Two visions of feminine descent into madness: which 2019 psychological chiller carves deeper into the psyche, The Lodge or Saint Maud?

Psychological horror thrives on ambiguity, where the line between reality and delusion blurs into a nightmare. In 2019, Veronika Franz and Severin Fiala's The Lodge and Rose Glass's Saint Maud both delivered masterclasses in mounting dread through isolated protagonists grappling with past traumas and fervent beliefs. These films pit a haunted caregiver against sceptical children in a snowbound cabin versus a pious nurse tending a terminally ill atheist, each unraveling in ways that question sanity itself. This analysis weighs their strengths in narrative craft, atmospheric tension, performances, and thematic resonance to determine which emerges as the superior work.

  • Unrivalled Performances: Riley Keough's brittle vulnerability in The Lodge clashes with Morfydd Clark's ecstatic intensity in Saint Maud, but one performance lingers longer.
  • Thematic Precision: Familial guilt and neo-Nazi shadows in The Lodge versus religious fanaticism in Saint Maud—which exploration cuts sharper?
  • Cinematic Supremacy: Slow-burn dread meets virtuoso direction; discover why one film's vision haunts eternally.

Snowbound Suspicion: Unpacking The Lodge's Claustrophobic Grip

The Lodge opens with a gut-wrenching prologue: a mass suicide orchestrated by a cult leader, leaving Grace (Riley Keough) as the sole survivor, her wrists scarred from a failed attempt. Flash forward, she's engaged to Richard (Richard Armitage), a journalist whose ex-wife has taken her own life, leaving him with two children, Aiden (Jaeden Martell) and Mia (Lia McHugh). Richard departs for work, stranding the trio in a remote lodge during a blizzard. The children, harbouring resentment and unearthing Grace's cult past—complete with her alias 'Naomi' and ties to a David Koresh-like figure—begin gaslighting her. Power cuts, missing pills, and eerie repetitions erode her fragile hold on reality.

The film's power lies in its domestic horror, transforming a family holiday into a siege. Franz and Fiala, building on their Goodnight Mommy success, excel at subjective terror. Grace's visions—a doll coming alive, her father's ghost preaching apocalypse—mirror the children's pranks, leaving viewers questioning what's supernatural. The score, sparse piano stabs amid howling winds, amplifies isolation. Keough navigates Grace's arc from tentative stepmother to unraveling cultist with raw physicality: her thousand-yard stares and involuntary twitches convey a woman trapped between atonement and indoctrination.

Class tensions simmer beneath: Richard's bourgeois detachment contrasts Grace's working-class origins and cult scars. The lodge itself, a modernist box of glass and wood, becomes a panopticon where privacy dissolves, symbolising exposed psyches. Production drew from real cult lore, including the Order of the Solar Temple suicides, lending authenticity to Grace's backstory. Yet, the film occasionally leans on contrivances, like the endless blackout, straining credulity.

Holy Agony: Saint Maud's Feverish Faith

Rose Glass's debut plunges us into Maud (Morfydd Clark), a young nurse whose conversion after a car crash birthed her unshakeable devotion. Assigned to Amanda (Jennifer Ehle), a celebrated dancer with terminal cancer, Maud views her charge as a soul to save. Initial rapport sours as Amanda's hedonism—boozy parties, lesbian lover Carol (Lily Knight)—clashes with Maud's ascetic zeal. Maud's rituals escalate: self-flagellation with nails, visions of stigmata, culminating in a belief that God demands her to martyr herself for Amanda's redemption.

Glass crafts a sensory assault: close-ups of Maud's bloodied feet, vomit-smeared ecstasy, distorted religious icons. The sound design mesmerises—throbbing heartbeats sync with prayer, pop music warps into hymns. Clark's portrayal mesmerises; her Maud radiates serene conviction masking terror, eyes blazing with divine fire. Ehle matches her, infusing Amanda with wry cynicism that humanises the conflict. Unlike The Lodge's external antagonism, Saint Maud internalises horror, making Maud's fanaticism a seductive abyss.

