Two mothers arrive in Los Angeles carrying the weight of a brutal Chicago murder committed by their own sons, hoping the sunshine and soundstages might wash away the stain. Curtis Harrington’s 1971 film What’s the Matter with Helen? follows that desperate gamble and shows how the dream factory can twist hope into something far more dangerous.

This article looks at the story, the performances, the director’s background, and the place the movie holds in the psycho-biddy cycle that flourished in the early seventies.

From Chicago Killers to California Killjoys

The film opens in 1934 Chicago, where the brutal murder of a young boy by two teenage killers shocks the nation, echoing the real-life Leopold and Loeb case that gripped America two decades earlier. Adelle (Debbie Reynolds) and Lorraine (Shelley Winters), the killers’ distraught mothers, decide to escape the scandal by relocating to sun-drenched Los Angeles. There, they reinvent themselves as proprietors of the Sister Act School of Dance for Girls, a nod to the era’s obsession with child stars like Shirley Temple. But the past clings like stage makeup; anonymous letters and eerie phone calls remind them of their infamy, while financial woes and romantic entanglements push them toward the brink.

Harrington masterfully weaves the narrative through meticulously recreated 1930s aesthetics. The sisters’ modest bungalow contrasts sharply with the grandeur of nearby studios, symbolising their outsider status in the dream factory. As Adelle blossoms under the attention of a wealthy patron, Lewis Medford (Dennis Weaver), her transformation from frumpy widow to glamorous hopeful feels both triumphant and treacherous. Lorraine, however, spirals into alcoholism and delusion, her affections turning obsessive toward a precocious pupil, Billy (Roberta Wallach), whom she grooms as the next Temple.

The plot thickens with supernatural-tinged horror elements. Visions of the murdered boy haunt the women, blurring lines between guilt-induced hallucination and genuine ghostly retribution. A pivotal scene unfolds at a lavish Hollywood party, where Adelle’s budding romance collides with Lorraine’s unraveling psyche, culminating in a frenzy of smashed mirrors and shattered illusions. Harrington employs shadowy cinematography, courtesy of Lucien Ballard, to heighten tension, with elongated shadows creeping across art deco interiors like fingers from the grave.

Without spoiling the feverish finale, the story crescendos in a blood-soaked ballet of betrayal and vengeance, revealing the depths of maternal denial and the perils of living vicariously through fame. The screenplay by Henry Farrell, fresh off scripting What Ever Happened to Baby Jane?, infuses the proceedings with deliciously overheated dialogue, ripe for camp appreciation. Every accusation and confession lands like a melodramatic aria, yet underpinned by genuine pathos.

Star Turns in a House of Horrors

Debbie Reynolds, forever etched in collective memory as the wholesome Tammy or the spirited Singin’ in the Rain ingenue, delivers a revelation here. Her Adelle evolves from dowdy despair to predatory poise, shedding inhibitions like an old costume. Reynolds channels the era’s starlets with uncanny precision, her tap-dancing interludes infused with manic glee. Critics at the time praised her for embracing the grotesque, a bold pivot from her squeaky-clean image that showcased her versatility.

Shelley Winters, no stranger to unhinged roles after The Night of the Hunter and Lolita, chews scenery with Oscar-calibre ferocity. Lorraine’s descent is a tour de force: from boozy bluster to feral frenzy, Winters imbues her with tragic humanity. Her rendition of “When You Wish Upon a Star” atop a grand piano becomes an iconic moment of warped nostalgia, twisting Disney innocence into something sinister. The chemistry between the leads crackles, their sisterly bond fraying like threadbare velvet.

Supporting turns add flavour. Agnes Moorehead shines as Sister Alma, the landlady whose sanctimonious prying hints at deeper secrets. Michael MacLiammoir provides oily charm as the priestly confessor, while the child performers inject eerie authenticity. Harrington’s direction elicits powerhouse performances, balancing histrionics with restraint to avoid mere parody.

Sound design amplifies the unease. David Raksin’s score swells with lush strings and dissonant piano, evoking Hollywood’s heyday while underscoring psychological fracture. Diegetic tunes like Temple hits pepper the soundtrack, their saccharine cheer clashing against mounting dread for maximum irony.

Psycho-Biddy Perfection: Design and Decade Dressing

Visually, the film is a feast for retro eyes. Production designer Eugène Lourie crafts period splendor: feathered gowns, crystal chandeliers, and marquees hawking Bright Eyes. The dance school’s cheery facade belies its horrors, with mirrored walls reflecting fractured psyches. Practical effects, from bloodied bathtubs to phantom apparitions, rely on clever illusions rather than gore, aligning with the era’s tasteful terror.

Harrington draws from his experimental roots, incorporating surreal flourishes like slow-motion breakdowns and dreamlike montages. The 1930s setting serves dual purpose: immersing viewers in vintage glamour while critiquing its hollowness. Shirley Temple fanaticism becomes a metaphor for blind idolatry, prescient in an age of manufactured idols.

Costuming by Moss Mabry accentuates character arcs. Adelle’s wardrobe upgrades mirror her ascent, from drab housedresses to sequined splendor. Lorraine’s dishevelled furs and smeared lipstick signal decay. Every detail, from Bakelite phones to floral wallpaper, transports us to a bygone era, making the film’s 1971 release feel like a time capsule unearthed.

