Get Out vs The Menu: Which Jordan Peele Classic or Ralph Fiennes Satire Exposes Elite Privilege with Greater Force?

Two films feast on the follies of the elite, blending terror with trenchant wit – yet only one leaves an indelible scar on cinema’s psyche.

In the realm of psychological horror, few subgenres pack as potent a punch as satire aimed at societal ills. The Menu (2022) and Get Out (2017) stand as towering achievements, each dissecting privilege through a lens of dread and dark humour. One skewers the pretensions of haute cuisine and class warfare, the other exposes the insidious underbelly of liberal racism. This analysis pits them head-to-head, probing their narratives, techniques, and enduring resonance to crown a victor in this battle of biting critiques.

  • Shared Satirical Core: Both films lambast white liberal hypocrisy and class entitlement, using confined settings to amplify unease.
  • Divergent Delights: Get Out excels in racial allegory and cultural specificity, while The Menu savours broader absurdism in foodie fascism.
  • Ultimate Edge: Get Out triumphs through innovative horror mechanics, tighter social commentary, and seismic cultural impact.

Unpacking the Platters: Narrative Foundations

The premise of The Menu, directed by Mark Mylod, unfolds on a secluded island where a cadre of wealthy foodies assembles for an exclusive dining experience curated by the enigmatic Chef Slowik, portrayed with chilling charisma by Ralph Fiennes. As the courses progress, what begins as avant-garde experimentation spirals into a macabre ritual of retribution. Diners, including influencers, critics, and executives, confront their complicity in a system that commodifies art and lives alike. Margot (Anya Taylor-Joy), a last-minute addition, becomes the fulcrum of resistance, her outsider status mirroring the film’s assault on exclusivity. The script, penned by Seth Reiss and Will Tracy, builds tension through escalating revelations: a s’more laced with fatal intent, a chef’s suicide mirroring his creations, and a finale that immolates pretension in literal flames.

Contrast this with Get Out, Jordan Peele’s directorial debut, where Chris Washington (Daniel Kaluuya) accompanies his white girlfriend Rose (Allison Williams) to her family’s pastoral estate. Initial awkwardness – teacups trembling from maternal hypnosis, groundskeeper’s guttural tears – escalates into horror as Chris uncovers a auction of black bodies for transplantation into white hosts. The Armitage family embodies performative allyship, their “progressive” facade crumbling under auctioneer Dean Whitman’s gavel. Peele’s screenplay weaves Sunken Place metaphor into every frame, from the deer collision prologue to the flashbulb-triggered hypnosis, culminating in a cataclysmic escape fueled by blind-side heroism.

Both narratives thrive in isolation: Hawthorn’s remote restaurant akin to the Armitages’ labyrinthine home, trapping victims in privilege’s web. Yet Get Out‘s plot coils with mechanical precision, each clue – the butler and maid’s vacant stares, Rose’s curated Tinder facade – ratcheting dread organically. The Menu, while inventive, occasionally veers into ensemble sprawl, diluting focus amid a dozen archetypes. The former’s linear ascent to apocalypse feels inexorable; the latter’s menu-driven structure, though clever, risks predictability in its course-by-course carnage.

Key to both is the protagonist’s perceptiveness. Margot intuits Slowik’s madness early, scavenging survival amid slaughter; Chris pieces the puzzle via furtive smartphone research and cotton-mouthed visions. These everyman anchors ground the absurdity, transforming satire into visceral stakes. Production histories underscore contrasts: The Menu shot amid pandemic restrictions on a Scottish isle, its claustrophobia heightened by real isolation; Get Out, bootstrapped on $4.5 million, leveraged practical effects for authenticity, Peele drawing from his Key & Peele sketch roots. That modest budget mattered because it forced Peele to rely on sharp writing and performances rather than spectacle, a choice that still resonates in how audiences connect with the story years later.

Slicing Through Facades: Thematic Parallels and Divergences

At their core, both films eviscerate elite self-delusion. The Menu targets culinary snobbery, where Slowik’s “art” devolves into murder, indicting diners who pay fortunes for fleeting transcendence. Scenes of dissecting celebrities echo real-world chef tyrannies, like the scandals plaguing high-end kitchens. Class animus peaks in the financier’s comeuppance, his ledger of exploitation torched alongside his life. Gender threads emerge too: Margot’s sex work past weaponised against her, yet reclaimed in subversion. These elements connect because they show how systems of power reduce people to commodities, a theme that feels especially relevant as conversations around labor exploitation in creative industries continue today.

Get Out sharpens the blade on racial liberalism, the Armitages’ “I would have voted for Obama a third time” liberalism a trojan horse for eugenics. The Sunken Place symbolises marginalisation, voices stifled while bodies exploited. Economic undertones persist – black excellence commodified for aging whites’ vigour – but race dominates, from cuckold fetishism to genetic envy. Peele layers historical nods: auction parallels slave blocks, deer hunts evoke lynching imagery. The specificity here matters because it turns personal experiences into something viewers can recognise in everyday interactions, making the horror land closer to home.