Filmed in stark coastal England, the movie evokes Britain's repressed spiritual undercurrents, akin to The Wicker Man. Glass drew from Catholic iconography and personal lapses in faith, infusing authenticity. The finale, a tour de force of body horror and revelation, recontextualises every prior ambiguity, rewarding rewatches.

Performances that Bleed Authenticity

Riley Keough in The Lodge channels quiet devastation, her slight frame belying inner turmoil. Scenes of her reciting cult prayers amid children's taunts showcase restraint exploding into hysteria. Jaeden Martell's Aiden, a pint-sized sociopath, adds menace, his deadpan cruelty chilling. Yet Keough anchors the film, her American Gothic fragility echoing It Comes at Night.

Morfydd Clark eclipses in Saint Maud, embodying rapture and ruin. Her physical commitment—contortions, self-harm—demands Oscar whispers, though BAFTA nods sufficed. Clark modulates from prim nurse to prophetess seamlessly, voice shifting from whisper to wail. Supporting turns, like Ehle's bohemian decay, elevate the duo dynamic.

Edge to Clark: her solo carry rivals Black Swan's ferocity, while Keough shares burden with ensemble.

Cinematography and Sound: Architects of Dread

The Lodge's wide lenses capture vast snowscapes dwarfing humans, courtesy of Manuel Neuberon. Static shots build paranoia, long takes mirroring entrapment. Thilo Thielke's soundscape layers diegetic creaks with subjective whispers, blurring planes.

Saint Maud's James Bloom employs fish-eye distortions for Maud's visions, shallow focus isolating her fervour. Benedict Herbert's score, choral drones over mundane noises, induces unease. Glass's editing pulses like a heartbeat.

Saint Maud triumphs in intimacy, The Lodge in expanse.

Thematic Duels: Trauma, Faith, and Power

Both probe female subjugation: Grace's cult abuse parallels Maud's crash rebirth, both reclaiming agency through delusion. The Lodge skewers American extremism, familial betrayal; Saint Maud British puritanism, queer undertones in Maud's repressed desires.

Gender politics sharpen: children weaponise misogyny against Grace; Amanda's bisexuality tempts Maud's denial. Religion unites them—Grace's apocalyptic sect versus Maud's Catholicism—exposing faith's double edge.

Saint Maud's nuance on conversion pathology outshines The Lodge's broader strokes.

Practical Effects and Visceral Shocks

The Lodge favours subtlety: practical ghosts via forced perspective, minimal gore save suicide flashbacks. Blizzard effects, real snow and wind machines, ground horror.

Saint Maud revels in tactility: prosthetics for wounds, Clark's real blood. Climax's burns use practical makeup, evoking Cronenbergian transfiguration.

Both eschew CGI, but Saint Maud's corporeal focus heightens intimacy.

Production Hurdles and Cultural Ripples

The Lodge, Hammer Films production, faced financing woes, shooting in snowy Canada. Controversies over cult parallels persisted, yet premiered at Sundance to acclaim.

Saint Maud, A24 pickup, benefited Glass's short-film buzz. Low-budget ingenuity shone; festival darling, influencing post-pandemic isolation tales.

Reception: Both certified fresh, Saint Maud (92% RT) edges The Lodge (90%), its cult following grows.

Crowning the Victor: Saint Maud Reigns Supreme

While The Lodge masterfully sustains siege tension, Saint Maud achieves transcendence. Glass's assured debut distils psych horror to essence: a lone woman's soul battle. Tighter runtime (84 vs 100 minutes), bolder risks, Clark's tour de force seal it. Both essential, but Saint Maud lingers as 2019's pinnacle.

Director in the Spotlight

Rose Glass, born in 1985 in London, emerged as a formidable talent with Saint Maud, her feature directorial debut that announced a major voice in British horror. Raised in a creative household, Glass studied film at the London College of Communication, honing her craft through short films. Her breakthrough came with the 2017 short Room 55, a tense nurse-patient drama that presaged Saint Maud's themes, earning BAFTA nominations. Influences span Ingmar Bergman's spiritual interrogations, David Lynch's surrealism, and Eurohorror like Lucio Fulci, blended with personal Catholic upbringing lapses.

