The story of Valak begins not with a grand reveal but with a single unsettling vision in The Conjuring 2. That moment set the stage for two films that would test the boundaries of faith and fear in very different settings, one rooted in ancient stone and the other in the fragile routines of everyday life. This piece looks closely at The Nun from 2018 and The Nun II from 2023, tracing how Sister Irene faces the demon across Romania and France while the series itself shifts from quiet dread to something more urgent and physical.
Cloistered Curse: The Romanian Roots of Terror
The origins of Valak’s cinematic hauntings trace back to the chilling coda of The Conjuring 2 from 2016, where the demon first menaced the Warrens in Enfield. This sparked The Nun, directed by Corin Hardy, which rewinds to 1952 Romania. Dispatched by the Vatican, Father Burke and novice Sister Irene probe a suicide at Saint Carta Monastery, only to unearth a portal to hell guarded by blood rituals. The abbey’s labyrinthine catacombs, dripping with candle wax and echoing chants, set a tone of medieval dread. Hardy drew from Hammer Horror aesthetics to craft a film where every shadow conceals blasphemy, from inverted crosses to desecrated chalices. That choice matters because it reconnects modern audiences with the gothic tradition that once made religious horror feel both beautiful and dangerous.
The narrative hinges on unholy experiments by a fallen monk, unleashing Valak as a towering, croaking entity with eyes like burning coals. Frenchie, the local handyman, becomes an unwitting conduit for the demon’s escape, biting Irene and foreshadowing sequels. This prequel excels in building suspense through restraint. Long takes in torchlit halls amplify isolation, while the score by Joseph Bishara pulses like a heartbeat from the grave. Production designer Jennifer Spence recreated the Carthusian abbey with practical sets in Romania, blending Orthodox iconography with infernal twists to symbolise corrupted faith. Those details give the film a tangible weight that digital effects alone rarely achieve.
Yet The Nun stumbles in its final act, resorting to jump scares over subtlety, a concession to franchise formula. Still, it grossed over $365 million worldwide on a $22 million budget, proving Valak’s market appeal. Critics praised its visual poetry but noted thin characterisation beyond archetypes. Taissa Farmiga’s serene poise amid chaos anchors the film, her wide-eyed innocence clashing with Demián Bichir’s world-weary priest and evoking classic gothic duos like Christopher Lee and Peter Cushing. The tension between innocence and experience remains one of the most compelling parts of the first film.
Profane Progression: France’s Boarding School of Sin
Five years later, The Nun II, helmed by Michael Chaves, catapults the action to 1956 France. Sister Irene reunites with possessed Frenchie, now Maurice, after children at a Normandy school fall victim to Valak’s new vendetta: profaning the Holy Sacraments. The demon, seeking a relic called the Eyes of Saint Lucy, manifests through Maurice’s body, twisting his affable grin into grotesque contortions. Chaves shifts from abbatial gloom to sun-dappled classrooms, where wine turns to blood and rosaries strangle throats, heightening the perversion of innocence. The move to a school setting broadens the threat, showing how evil can invade spaces meant to protect the young.
This sequel expands the lore, introducing Sister Debra and schoolmistress Sister Catherine, fleshing out Irene’s allies. Valak’s human guise, played by Jonathan Roumie, adds layers of seduction and menace, echoing The Exorcist’s possessed Regan but with seductive flair. Cinematographer Michael Burgess employs Steadicam for fluid pursuits through vineyards and cathedrals, contrasting Hardy’s static dread. The budget swelled to $65 million, reflected in polished CGI for Valak’s wings and flames, though practical stunts like a truck impaling a victim retain visceral punch. That balance between spectacle and grounded horror keeps the sequel from feeling entirely weightless.
Box office soared to $269 million, buoyed by franchise loyalty, yet reviews were mixed. Praise went to Bloquet’s dual performance while criticism focused on repetitive scares. Chaves, known for kinetic horror, infuses more action through chases on Vespas and rooftop leaps, morphing the series into exorcist-adjacent thrillers. Themes deepen too. Postwar Europe’s lingering scars mirror the church’s abuses, with Valak as metaphor for institutional evil infiltrating the young. These layers give the film more to say about power and vulnerability than many viewers initially noticed.
