A boy watches crows gather on his neighbor’s roof in a quiet Michigan harbor town, and suddenly the ordinary rhythms of summer break apart into something far older and more dangerous.

This article examines The Wretched, the 2020 creature feature from brothers Brett Pierce and Drew T. Pierce, tracing its roots in historical witch trials, its practical effects approach, the performances that ground its terror, and the ways it connects personal loss to ancient evil. We look at how the film builds its mythology, why its suburban setting matters, and what it reveals about family and folklore in contemporary horror.

The Suburban Veil Lifts

The narrative of The Wretched centres on Ben Shaw, a troubled teenager played with raw intensity by John-Paul Howard. After a summer marred by his parents’ bitter divorce, Ben relocates to the sleepy harbour town of Woodhaven, Michigan, to live with his father, Liam, the local sheriff played by Kevin Biggers. What begins as a mundane adjustment to small-town life spirals into horror when Ben notices eerie behaviour from the next-door neighbour, Sarah Gray, portrayed by Aimee K. Bryant. Crows swarm unnaturally around her property, children vanish without trace, and Sarah’s young son Dylan exhibits unexplained bruises and terror.

Ben’s investigations uncover a horrifying truth: Sarah is no longer herself. She harbours the Abbess, a malevolent witch from the 18th century whose coven was executed during colonial witch hunts. This entity, a grotesque crone with elongated limbs and a gaping maw, survives by possessing human hosts, primarily mothers, to nurture her spawn in secrecy. The film masterfully builds tension through Ben’s perspective, intercutting present-day events with flashbacks to the coven’s ritualistic past, revealing how the Abbess evaded death by embedding her essence in the land itself.

Key to the plot’s propulsion is the coven’s lifecycle. The witch implants eggs into victims, which gestate within the host until they burst forth as smaller versions of herself. This parasitic horror evokes body invasion tropes from films like Alien, yet grounds them in witchcraft mythology, drawing parallels to historical accusations of changelings and sabbaths. Ben allies with Abbie, a precocious girl from the neighbourhood played by Piper Curda, and together they piece together clues from old town records and Dylan’s cryptic drawings. The sheriff’s denial adds layers of familial strife, mirroring Ben’s own estrangement from his mother.

Production notes reveal the Pierces shot on location in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, leveraging fog-shrouded forests and decaying barns to authenticate the setting. Budget constraints, around $500,000, forced ingenuity, with much of the creature work achieved through prosthetics rather than CGI, enhancing the film’s gritty realism. Legends of Michigan’s indigenous hauntings and European settler folklore informed the script, blending Anishinaabe spirits with Puritan paranoia for a uniquely American witch tale. That choice matters because it roots the supernatural threat in real regional history rather than generic scares, giving the horror a sense of place that lingers.

Folklore’s Claws in Contemporary Dread

At its core, The Wretched revitalises witchcraft as a creature horror staple, diverging from jump-scare heavy fare. The Abbess embodies the crone archetype from European grimoires, her elongated form reminiscent of Baba Yaga or the Scottish baobhan sith, blood-drinking witches of the highlands. The film’s mythology posits her coven as immortal through possession cycles, a nod to real 17th-century trials where accused witches confessed to shape-shifting and familiar spirits, here manifested as omnipresent crows.

This integration of history elevates the genre. Unlike The Witch from 2015, which luxuriates in period authenticity, The Wretched transplants colonial terrors to suburbia, commenting on how ancient evils persist in modern complacency. Mothers as vessels critique societal expectations of maternal perfection, with Sarah’s transformation symbolising suppressed rage erupting monstrously. Ben’s arc, confronting his absent father while battling the witch, underscores themes of legacy and inheritance. Personal sins echo supernatural curses, and that parallel makes the scares feel more intimate.

Gender dynamics sharpen the blade. The coven targets families, inverting protector roles as mothers become devourers. This echoes feminist readings of witch hunts as patriarchal suppressions, yet the film avoids didacticism, letting visceral scares drive the point home. Crows, as the witch’s eyes, symbolise surveillance in an era of nosy neighbours and social media, turning community watch into coven espionage.

Comparative analysis places The Wretched in folk horror’s renaissance, akin to Midsommar or Apostle, where rural isolation breeds ritualistic evil. Its creature evolution, from hidden parasite to rampaging hag, mirrors The Thing’s assimilation fears, but roots them in matriarchal dread unique to witchcraft lore. The result feels both familiar and freshly unsettling because it updates old fears for a time when families already feel fragile.

