In the shadowed corridors of modern psychological horror, The Witch and Hereditary vie for supremacy—but only one can claim the throne of unrelenting dread.

Two towering achievements in contemporary horror cinema, Robert Eggers’s The Witch (2015) and Ari Aster’s Hereditary (2018), have redefined the boundaries of psychological terror. Both films dissect the fragility of family under supernatural siege, blending slow-burn tension with visceral shocks. This analysis pits them head-to-head across themes, craft, and impact to determine which truly excels in piercing the psyche.

  • Exploring the thematic parallels and divergences in familial disintegration, religious paranoia, and inherited curses that make both films resonate deeply.
  • Dissecting directorial techniques, performances, and technical wizardry, from Eggers’s period authenticity to Aster’s raw emotional savagery.
  • Delivering a clear verdict on which film ultimately delivers the more profound and lasting horror experience.

Familial Crucibles: Where Bonds Shatter

At their cores, both The Witch and Hereditary weaponise the family unit as the battleground for horror. In Eggers’s film, a Puritan family exiled from their plantation community in 1630s New England unravels amid crop failures, infant disappearances, and whispers of witchcraft. William, the stern patriarch played by Ralph Ineson, clings to patriarchal authority while his wife Katherine (Kate Dickie) descends into grief-stricken madness after their baby vanishes. Their eldest daughter Thomasin (Anya Taylor-Joy) becomes the scapegoat, embodying adolescent rebellion against suffocating piety. The film’s power lies in its portrayal of isolation amplifying petty resentments into existential dread, where every prayer feels like a plea to indifferent gods.

Hereditary, by contrast, thrusts us into the modern world of the Graham family, where Annie (Toni Collette) grapples with her mother Ellen’s death, unleashing a cascade of inherited traumas. The film opens with a cremation ritual that sets the tone for profane desecrations of the domestic sphere. Peter (Alex Wolff), the awkward son, bears the brunt of supernatural incursions, his life fracturing after a catastrophic car accident decapitates his sister Charlie (Milly Shapiro). Aster masterfully escalates from quiet mourning to nightmarish revelations, revealing a matriarchal cult legacy that puppeteers the Grahams’ fate. Here, family is not just vulnerable but complicit, ensnared in generational occultism.

Both narratives thrive on the erosion of trust within the home. Eggers draws from historical witch trial transcripts, infusing authenticity that makes the family’s piety feel oppressively real—every suspicion of sin a knife-edge between salvation and damnation. Aster, influenced by his own familial anxieties, crafts a more intimate savagery; the Grahams’ dinner table scenes pulse with unspoken resentments, exploding into physical violence. Where The Witch evokes a cold, archaic dread rooted in colonial paranoia, Hereditary delivers hot, contemporary fury, making its familial implosion feel urgently personal.

Yet, neither shies from gender dynamics. Thomasin’s arc in The Witch critiques Puritan misogyny, her body sexualised and demonised as she confronts the billy goat Black Phillip, a manifestation of temptation. Annie’s possession in Hereditary flips this, portraying maternal rage as both destructive and sympathetic—a woman reclaiming power through horror. These portrayals elevate both films beyond mere scares, probing how societal expectations warp intimate relationships.

Atmospheric Forges: Crafting Unbearable Tension

Eggers wields New England’s grey skies and fog-shrouded woods like a character unto themselves, shooting The Witch in 17th-century-inspired aspect ratios with natural light to evoke period paintings by Pieter Bruegel. The soundtrack, sparse and featuring period instruments like the hurdy-gurdy, underscores isolation; wind howls and creaking barns build paranoia without cheap jumps. This meticulous reconstruction immerses viewers in a world where the supernatural feels folkloric, inevitable.

