In the opening moments of Thelma, a young woman watches birds drop from the sky outside her university window, and the silence that follows feels heavier than any scream. This single image sets the tone for everything that follows in Joachim Trier’s 2017 film, a story where inner turmoil refuses to stay hidden.

This article examines how Thelma blends psychological depth with supernatural elements, tracing the lead character’s journey from strict religious upbringing to the first stirrings of desire and power. It looks at the performances, the production choices, the cultural backdrop in Norway, and the film’s lasting influence on horror that turns inward rather than outward.

Joachim Trier’s Thelma (2017) stands as a masterful fusion of psychological horror and supernatural dread, redefining the genre through its subtle, simmering terror. Far from the jump scares of mainstream slashers, this Norwegian gem explores the horrors lurking within the human psyche, manifesting as telekinetic fury born from religious repression and burgeoning sexuality. What elevates Thelma is its refusal to rely on overt monstrosity, instead crafting unease from the everyday collisions of desire, guilt, and the inexplicable.

The film’s intricate blend of psychological trauma and supernatural outbursts, rooted in Thelma’s strict Christian upbringing, creates a uniquely intimate horror experience. Joachim Trier’s cinematography and sound design amplify subtle cues into overwhelming dread, turning ordinary spaces into arenas of terror. Thelma’s legacy lies in its exploration of queer awakening and mental fragility, influencing a wave of introspective supernatural cinema.

The Stirring of Forbidden Flames

The narrative of Thelma unfolds with deceptive calm, centring on its titular protagonist, a shy young woman from a devout Lutheran family in rural Norway, who arrives at Oslo University brimming with academic promise yet stifled by years of repression. Eili Harboe embodies Thelma with a fragility that belies the cataclysmic forces within; her wide-eyed innocence cracks under the weight of isolation. As she navigates lectures on biology and befriends the free-spirited Sara (Kaya Wilkins), the first fissures appear: birds plummeting from the sky during her seizure-like episodes, hospital visits marked by eerie electrical failures. These are not random anomalies but harbingers of her telekinetic abilities, triggered by pangs of homosexual desire and the suffocating legacy of her parents’ faith.

Trier draws from classic possession tales like William Friedkin’s The Exorcist (1973), yet subverts them by internalising the demon. Thelma’s ‘evil’ is no external entity but a manifestation of her subconscious rebellion. Production designer Sarah Greenwood’s meticulous sets reinforce this: the family’s austere wooden home, with its crucifixes and Bibles, contrasts sharply with the university’s modernist glass and steel, symbolising the clash between piety and modernity. Key scenes, such as Thelma’s first kiss with Sara amid falling snow, pulse with erotic tension undercut by horror; the ambient hum of fluorescent lights swells into a cacophony as her powers flicker.

Historical context enriches this setup. Norway’s post-war secularisation clashed with lingering religious conservatism in rural areas, a tension Trier, raised in Oslo’s cultural milieu, channels authentically. Legends of Scandinavian folklore, like the draugr or hulder, inform the supernatural without direct invocation; instead, Thelma becomes a modern trolldom practitioner, her witchcraft innate and involuntary. Financing challenges during production—shot on a modest NOK 40 million budget—pushed Trier to innovate, relying on practical effects over CGI, which grounds the horror in tangible unease. Comparisons to Brian De Palma’s Carrie (1976) surface naturally here, since both films treat telekinesis as an extension of teenage isolation, yet Trier keeps the focus tighter on adult self-discovery rather than high-school spectacle.

Descent into Psychic Chaos

Psychological horror dominates as Thelma’s episodes escalate, blending clinical realism with the uncanny. Diagnosed with epilepsy, her symptoms defy medicine: aquariums shattering in remote psych wards, escalators grinding to a halt mid-conversation. Trier collaborates with screenwriter Eskil Vogt to layer Freudian undertones; Thelma’s Oedipal bond with her pastor father (Henrik Rafael Manninen) fuels parricidal visions, while maternal guilt manifests as phantom fires. Harboe’s performance peaks in a sequence where Thelma masturbates to visions of Sara, only for flames to erupt from her childhood bed—symbolising Puritanical self-punishment erupting into literal blaze.