Sister Irene: From Novice to Avenging Angel
Taissa Farmiga’s portrayal evolves strikingly. In the original, Irene is a visionary guided by divine dreams, her faith untested. Scenes of her silent prayer amid screams underscore quiet strength, reminiscent of Deborah Kerr in Black Narcissus. By the sequel, scars from the bite mark her brow. She becomes proactive, wielding crosses like weapons and directing exorcisms with commanding grace. This arc symbolises spiritual maturation, paralleling the audience’s growing investment in the Conjuring mythos. Watching her change across the two films feels like following someone who has learned that belief alone is never enough.
Farmiga, with her ethereal features, embodies purity under siege. Her chemistry with Bloquet grounds the supernatural. Tender moments in the abbey evolve into tragic confrontations in France. Directors leverage her American Horror Story pedigree, honed in Asylum and Coven, for nuanced terror. Her eyes convey turmoil without dialogue. Critics like those in Empire noted how she elevates formulaic plots through subtle micro-expressions. That quiet intensity is what makes the character linger long after the credits roll.
Valak’s Versatility: Demon Deconstructed
Valak, the androgynous duke of hell from the Lesser Key of Solomon, shapeshifts masterfully. Hardy’s version is spectral, a hooded silhouette with a rumbling croak that materialises in mirrors and mist. Practical makeup by Adrian Morot creates a hulking form blending nun’s habit with draconic flair. The sequel innovates with possession mechanics, Maurice’s eyes yellowing and voice distorting, for intimate horror that draws from The Conjuring’s Annabelle playbook but with biblical specificity. The shift from distant apparition to something that speaks through a familiar face makes the threat feel far more personal.
Roumie’s live-action Valak in II humanises the beast, sporting slicked hair and priestly collars while seducing with honeyed lies. This escalation critiques clerical hypocrisy, Valak posing as confessor to corrupt souls. Effects supervisor Brian Dodge blended prosthetics and digital enhancements, earning nods for seamlessness despite franchise CGI critiques. The demon’s adaptability across both films shows how horror can refresh ancient mythology for new audiences without losing its core menace.
Soundscapes of Sacrilege
Audio design distinguishes the pair. Bishara’s score in The Nun layers Gregorian chants with dissonant strings, evoking cathedral organs possessed. Footsteps echo interminably in stone vaults, building paranoia. Chaves amps this with industrial clangs in school bells and shattering stained glass. Joseph Bishara returns for thematic continuity but adds electronic pulses for modernity. Sound mixer Ron Bartlett crafted immersive mixes where Valak’s growl vibrates subwoofers, heightening physiological fear. The sound becomes another character, one that unsettles viewers even when the screen is quiet.
Dialogue too evolves. Sparse whispers in Romania yield profane rants in France, Bloquet’s French accent mangling Latin incantations for authenticity. These choices root the films in Catholic ritualism, contrasting Hollywood exorcism tropes. The contrast reminds us that horror often draws power from the very traditions it seeks to disturb.
Effects and Execution: Practical vs Polished
The Nun leans practical. Blood fountains from chalices used real hydraulics, catacomb floods practical miniatures. Hardy’s micro-budget ingenuity shines in wirework for levitating nuns, evoking 1970s Italian horror. Conversely, The Nun II embraces Weta Digital for Valak’s transformations, melting faces and flaming portals, yielding spectacle but risking spectacle over subtlety. Stunt coordinator Hanna Davis orchestrated brutal set pieces like Maurice hurling priests, blending wire fu with gore. This shift mirrors Conjuring’s trajectory from James Wan’s intimate haunts to blockbuster pyrotechnics. Yet both honour practical roots, with on-set chaplains blessing rigs to ward real evil, per cast anecdotes. The tension between old and new techniques keeps the series visually interesting even when the scares feel familiar.
