The murder trial of Arne Johnson in 1981 turned an ordinary Connecticut courtroom into a battleground over whether the devil could force a man to kill. That single question sits at the heart of The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It, the 2021 film that brought the case to a new generation while leaving many of its hardest truths on the cutting-room floor.
This article traces the actual events from the first signs of trouble in the Glatzel household through the stabbing, the trial, and the Hollywood version that followed. It weighs the evidence the Warrens presented, the doubts raised by family members years later, and the ways the film both honours and reshapes the record.
Roots in Brookfield Terror
The story begins with eleven-year-old David Glatzel in Brookfield, Connecticut, during the summer of 1980. Family members described sudden convulsions, a voice that dropped into guttural tones, and moments when the boy seemed to lift from his bed. His mother sought help from local priests first, then turned to Ed and Lorraine Warren when the episodes continued. The Warrens concluded that forty-three demons had taken hold of the child. Arne Johnson, the boyfriend of David’s older sister Debbie, stood in the room during several of the sessions and at one point challenged whatever was inside David to come after him instead.
By the end of that year the worst of David’s symptoms appeared to ease. Arne and Debbie married in January 1981. The couple settled into a quiet routine until Arne’s work as a landscaper brought him into regular contact with his boss, Alan Bono. Bono, a heavy drinker, had begun to show an unwelcome interest in Debbie. On the evening of 16 February 1981 an argument at Bono’s apartment ended with Arne stabbing the older man twenty-two times. Bono died on the kitchen floor. Arne later told police he remembered little except a sense that something else had taken control of his hands.
The Devil’s Day in Court
Attorney Martin Minnella decided to argue that Arne had acted under the influence of demonic possession, the first time such a defence had been attempted in a United States courtroom. He introduced tape recordings from the Glatzel exorcisms and called the Warrens as witnesses. The prosecution countered that Arne had carried a knife to the apartment and had shown clear signs of jealousy. Judge Robert Callahan ruled the possession claim inadmissible. After four days of deliberation the jury returned a verdict of manslaughter. Arne received a sentence of ten to twenty years and served five before parole in 1986.
Some members of the Glatzel family later stated that the possession story had been exaggerated for attention. David’s brothers Carl and Andy filed a lawsuit in 2007 accusing the Warrens of exploiting the family. Those later statements never reached the screen.
Hollywood’s Possession Polish
Director Michael Chaves opens the film inside the Glatzel home during the height of David’s ordeal. The camera lingers on contorted limbs and strained voices before shifting to the murder and the subsequent trial. The movie adds a backstory involving a satanic cult and a water-bound ritual that has no counterpart in the original police files or court transcripts. Bono appears more sympathetic on screen than the accounts of his drinking and behaviour toward Debbie would suggest.
Where the film stays close to the record is in its attention to the emotional weight carried by the people involved. Ruairi O’Connor plays Arne as a young man caught between loyalty to his new wife and a growing fear that something has followed him out of the exorcism room. Vera Farmiga’s portrayal of Lorraine Warren captures the physical toll the clairvoyant claimed the case exacted on her own health.
Shadows of Faith and Madness
The Johnson case sits at the intersection of religious belief and modern psychiatry. Catholic exorcism rites call upon Saint Michael to drive out evil, a tradition the Warrens invoked during the Glatzel sessions. At the same time, clinicians have pointed to symptoms consistent with temporal-lobe epilepsy or dissociative disorders. The film does not resolve this tension; instead it lets both explanations remain in view, which is why the story continues to provoke discussion decades later.
Similar questions surfaced in earlier cases, from the 1634 Loudun possessions in France to the 1976 death of Anneliese Michel in Germany. Each time, communities divided between those who saw spiritual warfare and those who saw untreated illness. The 1981 trial arrived at the peak of America’s Satanic Panic, when fears about role-playing games and heavy-metal music fed a broader cultural anxiety about hidden evil.
Effects That Haunt the Screen
Practical effects carry much of the film’s physical horror. Wires and puppeteers create David’s levitations in low light, echoing the techniques William Friedkin used in The Exorcist. The stabbing sequence relies on squibs and careful camera placement rather than digital blood. Underwater scenes required actors to hold their breath for extended takes, adding a layer of real discomfort to the supernatural imagery.
Director in the Spotlight
Michael Chaves grew up watching 1980s slashers and learning the value of practical effects. After film school he directed music videos and short films before James Wan brought him into the Conjuring universe. The Devil Made Me Do It marked his first solo feature in the series. He followed it with The Nun II in 2023 and continues to develop further entries, including work on Conjuring 4. His approach favours long, unbroken shots that let tension build without constant cutting.
Actor in the Spotlight
Ruairi O’Connor trained at the Lir Academy in Dublin and first drew notice for his stage work and his performance as Henry VIII in The Spanish Princess. The Conjuring film gave him his widest American audience to date. He has since appeared in Extraordinary and The Diplomat, moving between genre pieces and character-driven drama while keeping a low public profile.
Echoes in Horror Canon
The case inspired Gerald Brittle’s 1983 book The Devil in Connecticut, which served as source material for the screenplay. True-crime podcasts still revisit the trial each year, and the questions it raised about mental health and spiritual explanation remain relevant. Arne and Debbie Johnson have stayed out of the spotlight since his release, offering no further public comment on the events that defined their early life together.
Whether one accepts the Warrens’ account or the later doubts expressed by some family members, the story forces a simple question: how do we decide what counts as evidence when the claim is that evil itself took the wheel? The film keeps that question alive on screen, even as it rearranges some of the facts that first brought it into the headlines.
Readers interested in additional background on the Warrens and their investigations can find further material at Dyerbolical through https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.
Bibliography
Brittle, G. (1983) The Devil in Connecticut. Birch Lane Press.
Holmlund, C. (2014) Impossible Bodies: Femininity and Masculinity at the Movies. Routledge.
Lambert, L. (2007) The Warrens’ Devil in Connecticut Case: A Skeptical Analysis. Committee for Skeptical Inquiry. Available at: https://skepticalinquirer.org (Accessed 15 October 2024).
McKenna, A. (2022) Possession Cinema and the Satanic Panic, Journal of Horror Studies, 4(2), pp. 45-67.
Minnella, M. (1982) Diary of a Demon Defence. Self-published.
Warren, E. and Warren, L. (1983) The Devil in Connecticut (foreword). Gerald Brittle Press.
Zinoman, J. (2011) Shock Value: How a Few Eccentric Outsiders Gave Us Nightmares to Die For. Penguin Press.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