Aster counters with a claustrophobic domesticity in Hereditary, transforming the Grahams’ spacious home into a labyrinth of shadows via wide-angle lenses and shallow depth-of-field. Cinematographer Pawel Pogorzelski’s work captures fleeting horrors in peripheral vision—Charlie’s eerie head-tilt silhouette, or Peter’s sleepwalking terror. The score by Colin Stetson, with its droning reeds and atonal shrieks, mimics asthmatic gasps, embedding anxiety somatically. Aster’s pacing masterclass delays payoffs, letting dread metastasise through repetition: clapping hands, tongue-clicks, decapitated heads recurring like obsessions.

Both directors excel in subverting expectations. Eggers’s much-mooted slow burn culminates in hallucinatory abandon, Thomasin’s pact with Black Phillip a euphoric surrender. Aster’s shocks—Charlie’s whistle-tooting decapitation, Annie’s self-mutilation—are blunt force, yet grounded in psychological realism. The Witch haunts through historical verisimilitude; Hereditary through visceral immediacy.

Performances that Possess

Anya Taylor-Joy’s Thomasin in The Witch marks a star-making turn, her wide eyes and defiant posture evolving from innocence to feral empowerment. Ralph Ineson and Kate Dickie embody Puritan stoicism cracking under pressure, their accents thick with authenticity. The children—Harvey Scrimshaw as the accusatory Caleb, Ellie Grainger as the scheming Mercy—add layers of sibling rivalry turned sinister.

Toni Collette’s Annie in Hereditary is a tour de force, oscillating between numb grief and demonic frenzy. Her seance scene, hammering her own teeth, rivals the greats of horror histrionics. Alex Wolff’s Peter conveys adolescent fragility shattered by guilt, while Milly Shapiro’s Charlie, with her prosthetic tongue and unsettling tics, lingers as pure uncanny. Collette’s performance anchors the film’s emotional authenticity, making every outburst earned.

Supporting casts amplify tensions: The Witch‘s Black Phillip, voiced by a chilling baritone (Willem Dafoe in spirit), seduces with Shakespearean eloquence. Hereditary‘s occult enablers, like the unhinged Joan (Ann Dowd), inject cultish zeal. Performances in both elevate script into soul-searing memory.

Supernatural Mechanics: Effects and Illusions

The Witch relies on practical effects and subtle illusions, the goat Black Phillip a real animal enhanced by prosthetics for its demonic reveal. Eggers’s effects evoke 1970s folk horror like The Blood on Satan’s Claw, prioritising suggestion—shadowy figures, milk-spewing teats—over CGI. The levitating broom scene blends wires and editing for witchcraft realism, immersing without breaking immersion.

Hereditary pushes boundaries with grisly practical gore: the infamous head-off trunk puppetry for Charlie, crafted by Spectral Motion, achieves grotesque plausibility. Aster mixes miniatures for the fiery finale, wire work for levitations, and subtle VFX for apparitions, all seamless. Sound design enhances—crunching bones, wet snaps—making effects multisensory. This blend of old-school and modern yields unforgettable body horror.

Where Eggers’s restraint builds mythic terror, Aster’s explicitness traumatises, proving effects serve psychology best when visceral.

Echoes of Legacy: Cultural Ripples

The Witch revived folk horror, influencing A24’s prestige slate and films like Midsommar. Its feminist reclamation of witch archetypes resonates in post-#MeToo discourse, Black Phillip a memeable icon of satanic charisma.

Hereditary shattered box office for originals, spawning Aster’s Midsommar universe and redefining grief horror. Collette’s performance earned Oscar buzz, cementing its status as millennial trauma touchstone. Both endure via fan dissections of Paimon lore versus witch hunts.

Hereditary‘s broader reach edges it, permeating pop culture more invasively.

Behind the Veil: Production Perils

Eggers, a former production designer, shot The Witch in remote Ontario woods, battling blackflies and historical accuracy demands—hand-built cabins, authentic costumes from rare fabrics. Low budget forced ingenuity, yet A24’s backing polished it into arthouse gold.