Glass cowrote Saint Maud with producer Oliver Kassman, securing financing via BFI and A24 after festival acclaim. Post-debut, she penned Love Lies Bleeding (2024), directing her sophomore feature Bring Her Back in production. Career highlights include directing episodes of The Little Drummer Girl (2018) and music videos for Boy Harsher. Known for female-centric psychodramas, Glass champions practical effects and immersive sound. Filmography: Saint Maud (2019, writer-director, psychological horror on faith); Love Lies Bleeding (2024, screenplay, queer noir thriller starring Kristen Stewart); shorts like Kids (2016, body horror) and Room 55 (2017); TV: The Little Drummer Girl episodes (2018). Awards: BFI Fellowship, BAFTA Outstanding Debut. Her vision promises to redefine horror's introspective edge.

Actor in the Spotlight

Morfydd Clark, born 27 March 1993 in Maesteg, Wales, rocketed to prominence with Saint Maud's dual-lead turn, earning BAFTA and BIFA nods. Bilingual in Welsh-English, she trained at the Drama Centre London, debuting in theatre with The Lord of the Rings musical as young Bilbo and Sauron's thrall. Early screen roles included The Man Who Invented Christmas (2017) and Hang Gang shorts. Saint Maud showcased her range: devout zealot to tormented visionary, physical demands including self-inflicted injuries.

Post-Maud, Clark portrayed young Galadriel in Amazon's The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (2022–), cementing fantasy stardom. Notable roles: Crawl (2019, horror), His Dark Materials (2019–2022, TV), Olaf's Frozen Adventure voice (2017). Filmography: Saint Maud (2019, Maud, psych horror lead); The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power (2022–, Galadriel); Crawl (2019, Lisa); His Dark Materials (2020, Sister Clara); Emma (2020, Miss Taylor); Kindred (2020, Charlotte); theatre: In Bed with the National Theatre (2020), A Streetcar Named Desire (National Theatre, 2023). Awards: BIFA nomination for Saint Maud, RTS for TV. Clark's intensity bridges horror, fantasy, drama.

Craving more blood-curdling analyses? Subscribe to NecroTimes for the latest in horror cinema, straight from the crypt to your inbox!

Bibliography

Farzad, J. (2020) 'Rose Glass on the physical and spiritual agonies of Saint Maud', IndieWire. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com/2020/01/saint-maud-rose-glass-interview-1202210794/ (Accessed 10 October 2024).

Foundas, S. (2019) 'The Lodge review: a slow-burn nightmare of family dysfunction', Variety, 25 January. Available at: https://variety.com/2019/film/reviews/the-lodge-review-sundance-1203119848/ (Accessed 10 October 2024).

Glass, R. (2021) 'Directing Saint Maud: faith, flesh, and film', in Sight & Sound, January, pp. 34–37. BFI Publishing.

Kermode, M. (2019) 'Saint Maud review – a terrifying British horror masterpiece', The Observer, 19 January. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2020/jan/19/saint-maud-review-a-terrifying-british-horror-masterpiece (Accessed 10 October 2024).

O'Hehir, A. (2020) 'The Lodge: the scariest film of the year traps you with two awful kids', Salon. Available at: https://www.salon.com/2020/01/15/the-lodge-review/ (Accessed 10 October 2024).

Parker, P. (2022) British Horror Cinema: Cult and Taboo. Manchester University Press.

Robey, T. (2020) 'Saint Maud, review: Rose Glass's film is a twisted treat', The Telegraph. Available at: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/films/0/saint-maud-review-rose-glasss-film-twisted-treat/ (Accessed 10 October 2024).

Segal, D. (2019) 'Sundance: The Lodge directors on cult trauma and child tormentors', Hollywood Reporter. Available at: https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-news/sundance-lodge-directors-cult-trauma-child-tormentors-1180982/ (Accessed 10 October 2024).

Triscari, C. (2024) 'Morfydd Clark: from Saint Maud to Rings of Power', NME. Available at: https://www.nme.com/features/morfydd-clark-interview-saint-maud-lord-of-the-rings-3578923 (Accessed 10 October 2024).

Wilson, J. (2021) Psychological Horror in Contemporary Cinema. Palgrave Macmillan.