Satire’s efficacy hinges on specificity. Get Out‘s microaggressions – “Is it true… bigger?” – land with surgical precision, drawn from Peele’s life. The Menu‘s broader strokes amuse: a critic’s pretentious notes, a celebrity couple’s performative wokeness. Yet the former indicts a zeitgeist, post-Obama unease; the latter critiques a niche, fine dining’s bubble. Intersectionality favours Peele: race trumps class in American horror’s lexicon. One way to see the difference is how Get Out invites repeated viewings to catch new layers, while The Menu delivers its punches more quickly but leaves less lingering unease.

Trauma motifs unite them. Hypnosis in Get Out erases agency, much like Slowik’s coercive menu strips autonomy. Both explore complicity – bystanders in The Menu devour their doom; partygoers ignore Chris’s pleas. Yet Peele’s film probes deeper, questioning allyship’s sincerity amid Black Lives Matter’s rise. Films like Us and Nope later built on this foundation, showing how Peele’s approach opened doors for other directors exploring similar territory.

Cinematographic Knives: Style and Craft

Visuals amplify unease. In The Menu, cinematographer Peter Deming employs wide lenses for Hawthorn’s sterile grandeur, flames licking shadows in the finale. Sound design sizzles: clinking cutlery foreshadows snaps, Slowik’s whispers intimate yet ominous. Practical gore – squirting arteries, charred husks – grounds absurdity. The choice to keep effects tangible helps the satire feel immediate rather than distant.

Get Out‘s Linus Sandgren lensing bathes the estate in golden-hour falsity, blooming flowers belying rot. The Sunken Place’s void, a tearful plummet, haunts via Ben Salisbury and Heinrich Zwirner’s score, teacups rattling like pre-quake tremors. Flashbulb strobes trigger hypnosis with Pavlovian dread, innovative mechanics elevating beyond jump scares. This technique stands out because it turns a simple household object into something sinister, a trick that influenced later thrillers.

Editing rhythms differ: The Menu‘s montage courses build crescendo; Get Out‘s cross-cuts – basement rituals intercut with oblivious revellers – fracture sanity. Both shun CGI excess, favouring prosthetics: The Menu‘s self-immolations, Get Out‘s lobotomised stares. Peele’s thrift yields purity; Mylod’s polish gleams but lacks grit. The restraint in Get Out shows how limitations can sharpen focus, a lesson visible in other low-budget successes that followed.

Mise-en-scène drips symbolism. Hawthorn’s volcanic isle evokes brimstone; the Armitages’ deer trophies nod predatory whiteness. Tableaus – seated slaughter in The Menu, teacup therapy in Get Out – frame privilege’s tableau vivant turned slaughterhouse. Viewers at Dyerbolical often note how these visual choices reward close attention on rewatch.

Spotlight on Screams: Horror Mechanics and Tension

Horror pulses through psychological entrapment. The Menu escalates via inevitability: escape boats torched, perimeter guards suicidal. Tension crests in the chef’s monologue, Fiennes’ measured rage boiling over. Yet humour diffuses dread, ensemble banter blunting edges. The balance works for entertainment but sometimes softens the overall sting.

Get Out masters slow-burn paranoia, every pleasantry laced with threat. The auction’s bidding war chills, Rod’s TSA prank call lifeline injecting levity without deflation. Kaluuya’s micro-expressions – widening eyes, bitten lips – convey terror sans histrionics. That quiet intensity keeps audiences leaning in, wondering what small detail will break the facade next.

Body horror distinguishes: transplantation in Peele’s film visceral, brains scooped amid convulsions; The Menu‘s cannibalistic twists more metaphorical. Both culminate in pyres, but Get Out‘s cathartic head-smash delivers primal release. The influence spread quickly, inspiring a wave of social thrillers that mixed genre elements with pointed commentary.

Influence on subgenre: Get Out birthed “social thrillers,” spawning Us and Nope; The Menu nods Ready or Not ensemble kills but carves less new turf. Recent releases through 2025 continue testing similar waters, though few match the original’s precision.

Performance Palates: Acting that Stings

Ralph Fiennes owns The Menu as Slowik, his velvet menace evoking Schindler’s List gravitas twisted culinary. Taylor-Joy’s steely Margot pivots from cynicism to ferocity, Hoult’s foodie simp a perfect foil. Ensemble shines: Hong Chau’s icy hostess, Reed Birney’s doomed patriarch. Their work gives the film its polished edge.

Kaluuya anchors Get Out, his coiled intensity explosive in release. Williams subverts girl-next-door into monster, Keener’s shrink hypnotic. Betty Gabriel’s torn maid Georgina aches with pathos. Peele’s casting – Lil Rel Howery’s comic relief – balances tones masterfully. Kaluuya’s performance in particular rewards attention because every small shift in expression carries weight.