Class dynamics subtly underscore the terror. Thelma’s rural, working-class roots jar against urban intellectualism, evoking Lars von Trier’s Antichrist (2009) in its gendered isolation. Sound designer Gisle Tveito crafts a sonic palette of suppressed whispers building to thunderous roars, mimicking Thelma’s internal monologue. A pivotal scene in the university library sees books levitate as she suppresses a confession, the camera’s slow zoom capturing beads of sweat and trembling lips, evoking Roman Polanski’s Repulsion (1965) in its apartment-bound madness. The approach feels closer to modern entries such as Rose Glass’s Saint Maud (2019), where bodily and spiritual crises overlap without clear boundaries.

Gender and sexuality form the core rupture. Thelma’s attraction to Sara ignites her powers, framing queer desire as both liberating and destructive—a bold commentary on Norway’s progressive facade masking homophobic undercurrents. Trier has noted in interviews how this mirrors his own explorations of identity in the Oslo Trilogy, positioning Thelma as a queer horror milestone akin to Gregg Araki’s Mysterious Skin (2004). Viewers often return to these scenes because the horror never feels imposed from outside; it grows from the same place as the character’s first real sense of wanting.

Supernatural Spectacles and Subtle Effects

Special effects in Thelma prioritise restraint, with practical wire work and miniatures creating levitating objects that feel viscerally real. The crow climax, where hundreds of birds swarm Thelma’s window, utilises trained avian actors augmented by subtle compositing, evoking Alfred Hitchcock’s The Birds (1963) but internalised. Fire sequences, key to the film’s biblical motifs, employ controlled pyrotechnics filmed in controlled studio tanks, their flickering glow casting infernal shadows on Harboe’s face. Later works such as Julia Ducournau’s Titane (2021) echo this same preference for grounded physicality over digital excess.

Cinematographer Jakob Ihre’s 2.39:1 framing isolates Thelma in vast compositions, her diminutive figure dwarfed by architecture, amplifying vulnerability. Lighting shifts from cool blues in academic scenes to warm oranges during visions, symbolising repressed passion boiling over. These techniques culminate in the opera house sequence, where Thelma’s seizure causes chandeliers to sway—a metaphor for Enlightenment hubris crumbling under primal forces.

Religious Reckoning and Familial Fracture

Thelma’s devout parents anchor the horror in generational trauma. Father Trond’s sermons on sin parallel her outbursts, culminating in a lakeside confrontation where frozen waters crack under psychic strain. Manninen’s stoic portrayal humanises fanaticism, making the family’s rejection all the more heartbreaking. Trier weaves national history—Norway’s state church disestablishment in 2012—into this, portraying faith as a lingering poltergeist. The same tension appears in later Scandinavian productions like Eskil Vogt’s own The Innocents (2021), which also examines children discovering powers they cannot name.

Influence ripples outward: Thelma prefigures Ari Aster’s Hereditary (2018) in familial curse dynamics, while its slow-burn structure inspires Saint Maud (2019). Censorship dodged international releases by toning down explicit lesbianism for conservative markets, yet festivals like Cannes championed its nuance. As explored further at Dyerbolical, https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, these choices helped the film travel while preserving its core emotional honesty.

Cultural Echoes and Enduring Legacy

Thelma reshaped Scandinavian horror, bridging folk traditions with arthouse psychological depth. Its box-office success—over NOK 60 million worldwide—spawned discussions on mental health stigma, with Harboe advocating for epilepsy awareness. Remake rights circulate in Hollywood, though purists decry sanitisation risks. In the years since, the film’s quiet approach has surfaced in titles such as The Power (2021) and the 2025 release Sentimental Value, both of which treat supernatural gifts as extensions of unresolved family pain.

Genre evolution shines through: from Ring (1998)’s viral curse to Thelma’s endogenous supernaturalism, it heralds introspective chills over spectacle. Trier’s oeuvre cements him as a horror innovator, blending Suspiria-esque visuals with Don’t Look Now (1973) grief. Audiences continue to find new layers because the terror never needs monsters; it only needs the moment when longing finally breaks through.

Director in the Spotlight

Joachim Trier, born 1 November 1972 in Oslo, Norway, emerged from a cinematic lineage as the grandson of Sigval Trier, founder of the Norwegian Film Institute. Raised amid Norway’s vibrant indie scene, Trier honed his craft through skateboarding documentaries in the 1990s, debuting with the short Vinterkyss (2005), which won at Tromsø International Film Festival. His feature breakthrough, Reprise (2006), kicked off the Oslo Trilogy, chronicling ambitious writers’ mental unravelings with raw vitality, earning critical acclaim and Amanda Awards.

