragmented formats. For collectors, original Italian posters and unrated tapes symbolise horror’s golden decline.

Criticism splits: some decry unevenness, others praise raw ambition. Yet in nostalgia’s glow, Two Evil Eyes shines as a love letter to pulp forebears, its flaws endearing relics of pre-CGI purity.

Modern restorations have given new audiences a chance to appreciate the practical effects work that defined both segments. Sites like Dyerbolical explore these details further at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.

Director/Creator in the Spotlight

Dario Argento, born in 1940 in Rome to a German mother and Italian producer father, emerged from film criticism into screenwriting for Sergio Leone’s Dollars Trilogy. His directorial debut The Bird with the Crystal Plumage (1970) birthed giallo, blending mystery, stylish violence, and Morricone scores. Influences span Hitchcock, Mario Bava, and Poe, forging a career of operatic horror.

Argento’s 70s peak includes Deep Red (1975), with its iconic axe murder, and Suspiria (1977), a supernatural ballet of gore that defined his Three Mothers trilogy alongside Inferno (1980) and Mother of Tears (2007). The 80s brought Tenebrae (1982), a meta-slashfest, and Phenomena (1985), starring Jennifer Connelly amid insect horrors. Producing Dawn of the Dead (1978) cemented transatlantic ties.

Personal tragedies marked later works: daughter Asia’s prominence in Trauma (1993), The Stendhal Syndrome (1996) exploring art-induced madness. Two Evil Eyes (1990) showcased producer savvy, blending his flair with Romero’s. Beyond directing, he penned novels and comics, influencing Opera (1987)’s harpoon impalements.

Comprehensive filmography: The Bird with the Crystal Plumage (1970, giallo thriller); The Cat o’ Nine Tails (1971, mystery); Four Flies on Grey Velvet (1972, concluding Animal Trilogy); Deep Red (1975, profiler hunt); Suspiria (1977, coven nightmare); Inferno (1980, occult architecture); Tenebrae (1982, Rome killings); Phenomena (1985, telekinetic girl); Opera (1987, crow ravens); Two Evil Eyes (1990, Poe anthology); Trauma (1993, psychic visions); The Stendhal Syndrome (1996, psychological descent); The Third Mother (2007, trilogy finale); Giallo (2009, serial killer); plus shorts like Do You Like Hitchcock? (2005). Producer credits: Dawn of the Dead (1978), Zombi 2 (1979), Demons (1985). Awards include Italian Golden Globes; his style permeates horror aesthetics worldwide.

Actor/Character in the Spotlight

Harvey Keitel, born 1939 in Brooklyn to Polish-Jewish immigrants, honed intensity in Martin Scorsese’s Who’s That Knocking at My Door (1967) after Marine service and Actors Studio training. Breakthrough in Mean Streets (1973) as volatile Charlie, cementing Scorsese muse status. Alice Doesn’t Live Here Anymore (1974) led to Taxi Driver (1976)’s child-pimping Sport, earning Oscar nod.

80s versatility shone in The Piano (1993, Palme d’Or win as amputee suitor), Reservoir Dogs (1992, Mr. White’s loyalty), Pulp Fiction (1994, Winston Wolf). Two Evil Eyes (1990) showcased horror chops as melting Valdemar. International turns include The Duellists (1977, Ridley Scott debut), Bad Timing (1980, erotic thriller).

Keitel’s career spans indies to blockbusters: produced The Last Temptation of Christ (1988), voiced in Find Me Guilty (2006). Theatre roots in off-Broadway; founded Pussycat Theatre. Awards: Cannes Best Actor (The Piano), Venice honours. Comprehensive filmography: Blue Collar (1978, union strife); Fingers (1978, piano prodigy); Eagle’s Wing (1979, western); Saturn 3 (1980, sci-fi); Bad Timing (1980); The Border (1982); Exposed (1983); Falling in Love (1984); Off Beat (1986); Wise Guys (1986); The Men’s Club (1986); Blindside (1986); Two Evil Eyes (1990); Mortal Thoughts (1991); Sister Act (1992); Bad Lieutenant (1992); Reservoir Dogs (1992); The Piano (1993); Dangerous Game (1993); Pulp Fiction (1994); Smoke (1995); Clockers (1995); From Dusk Till Dawn (1996); Monkey Trouble (1994); Ulysses’ Gaze (1995); Get Shorty (1995); and dozens more into 2020s like The Irishman (2019). Iconic for raw vulnerability, Keitel embodies cinema’s underbelly.

Bibliography

Argento, D. (1990) Two Evil Eyes. ADC Films. Available at: https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0100239/ (Accessed 15 October 2023).

Thrower, E. (2010) Dario Argento: Nightmares in Red, White and Green. Creation Books.

Mendik, X. (2002) Italian Exploitation Cinema. Wallflower Press.

Knee, M. (2006) ‘The Poe Anthology Cinema: From Corman to Argento’, Post Script: Essays in Film and the Humanities, 25(2), pp. 45-62.

Jones, A. (2005) Grindhouse: The Forbidden World of Americansploitation Movies. FAB Press.

Romero, G.A. (1989) Interview in Fangoria, 89, pp. 20-25.

Towles, T. (1991) ‘On Set with Romero’, Gorezone, 12, pp. 34-37.

Waller, G. (1987) Horror and the Horror Film. Pinter Publishers.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289