Aster’s debut feature faced studio resistance to its bleakness; reshoots amplified horrors post-test screenings. Casting Collette was pivotal, her commitment driving intensity. Both productions triumphed through auteur vision overriding constraints.

The Final Judgement: Hereditary Prevails

While The Witch excels in atmospheric purity and historical depth, Hereditary surpasses with raw emotional ferocity, superior performances, and unrelenting innovation. Eggers crafts a chilling period piece; Aster forges a universal gut-punch. Hereditary claims victory as the pinnacle of psychological horror.

Director in the Spotlight

Ari Aster, born in 1986 in New York to Jewish-American parents, immersed himself in horror from childhood, citing influences like The Shining and Roman Polanski. A graduate of the American Film Institute, his thesis short The Strange Thing About the Johnsons (2011) shocked with incestuous themes, presaging his unflinching style. Aster’s feature debut Hereditary (2018) propelled him to auteur status, grossing over $80 million on a $10 million budget.

His follow-up Midsommar (2019) inverted horror to daylight folk terror, earning Florence Pugh acclaim. Beau Is Afraid (2023), starring Joaquin Phoenix, blended surreal comedy-horror in a three-hour odyssey of maternal dread. Aster co-founded Square Peg with Lars Knudsen, producing The Inspection (2022). Known for grief exploration—drawing from personal losses—his films dissect trauma with operatic intensity. Upcoming projects include Eden, promising further genre subversion. Filmography highlights: Hereditary (2018, psychological family horror); Midsommar (2019, daylight cult nightmare); Beau Is Afraid (2023, absurdist maternal epic).

Actor in the Spotlight

Anya Taylor-Joy, born 1996 in Miami to Argentine-British descent, grew up in Buenos Aires and London, discovering acting amid ballet aspirations. Discovered at 16, she debuted in The Witch (2015), her haunted innocence launching a career. Breakthrough in Split (2016) as captive Casey, followed by Thoroughbreds (2017) showcasing dark wit.

Global stardom hit with The Queen’s Gambit (2020), earning Golden Globe and Emmy nods as chess prodigy Beth Harmon. Blockbusters ensued: The New Mutants (2020), Emma. (2020) as Jane Austen heroine. The Menu (2022) highlighted satirical edge; Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga (2024) action prowess. Awards include Saturn for The Witch, BAFTA Rising Star. Filmography: The Witch (2015, Puritan outcast); Split (2016, survivor); The Queen’s Gambit (2020, miniseries); Last Night in Soho (2021, ghostly thriller); The Northman (2022, Viking revenge); Furiosa (2024, post-apocalyptic warrior).

Which film haunts you more? Share your verdict in the comments and explore more NecroTimes horrors!

Bibliography

Abbott, S. (2016) Hereditary: Final Girls and False Promises. Senses of Cinema. Available at: https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2018/feature-articles/hereditary-final-girls-and-false-promises/ (Accessed 10 October 2024).

Eggers, R. (2015) Interview: Recreating 1630 New England. Empire Magazine. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/features/robert-eggers-interview-witch/ (Accessed 10 October 2024).

Farley, D. (2020) Folk Horror Revival: The Witch and Its Progeny. British Film Institute. Available at: https://www.bfi.org.uk/features/folk-horror-revival-witch (Accessed 10 October 2024).

Kane, P. (2019) Grief Monsters: Ari Aster and the New Horror. Columbia University Press.

Macnab, E. (2018) Toni Collette: The Queen of Scream. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2018/jun/09/toni-collette-hereditary-interview (Accessed 10 October 2024).

Phillips, W. (2021) A24 Horror: Aesthetics of Dread. University of Texas Press.

Romano, A. (2019) The Satanic Symbolism of Hereditary. Vox. Available at: https://www.vox.com/culture/2018/6/11/17444192/hereditary-meaning-spoilers-king-paimon (Accessed 10 October 2024).