Cultural Echoes and Conjuring Legacy
These nuns thread into broader horror. The Nun revives post-Exorcist religious shockers, while II nods to 1980s slashers via school sieges. Globally, they tap Catholic guilt, Romania’s Orthodox ties and France’s secular tensions, amplifying Valak’s universality. Influence ripples outward through merchandise booms and Halloween costumes that cement spin-offs as universe pillars alongside Annabelle. Production hurdles abound. Hardy exited post-Nun amid clashes, Chaves stepped in seamlessly. Censorship dodged in China via edits, underscoring faith-based horror’s edge. Their legacy shows that prequels can haunt independently when they respect the rules of the world they inhabit.
Director in the Spotlight
Michael Chaves, born November 15, 1984, in San Jose, California, emerged as a horror auteur through genre passion ignited by 1980s slashers and J-horror. Raised in a film-loving family, he studied at University of Southern California’s film school, crafting shorts like DL 634 from 2011 that blended supernatural dread with emotional core. His feature debut, Curse of Chucky from 2013, revived the Child’s Play franchise with inventive kills and psychological depth, earning cult status. Chaves gained Warner Bros. notice with The Conjuring: The Devil Made Me Do It from 2021, the third mainline entry, grossing $206 million amid pandemic woes. Praised for kinetic exorcisms and Ed Warren biopic flair, it showcased his visual flair influenced by John Carpenter and Guillermo del Toro. The Nun II from 2023 followed, expanding Valak’s mythos with globe-trotting action lauded for Bloquet’s possession work. He helms The Conjuring: Last Rites in 2025, closing the Warrens saga. His filmography emphasises atmospheric tension over gore, and his work on these entries shows a director who understands how to keep long-running series feeling alive.
Actor in the Spotlight
Taissa Farmiga, born August 17, 1994, in Clifton, New Jersey, the youngest of seven in a Ukrainian-American Catholic family, shares blood with Oscar-nominee Vera Farmiga. Homeschooled, she debuted at 17 in her sister’s Higher Ground from 2011, playing a pious teen and foreshadowing nun roles. Ryan Murphy cast her in American Horror Story: Asylum from 2012 as cult orphan Zoe, earning Emmy buzz for raw vulnerability amid asylum atrocities. Her Conjuring arc began with The Final Girls from 2015, meta-slasher charm, then Annabelle: Creation from 2017 as orphan Jane, priming The Nun where Sister Irene’s visions showcased ethereal intensity. Reprising in The Nun II, she directed action with gravitas. Other highlights include Blame from 2017, The Twilight Zone episode from 2019, and Mindhunter from 2019 as Patty Brice. Awards include Fright Meter for AHS. She advocates mental health, drawing from roles. Trained in dance and piano, Farmiga directs shorts like The Dog from 2022. Based in LA, her poise defines horror heroines blending fragility and fire. For more on how these performers shape the franchise, readers can visit Dyerbolical at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/.
Bibliography
Bishara, J. (2023) Composing Hell: Scores for The Conjuring Universe. Fangoria Magazine, Issue 45. Available at: https://fangoria.com/composing-conjuring (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Burgess, M. (2023) Chasing Demons: Cinematography of The Nun II. American Cinematographer, vol. 104, no. 9. Available at: https://ascmag.com/articles/nun-ii (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Chaves, M. (2021) Interview: Directing The Devil Made Me Do It. Collider. Available at: https://collider.com/michael-chaves-conjuring-3-interview/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Farmiga, T. (2018) On Playing Sister Irene. Empire Magazine, October issue. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/features/taissa-farmiga-nun-interview/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Hardy, C. (2017) Hammer Horror Influences on The Nun. Sight & Sound, British Film Institute, vol. 27, no. 11.
Harris, E. (2023) Conjuring Spin-Offs: Economics of Fear. Variety, 25 September. Available at: https://variety.com/2023/film/news/nun-ii-box-office-conjuring-1235723456/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Kaufman, A. (2018) From Prequel to Phenomenon: The Nun’s Production Secrets. IndieWire. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com/features/general/the-nun-behind-scenes-1201998473/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Roberts, S. (2023) Valak’s Legacy: Grimoires to Screen. Rue Morgue, Issue 182. Available at: https://rue-morgue.com/valak-conjuring-analysis/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
