Three films that turn private sorrow into something that watches you back.
Psychological horror often works best when it refuses to separate the monster from the person carrying it. The Babadook, The Night House and Saint Maud each place grief at the centre of the story, letting it reshape homes, bodies and beliefs until the viewer can no longer tell where the ordinary ends and the terrifying begins. This piece looks closely at how these three films achieve that effect, what they share and why their approach still feels urgent years later.
The Weight That Settles In
The Babadook opens with a home video of a car crash that took Amelia’s husband on the way to the hospital for their son’s birth. Jennifer Kent lets that single moment echo through every frame that follows. Amelia, played by Essie Davis, moves through her days with the mechanical precision of someone who has already used up every reserve of patience. When the pop-up book appears, its illustrations feel less like an intrusion and more like an externalisation of the depression she has been trying to outrun. The film never treats grief as a temporary visitor; it becomes the atmosphere the characters breathe.
The Night House picks up the same thread but moves it into a different kind of isolation. Rebecca Hall’s Beth returns to the lakeside house her husband built and begins to find evidence that his life contained entire rooms she never entered. David Bruckner stages the revelations so that each new discovery lands like another small collapse. The mirrored structure that appears in the woods is not simply a supernatural twist; it literalises the sense that the person you loved most may have lived a parallel existence you will never fully reach. Hall’s performance makes the exhaustion visible in the way she holds her shoulders and the way silence seems to press against her.
Saint Maud approaches the same territory through religious conviction rather than literal haunting. Morfydd Clark’s Maud has already survived one catastrophe and has rebuilt her identity around the idea that she was spared for a purpose. Rose Glass shows how that conviction can harden into something that no longer recognises the needs of the person it claims to serve. The seaside town becomes smaller and more airless as Maud’s certainty grows. In each film the domestic space turns hostile because the grief inside it has nowhere else to go.
Questions That Refuse Easy Answers
Ambiguity is the tool these directors use to keep the audience inside the characters’ uncertainty. The Babadook never settles whether the creature is an external force or the visible form of Amelia’s worsening mental state. The final image of her feeding it worms suggests that some forms of pain are not defeated but managed, and that management itself can look strange to outsiders. Kent’s choice to leave the question open mirrors how depression actually functions for many people; it does not vanish after one dramatic confrontation.
The Night House extends the same principle into architecture and memory. The house’s impossible double appears in blueprints and reflections before it ever manifests as a physical threat. Bruckner blends therapy sessions, text messages and low-frequency sound so that even the viewer begins to doubt which evidence is reliable. When the ancient entity tied to the lake finally surfaces, the film still withholds certainty about whether Beth is seeing something real or completing a pattern her mind has already accepted. That refusal keeps the story from collapsing into simple allegory.
Saint Maud works through bodily and spiritual doubt instead. Glass films Maud’s visions with the same handheld intimacy she uses for scenes of ordinary nursing work, so the distinction between revelation and hallucination never feels clean. The final act forces the audience to watch a private theology reach its logical conclusion without offering external judgment. Clark’s performance carries both the rapture and the terror, making it impossible to dismiss either side. Across all three films the sound design reinforces the uncertainty: creaks, distant voices and choral fragments arrive without clear sources, mirroring how grief distorts ordinary perception.
Performances That Carry the Pressure
Essie Davis, Rebecca Hall and Morfydd Clark each anchor their film in a single consciousness under siege. Davis shows Amelia’s anger emerging in small, involuntary flashes before it erupts. Hall lets Beth’s investigative energy mask a deeper unraveling, her physical presence growing more fragile as the house reveals its secrets. Clark makes Maud’s self-denial visible in posture and breath, turning religious ecstasy into something that looks increasingly like self-harm. These performances matter because they keep the horror tethered to recognisable human behaviour rather than abstract ideas.
How the Films Were Made and Why It Shows
Kent’s debut grew out of her earlier short film Monster and was completed on a modest budget after years of development. The practical effects and confined locations give the terror an immediacy that larger productions often lose. Bruckner’s film went through reshoots after its initial acquisition, yet the final cut retains a folk-horror undercurrent that connects it to earlier American ghost stories. Glass drew on her own background to shape Saint Maud’s religious imagery, and the result feels lived-in rather than researched. Each production decision reinforces the central theme: when resources are limited, the camera stays close to the character and the fear becomes more personal.
Continuing Influence
The Babadook helped shift the conversation around grief in horror and opened doors for later films that treat mental distress as the primary source of dread. The Night House found a second life on streaming platforms, where its slow accumulation of dread rewards repeat viewing. Saint Maud launched both Glass and Clark into wider recognition and contributed to a renewed interest in body horror that examines faith rather than simply rejecting it. Together the three films demonstrate that psychological horror can remain commercially viable while still asking difficult questions about loss, identity and belief. Their example continues to matter because audiences still respond to stories that treat inner conflict with the same seriousness usually reserved for external monsters.
Jennifer Kent’s Path to The Babadook
Jennifer Kent trained at Australia’s National Institute of Dramatic Art and worked as an actor before moving behind the camera. Her short film Monster already contained the core image of a child threatened by an adult’s unresolved fear. The feature that grew from it received support through crowdfunding and premiered at Venice, where it quickly found international attention. Kent followed The Babadook with The Nightingale, a period revenge story that applied the same attention to physical and emotional confinement on a larger historical canvas. She has also directed episodes of television, including work on The Kettering Incident, and continues to develop new projects including further exploration of the Babadook universe. Her consistent interest in characters whose environments reflect their inner state remains the thread that ties her work together.
Rebecca Hall’s Range and The Night House
Rebecca Hall came to acting through a family already immersed in theatre and music. After early roles and university study she gained notice in The Prestige and later in Vicky Cristina Barcelona. The Night House gave her the opportunity to carry an entire film through physical and emotional extremes without relying on dialogue to explain every shift. Since then she has moved between horror in Resurrection, sharp social satire in The Menu and her own directorial work with Passing. The precision she brings to roles that require both control and collapse made her a natural fit for Beth’s fractured investigation of her own marriage.
At Dyerbolical we have long admired the way these films refuse to separate craft from feeling. You can read more about our approach at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.
Bibliography
Bradshaw, P. (2014) The Babadook. The Guardian.
Glass, R. (2020) Interview: Directing Saint Maud. Sight & Sound, British Film Institute.
Kent, J. (2015) Grief and the Babadook. Fangoria, Issue 342.
Korven, M. (2021) Sound Design in The Night House. Sound on Sound Magazine.
Nelson, C. (2019) Saint Maud and the Ecstasy of Faith. Film Quarterly, 73(2).
Parker, H. (2022) Rebecca Hall: From Prestige to Possession. Empire Magazine.
Phillips, K. (2018) The Nightingale and Jennifer Kent’s Oeuvre. Senses of Cinema, Issue 88.
West, A. (2020) The Night House: Doppelgangers and Deception. Rue Morgue.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
