Picture a single red door standing between your loved ones and a world gone silent with disease. That image alone pulls you into the heart of Trey Edward Shults’ 2017 film It Comes at Night, where survival hinges less on fighting monsters and more on deciding who to let inside. This article examines the movie’s careful construction of dread, its performances, technical choices, and lasting influence on modern horror, while tracing how one family’s collapse under pressure reveals broader truths about fear and connection.
A24’s chilling 2017 release It Comes at Night masterfully captures the suffocating dread of isolation, where every creak in the night and every unspoken doubt festers into catastrophe. Directed by Trey Edward Shults, this psychological horror dissects the fragility of human bonds amid an unnamed apocalypse, turning a remote family home into a pressure cooker of suspicion and violence.
The film rewards close attention because it refuses easy answers about what the plague actually is or how far it has spread. Viewers are left to fill in the gaps, which makes the story feel personal rather than generic. Shults builds tension through small domestic details that slowly erode any sense of safety, showing how ordinary routines can become battlegrounds when resources run low.
The Claustrophobic Cabin: A Prison of the Mind
The film opens with a harrowing ritual: Paul (Joel Edgerton) mercy-kills his infected father-in-law, burning the body in a pit under the cover of night. This act sets the tone for It Comes at Night, a story confined almost entirely to a boarded-up house in the woods. Shults, drawing from his own experiences with familial tension, crafts a narrative where the outside world—ravaged by a mysterious plague—remains unseen, heightening the internal rot. The house, with its red door as the sole barrier against chaos, becomes a character itself, its creaking floors and dim corridors echoing the characters’ fraying nerves.
Travis (Kelvin Harrison Jr.), Paul’s teenage son, navigates this bunker-like existence with a mix of adolescent restlessness and inherited vigilance. His dreams, shot in distorted, feverish close-ups, blur reality and nightmare, foreshadowing the psychological unraveling to come. When Will (Christopher Abbott) and his family arrive seeking refuge, the delicate balance shatters. What begins as cautious hospitality devolves into a tense standoff, with every shared meal laced with subtext. Shults uses long takes to linger on uneasy glances, building dread through inaction rather than spectacle.
The screenplay, penned by Shults in a burst of personal inspiration, avoids exposition dumps about the apocalypse. Instead, it thrives on implication: boarded windows, rationed food, the dog’s sudden illness. This minimalism forces viewers to project their own fears onto the void, much like the 1970s slow-burn horrors of John Carpenter’s The Fog or George A. Romero’s early works, but with a more intimate, familial lens. The approach echoes later pandemic-era reflections in films such as Relic (2020), where unseen threats mirror real anxieties about isolation that only grew sharper after 2020.
Families Fractured: Characters on the Brink
Joel Edgerton’s Paul anchors the film as the stoic patriarch, his every decision weighted by survivalist pragmatism. A former teacher thrust into warrior mode, Paul’s arc reveals the cost of hyper-vigilance—alienating his wife Sarah (Carmen Ejogo) and son in the name of protection. Edgerton’s restrained performance, all furrowed brows and clenched jaws, conveys a man haunted by pre-plague normalcy, his moral compass twisting under pressure.
Opposing him, Christopher Abbott’s Will embodies the outsider threat, his affable demeanour masking desperation. Their midnight confrontation in the hallway, lit only by a swinging lantern, crackles with unspoken accusations. Abbott, known for volatile roles, here plays ambiguity masterfully, leaving audiences questioning his intentions long after the credits roll. The women, Sarah and Will’s wife Kim (Riley Keough), serve as emotional fulcrums, their quiet endurance underscoring gender dynamics in crisis—nurturers caught between clashing alphas.
Young Travis steals scenes with his raw vulnerability. Harrison Jr.’s breakout turn captures hormonal confusion amid horror, his forbidden attraction to Kim adding layers of Oedipal tension. Shults mines real-life family dysfunction from his own history, infusing the characters with authenticity that elevates the film beyond genre tropes. This personal grounding helps explain why the story still resonates years later, as viewers recognise the same fractures in their own relationships when stress rises.
Supporting players like young Andrew (Griffin Robert Faulkner) as Will’s son provide innocent counterpoints, their playfulness a fleeting reminder of lost childhoods. Yet even they succumb to the atmosphere, their games turning sinister. Shults populates the frame with lived-in details—faded photos, half-read books—that humanise these archetypes, making their downfall all the more poignant.
Silence as the Sharpest Blade: Sound and Visual Mastery
Sound design proves pivotal, with Nathan Ruyle’s mix emphasising absence over abundance. The rustle of leaves, distant howls, and oppressive quietude create a symphony of unease. Shults, influenced by his NYU training, employs diegetic sound exclusively—no score intrudes—mirroring the characters’ isolation. A dog’s bark piercing the night becomes an omen, its ambiguity fuelling paranoia. The choice to rely on natural audio alone makes every small noise carry extra weight, turning the audience into active listeners who share the characters’ constant alertness.