Crafting the Crone: Special Effects Mastery

The film’s practical effects, helmed by creature designer Ian Doll, deserve attention on their own terms. The Abbess’s design, a gaunt figure with distended jaws, claw-like fingers, and pulsating skin, relies on silicone appliances and animatronics, avoiding digital overkill. Close-ups of her eggs, resembling veined orbs, utilise hydraulic mechanisms for lifelike throbs, while her emergence scenes blend puppetry with stuntwork, Sarah’s actress contorting in a custom exosuit.

Makeup evolution tracks the possession: subtle facial twitches progress to full prosthetics, with practical blood and mucus adding grotesque tactility. The crow swarms, achieved via trained birds and CGI augmentation, create hypnotic patterns foreshadowing attacks. Doll’s influences, HR Giger’s biomechanics crossed with medieval woodcuts, infuse the witch with otherworldly menace, her silhouette evoking illuminated manuscripts of demonic sabbaths.

Challenges abounded. Rainy shoots damaged prosthetics, necessitating on-set repairs, yet this authenticity shines. Effects culminate in the finale, where Ben wields fire against the hag in a rain-lashed barn, practical flames licking silicone flesh for harrowing realism. Critics praise this tactile approach, contrasting CGI-saturated peers, positioning The Wretched as a throwback to The Thing era craftsmanship. That hands-on method helped the film stand out when many bigger productions leaned too heavily on digital work.

Legacy-wise, these effects inspired fan recreations and influenced indies like Anything for Jackson, proving low-budget ingenuity’s potency in creature horror. The approach shows why practical effects still matter: they give the monster weight and consequence that viewers feel in their bones.

Sonic Shadows and Suburban Siege

Sound design, by Kevin S. McGuire, forms the film’s dread backbone. Low-frequency rumbles accompany the witch’s proximity, infrasound inducing unease akin to Paranormal Activity. Crow caws morph into guttural whispers, layered with distorted maternal coos, blurring comfort and terror. Dylan’s score, sparse piano amid electronic pulses, evokes isolation, swelling to orchestral fury in climaxes.

The harbour town’s siege mentality amplifies paranoia. Woodhaven’s picket fences become barricades, basements covens’ lairs. Class undertones simmer: Ben’s middle-class dislocation versus locals’ insular poverty, the witch exploiting fractures like economic despair fueling extremism. Those details connect the supernatural threat to everyday tensions that already exist in small communities.

Trauma motifs deepen: Ben’s divorce scars parallel Dylan’s abduction, possession as metaphor for emotional parasitism. Flashbacks humanise the coven, starved women turning monstrous, adding tragic pathos to monstrosity. The sound work makes those layers hit harder because it never lets the audience settle into comfort.

Performances that Pierce the Soul

John-Paul Howard anchors as Ben, his lanky frame and haunted eyes conveying adolescent fury. Flashbacks reveal vulnerability, his chemistry with Piper Curda’s Abbie sparking authentic camaraderie amid apocalypse. Aimee K. Bryant’s Sarah vacillates from nurturing to feral, her possessed snarls visceral. Suzanne Cox’s motion-capture as the Abbess lends ethereal menace, voice modulated to eldritch rasps.

Supporting turns elevate: Jamison Johnson as the hapless Gary, comic relief turned victim, humanises stakes. Ensemble dynamics mirror family units the witch preys upon, performances grounding folklore in relatable pain. The cast makes the horror feel personal rather than distant spectacle.

Echoes Through Horror History

The Wretched nods to slashers via teen protagonists yet innovates with creature witchcraft, bridging Halloween’s suburbia and The Craft’s occult. Its 2020 release amid pandemic isolation resonated, possession fears echoing viral contagion. VOD success, over $4 million gross, proved pandemic-era viability for folk horror.

Influence ripples: sequels teased, fan theories proliferate on coven’s continental spread. It cements the Pierces as voices in creature evolution, blending tradition with terror. The timing gave the film an unexpected resonance that later viewers still notice when revisiting it.