Cultural Echoes and Hagsploitation Legacy

Released amid the psycho-biddy boom, think Bette Davis and Joan Crawford in Whatever Happened to Baby Jane?, this film carves its niche by blending homage with innovation. It predates the slasher surge yet anticipates its maternal monsters, influencing later works like Mommie Dearest. Cult status bloomed via late-night TV and VHS tapes, cherished by horror collectors for its quotable camp.

Thematically, it probes guilt, ambition, and the dark side of motherhood. In post-Manson Hollywood, the mother-son killer motif resonates with societal anxieties over youth rebellion. Fame’s Faustian bargain rings true today, as social media amplifies Temple-like obsessions. At Dyerbolical we often return to these films because they still speak to how quickly admiration can curdle into obsession.

Production anecdotes abound. Reynolds and Winters bonded over shared Broadway dreams, improvising scenes for authenticity. Harrington clashed with studio execs over tone, insisting on psychological depth over schlock. Budget constraints birthed ingenuity, like using real 1930s props sourced from auctions.

Legacy endures in fan conventions and restorations. Arrow Video’s Blu-ray revival introduced it to millennials, sparking podcasts dissecting its queer subtext. Harrington’s closeted perspective adds layers to the women’s codependence. Collecting original posters or lobby cards fetches premiums among ephemera hunters, testifying to its enduring allure.

Director/Creator in the Spotlight

Curtis Harrington, born in 1926 in Los Angeles, grew up amid Hollywood’s golden haze, son of a silent-era screenwriter. Fascinated by cinema’s mystical potential, he studied at USC before diving into avant-garde waters. As a teenager, he collaborated with Maya Deren on Ritual in Transfigured Time (1946), honing his eye for symbolic dread. His feature debut, Night Tide (1961), a moody seaside horror starring Dennis Hopper, blended film noir with supernatural whispers, earning praise from underground cinephiles.

Harrington’s career spanned genres, often exploring feminine psychosis and coastal unease. Voyage to the Prehistoric Planet (1965), a Soviet import repackaged with Basil Rathbone, showcased his knack for B-movie alchemy. Queen of Blood (1966), dubbed from a Russian sci-fi, featured Florence Henderson battling vampiric aliens, blending camp with cosmic chills. Television beckoned with episodes of Dynasty, The Twilight Zone, and Night Gallery, where his atmospheric touch elevated anthologies.

The 1970s marked his hagsploitation peak. How Awful About Allan (1970 TV film) starred Anthony Perkins in a Poe-esque guilt trip. What’s the Matter with Helen? followed, cementing his rep for star-driven psychodramas. Whoever Slew Auntie Roo? (1972) reunited Shelley Winters with Lionel Jeffries in a Hansel-and-Gretel twist. Later, The Cat Creature (1973 TV) prowled with David Hedison, while Devil Dog: The Hound of Hell (1978) unleashed demonic pets on Aldo Ray.

Influenced by Cocteau and Anger, Harrington infused works with homoerotic tension and dream logic. Post-retirement, he lectured on fantasy cinema, authored Nice Boys Don’t Kill (memoir excerpts), and championed preservation. He passed in 2007, leaving a filmography of 20+ features and shorts that punch above their weight, revered by auteurs like Guillermo del Toro for pioneering indie horror aesthetics.

Actor/Character in the Spotlight

Shelley Winters, born Shirley Schrift in 1920 Brooklyn to Jewish immigrants, clawed from chorus lines to stardom. Spotted by Lewis Milestone, she debuted in What a Blonde (1945) but exploded in The Diary of Anne Frank, netting a Supporting Actress Oscar in 1959. Method-trained under Lee Strasberg, she embodied raw emotion, winning another for A Patch of Blue (1965).

Her screen persona swung from sexpot to harridan. Early bombshell roles in The Night of the Hunter (1955) opposite Robert Mitchum showcased vulnerability amid menace. The Big Knife (1955) and Executive Suite (1954) displayed dramatic chops. Post-Oscars, she embraced grotesques: Lolita (1962) as Quilty’s mistress, Harper (1966) gumshoe foil.

Television triumphs included The Poseidon Adventure (1972), where her self-sacrificing belle clinched a third nod. Next Stop, Greenwich Village (1976) drew on her youth. Horror highlights: Bloody Mama (1970) as Ma Barker, Whoever Slew Auntie Roo?, and What’s the Matter with Helen?, her unhinged Lorraine a pinnacle of hag ferocity. Later, The Delta Force (1986) paired her with Chuck Norris.

Winters authored memoirs Shelley Also Known as Shirley (1981) and Shelley II (1989), spilling Tinseltown tea. Married four times, including to Vittorio Gassman, she mothered two, championing civil rights and feminism. Her 150+ credits span Alfresco voice work to The Portrait (1993). Dying in 2006 at 85, she remains a force of nature, her gravelly laugh echoing in cult canon.

Bibliography

Harrington, C. (1995) Nice Boys Don’t Kill: Curtis Harrington on Film. Fab Press.

Winters, S. (1981) Shelley: Also Known as Shirley. William Morrow.

Lucas, T. (2006) The Video Watchdog Book of Video Horror Guides. Video Watchdog.

Mendik, X. (2000) Sex, Vampires and Severed Heads: The Psycho-Biddy Phenomenon. Reynolds & Hearn.

Beck, C.T. (1973) Scream Queens: A Pictorial History of the Psycho-Biddy Horror Film. MacMillan Publishing.

Del Toro, G. (2007) Interviews and essays on Curtis Harrington. Various film journals.

Arrow Video (2014) What’s the Matter with Helen? Blu-ray liner notes.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289