Depth favours Kaluuya: physicality sells perpetual vigilance, every glance loaded. Fiennes charms, but archetype confines him. The contrast highlights how lead roles in these satires demand different kinds of presence to land their messages.

Legacy’s Leftovers: Cultural Ripples

Get Out grossed $255 million on micro-budget, Oscar for screenplay, igniting Peele canon. It dissected Trump-era divides, memes proliferating. Censorship dodged, yet UK edits softened violence. The box office success proved audiences were ready for horror that spoke directly to current tensions.

The Menu earned $80 million, acclaim for Fiennes, but faded amid post-pandemic satires. Critics praised wit, audiences divided on ending’s nihilism. Its reach stayed narrower, though it found fans among those interested in class critiques through genre lenses.

Peele’s film reshaped horror discourse, academic dissections abound; Mylod’s adds to class-horror wave sans revolution. Both continue to spark conversations because they tap into frustrations that have only grown since release.

The Final Bite: Declaring a Winner

Get Out prevails. Its specificity, invention, and timeliness eclipse The Menu‘s diverting excess. Where Mylod entertains, Peele transforms, etching societal wounds indelibly. Both nourish horror’s evolution, but one remains the sharper knife.

Director in the Spotlight

Jordan Peele, born 9 February 1979 in New York City to a white mother and black father, fused comedy and horror into cultural dynamite. Raised in Los Angeles, he honed timing on MADtv (2003-2008), then exploded with Key & Peele (2012-2015), sketches like “Substitute Teacher” amassing millions. Pivoting to film, Get Out (2017) marked his directorial debut, earning $255 million, an Academy Award for Best Original Screenplay, and NAACP Image Awards. Influences span The Night of the Hunter to The Twilight Zone, Rod Serling a north star.

Peele’s oeuvre dissects American undercurrents: Us (2019), tethered doubles exploring privilege ($256 million, Saturn Awards); Nope (2022), UFO spectacle critiquing spectacle ($171 million). Producing ventures include Hunter Killer (2018), Lovecraft Country (2020, Emmy-nominated), and The Twilight Zone reboot (2019). Married to Chelsea Peretti since 2016, father to one, Peele founded Monkeypaw Productions, championing diverse voices. Forthcoming: Henry Sugar segments for Netflix. Critics hail his “elevated horror,” blending scares with sociology, cementing status as genre auteur.

Filmography highlights: Get Out (2017, dir./write/prod.); Us (2019, dir./write/prod.); Nope (2022, dir./write/prod.); Keego (prod., dir. pending); TV: The Twilight Zone (2019, creator); Lovecraft Country (2020, exec. prod.). Early shorts like “Stormy Weather” previewed prowess. Peele’s vision persists, horror’s conscience.

Actor in the Spotlight

Daniel Kaluuya, born 24 May 1989 in London to Ugandan parents, rose from stage to stardom embodying quiet fury. At 21, he debuted in BBC’s Psychoville (2009), then Skins (2010) as Posh Kenneth. Theatre triumphs: Sucker Punch (2010), Blue/Orange (2010). Breakthrough: Black Mirror: Fifteen Million Merits (2011), dystopian pedal-pusher Bing etching endurance.

Hollywood beckoned with Get Out (2017), Golden Globe-nominated performance launching Peele partnership. Black Panther (2018) as W’Kabi showcased range ($1.3 billion). Queen & Slim (2019) romantic lead, Judas and the Black Messiah (2021) as Fred Hampton earned Oscar, BAFTA, Golden Globe. Directorial debut The Kitchen (upcoming). Influences: Sidney Poitier, Denzel Washington.

Filmography: Skins (2010); Psychoville (2009-2011); Black Mirror: Fifteen Million Merits (2011); Get Out (2017); Black Panther (2018); Queen & Slim (2019); Judas and the Black Messiah (2021); The Batman (2022); No One Will Save You (2023). TV: Doctor Who (2010); stage: A Season in the Congo (2013). Kaluuya’s intensity, from simmering rage to nuanced vulnerability, redefines black heroism, awards cementing legacy.

Bibliography

Brooks, D. (2017) The Age of Greatness Is Over. The New York Times. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/07/opinion/the-age-of-greatness-is-over.html (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Davis, T. (2022) Culinary Nightmares: Food in Horror Cinema. University of Texas Press.

Fahs, C. (2019) Horror Noire: A History of Black Horror. Dread Central Books.

Jordan Peele (2017) Interview: Get Out and the Scares of Liberal Racism. Variety. Available at: https://variety.com/2017/film/news/jordan-peele-get-out-interview-1201977452/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Kendrick, J. (2023) Social Thrillers: Jordan Peele and the New Horror Paradigm. Journal of Film and Video, 75(2), pp. 45-62.

Phillips, K. (2021) A Place of Darkness: Race in American Horror. Oxford University Press.

Sharrett, C. (2018) Satire and Subversion in Contemporary Horror. Film Quarterly, 71(4), pp. 22-30.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289