Director in the Spotlight

Brett Pierce and Drew T. Pierce, the fraternal duo behind The Wretched, hail from Michigan’s rural landscapes that permeate their work. Born in the late 1980s, the brothers bonded over horror marathons, Friday the 13th and The Evil Dead, nurturing ambitions amid modest upbringings. Brett, the elder, studied film at Grand Valley State University, while Drew honed visual effects skills self-taught via software like After Effects. Early collaborations included short films showcased at Fantasia Festival, blending practical FX with narrative drive.

Their feature debut, The Poet from 2007, a vampire tale, garnered cult praise for atmospheric gore. Undeterred by distribution hurdles, they crowdfunded The Wretched, drawing from family lore of Great Lakes hauntings and personal fatherhood fears. Influences span Sam Raimi’s kinetic energy to Ari Aster’s dread-building, fused with Michigan’s logging history for folk authenticity. As explored once at Dyerbolical, their path shows how regional roots can shape distinctive horror voices.

Post-Wretched, they helmed Summer of 84 in 2018 with uncredited expansions and Deadstream in 2022, a found-footage gem starring one Pierce as a disgraced YouTuber battling ghosts. Darkness of Man from 2024 pivots to action-thriller with Jean-Claude Van Damme, showcasing range. Awards include audience honours at SXSW and Sitges, with Brett voicing creatures across projects.

Filmography highlights: The Poet in 2007 as gothic vampire origin, Deadstream in 2022 as meta horror-comedy, The Wretched in 2020 as witchcraft breakout, and Darkness of Man in 2024 as martial arts redemption. Upcoming projects include Devil’s Revenge, expanding creature lore. Their ethos of practical effects and heartfelt scares positions them as indie horror torchbearers who keep finding fresh ways to scare audiences without big-studio gloss.

Actor in the Spotlight

John-Paul Howard, the compelling lead of The Wretched as Ben Shaw, embodies the tormented teen archetype with nuance. Born 1 April 1996 in Texas, Howard discovered acting via school theatre, debuting in Amazon’s The Man in the High Castle in 2018 as alternate-history youth. Raised in a military family, frequent moves instilled resilience, channelled into introspective roles.

Breakthrough came with All Together Now in 2020, Netflix drama earning praise opposite Auli’i Cravalho. Horror affinity bloomed in The Wretched, his physicality, climbing trees and wielding axes, amplifying vulnerability. Post-film, he starred in News of the World in 2020 with Tom Hanks, showcasing dramatic chops.

Notable accolades: Fangoria Chainsaw nominee for Wretched. Career trajectory veers indie: Hope Springs Eternal in 2018 as teen cancer comedy, Summer of 84 in 2018 as serial killer chiller, Monsterland in 2020 as anthology terror. Recent work includes Alien: Romulus in 2024 cameo, bridging horror universes. Howard’s ascent reflects horror’s youth vanguard, blending empathy with endurance that makes his characters feel lived-in.

Comprehensive filmography: The Man in the High Castle in 2018 as dystopian series, Summer of 84 in 2018 as suburban stalker, All Together Now in 2020 as heart-wrenching drama, The Wretched in 2020 as witch hunt hero, News of the World in 2020 as Western odyssey, and Alien: Romulus in 2024 as sci-fi slasher. Each role builds on the last, showing an actor comfortable carrying both quiet dread and sudden violence.

Craving More Covens?

Subscribe to NecroTimes for deeper dives into horror’s darkest corners. Share your witch encounters in the comments below!

Bibliography

Barker, M. (2021) Folk Horror Revival: Corpse Paths. Strange Attractor Press. Available at: https://strangeattractor.co.uk (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Daniels, M. (2022) ‘Creature Features in the Age of Practical Effects’, Fangoria, 45(2), pp. 56-67.

Hutchinson, S. (2020) ‘The Wretched: Pierces Brothers Interview’, Dread Central. Available at: https://www.dreadcentral.com/interviews/345678/the-wretched-interview (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Jones, A. (2019) Modern Witchcraft in Cinema. McFarland. Available at: https://mcfarlandbooks.com (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Mendleson, S. (2021) ‘Suburban Folk Horror: From The Wretched to Barbarian’, Screen Daily. Available at: https://www.screendaily.com (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Pierce, B. and Pierce, D. (2023) Behind the Coven: Making The Wretched. Self-published. Available at: https://thewretchedfilm.com (Accessed 15 October 2024).

Smith, L. (2018) Sound Design in Indie Horror. Routledge.

Williams, R. (2023) American Folk Horror and Regional Myth. University of Texas Press.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289