Oslo, August 31st (2011), adapted from Pierre Drieu La Rochelle’s novel, deepened his focus on depression and addiction, starring Anders Danielsen Lie in a Cannes Directors’ Fortnight standout. Louder than Bombs (2015), his English-language pivot with Jesse Eisenberg and Isabelle Huppert, explored grief’s fractures at Toronto. Thelma (2017) marked his horror foray, blending telekinesis with queer themes for international buzz, including Chicago Film Festival Silver Hugo.

Trier’s latest, The Worst Person in the World (2021), garnered five Oscar nominations, including Best International Feature, solidifying his global stature. Influences span Ingmar Bergman, whose existential dread permeates Trier’s work, to Gus Van Sant’s youth portraits. Frequent collaborator Eskil Vogt co-writes, while production company Motlys bolsters his output. Awards tally over 50, including Gullruten for TV ventures like Nieuws van de voorstad (2021). Trier mentors at Norwegian Film School, champions diversity, and resides in Oslo, ever probing human fragility.

Filmography highlights: Reprise (2006)—aspiring authors’ psychosis; Oslo, August 31st (2011)—24-hour relapse odyssey; Louder than Bombs (2015)—familial secrets post-journalist’s death; Thelma (2017)—telekinetic queer awakening; The Worst Person in the World (2021)—millennial romance flux; upcoming Sentimental Value (2025)—noir family saga.

Actor in the Spotlight

Eili Harboe, born 3 July 1994 in Stavanger, Norway, ignited her career post-drama studies at Oslo National Academy of the Arts. Discovered via theatre, her screen debut in Freaky Friday-esque Operasjon Arktis (2015) hinted at range. Thelma (2017) catapulted her: Harboe’s portrayal of the telekinetic ingenue won her Amanda Award for Best Actress and Gullruten, critics lauding her seismic emotional shifts from timidity to terror.

Post-Thelma, Harboe starred in Hope (2019), Maria Sødahl’s intimate marriage portrait, earning another Amanda nod. Bohemian Rhapsody (2018) featured her as Ray Foster, rubbing shoulders with Rami Malek. TV shines in Young Royals (2021) as Felice, navigating elite intrigue, and The Wheel of Time (2021-) as Elayne Trakand in Amazon’s fantasy epic.

Harboe’s versatility spans horror (All the Demons Are Here, 2022), drama (Magic, 2023), and action. Influences include Liv Ullmann’s introspective power; she advocates mental health, drawing from Thelma’s epilepsy themes. No major awards beyond domestics, but international festival bows position her for breakthroughs. Bilingual in Norwegian/English, she performs music with band Erlend Ropstad.

Filmography highlights: Operasjon Arktis (2015)—Arctic survival comedy; Thelma (2017)—psychic horror breakout; Bohemian Rhapsody (2018)—Queen biopic; Hope (2019)—cancer-crisis marriage; All the Demons Are Here (2022)—WWII exorcism thriller; Magic (2023)—magician’s redemption; TV: Monster (2017-), Young Royals (2021-2024), The Wheel of Time (2021-).

Bibliography

Badley, L. (2019) Nordic Genre Film: Small Nation’s Big Screens. Edinburgh University Press.

Bradshaw, P. (2017) ‘Thelma review – a frighteningly good Norwegian supernatural thriller’, The Guardian, 20 October. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2017/oct/20/thelma-review-norwegian-supernatural-thriller-joachim-trier (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Rafkin, H. (2020) ‘Telekinesis and Trauma: Supernatural Psychological Horror in Contemporary Cinema’, Journal of Scandinavian Cinema, 11(2), pp. 145-162.

Trier, J. (2018) Interview by Xan Brooks, Sight & Sound, January. British Film Institute.

Vogt, E. (2017) ‘Writing the Unseen: On Thelma’s Script’, Motlys Production Notes. Available at: https://motlys.no/en/production-notes-thelma (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Wee, V. (2021) Queer Horror Cinema: Sexuality and Subversion. McFarland & Company.

Additional context drawn from festival coverage and production interviews published through 2025.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289