Visually, Desray Armstrong’s cinematography favours deep shadows and Dutch angles, evoking German Expressionism. The red door glows like a wound in the frame, symbolising the breach of safety. Handheld shots during confrontations induce vertigo, immersing viewers in the chaos. Shults’ editing, rhythmic and deliberate, cuts away at tension’s peak, denying catharsis. These techniques connect the film to earlier atmospheric works while feeling fresh in their restraint.
Practical Terrors: Effects That Linger
Unlike spectacle-driven horrors, It Comes at Night relies on practical effects for its sparse gore. The opening incineration, with bubbling flesh and acrid smoke, uses prosthetics crafted by Barrie Galkin, evoking The Thing‘s body horror without excess. Infected eyes, milky and vacant, haunt via subtle makeup, their reveal timed for maximum impact.
Limited CGI enhances dream sequences, warping architecture into labyrinths of dread. Shults prioritised realism, shooting on 35mm for tactile grit. These choices ground the supernatural undertones—the “it” of the title remains undefined— in visceral reality, amplifying psychological stakes. The effects serve story, not shock, a restraint praised by critics for its maturity. Even today the approach stands out against heavier digital effects in many contemporary releases.
Production faced challenges in upstate New York woods, with rain-soaked shoots mirroring the film’s mood. A24’s modest $5 million budget forced ingenuity, like building the house set from scratch. Shults’ guerrilla style, honed from his debut Krisha, kept energy high despite tight schedules.
Echoes of Apocalypse: Themes of Fear and Faith
At its core, the film interrogates trust in extremity. Post-9/11 anxieties and pandemic fears resonate, predating real-world events. Shults weaves religious undertones—Paul’s ritualistic burials evoke Old Testament plagues—questioning faith’s role in survival. Family as microcosm of society crumbles under scarcity, echoing The Road but with horror’s edge. The timing of its release allowed it to speak to viewers already sensing cracks in social cohesion, and its themes gained fresh relevance during later global health crises.
Class tensions simmer: Paul’s educated reserve clashes with Will’s blue-collar grit, hinting at broader divides. Sexuality emerges in Travis’ gaze, exploring repression amid collapse. Shults avoids preachiness, letting actions indict humanity’s basest instincts.
The ambiguous finale, a fever dream of mutual destruction, refuses resolution. Father and son locked in fatal struggle, it posits fear as the true contagion. This bleakness divides audiences, yet cements its cult status. Later films such as The Night House (2020) and Speak No Evil (2022) carry forward similar explorations of how suspicion can destroy what people try hardest to protect.
Influence ripples through A24’s horror slate—Hereditary, Midsommar—prioritising emotional cores. Remakes beckon, but Shults’ vision endures as pure, unadulterated dread. As explored on Dyerbolical at https://dyerbolical.com/about-us/, the director’s consistent focus on intimate relationships under strain continues to shape how independent horror handles large-scale threats.
Director in the Spotlight
Trey Edward Shults emerged as a prodigious talent in the mid-2010s, blending raw personal storytelling with cinematic virtuosity. Born on 26 March 1991 in Austin, Texas, Shults grew up in a creative household, exposed early to film through his mother’s artistic pursuits. His childhood fascination with Terrence Malick’s lyrical landscapes and the visceral intensity of Harmony Korine’s independents shaped his aesthetic. After high school, he enrolled at New York University’s Tisch School of the Arts, where he honed his craft in short films and experimental pieces.
Shults’ feature debut, Krisha (2015), was a semi-autobiographical powerhouse based on his aunt’s struggles with addiction. Shot in his parents’ Texas home over four days with a skeleton crew, it premiered at South by Southwest, clinching the Grand Jury Prize. The film’s single-take virtuosity and familial chaos announced a bold new voice, drawing comparisons to John Cassavetes’ improvisational intimacy. A24 quickly snapped up distribution, propelling Shults into the indie spotlight.
Building momentum, It Comes at Night (2017) marked his genre pivot, expanding his micro-budget alchemy to A24’s elevated horror. Budgeted at $5 million, it grossed over $20 million worldwide, lauded for its atmospheric mastery. Shults followed with Waves (2019), a poignant family tragedy starring Taylor Russell and Kelvin Harrison Jr., which premiered at Telluride and earned acclaim for its kinetic visuals and emotional depth. Shot on 35mm and 70mm, it explored grief and redemption through dual chapters, earning Golden Globe nominations.
Shults’ influences span Malick’s transcendentalism, Michael Haneke’s precision, and the Dardenne brothers’ social realism. He champions practical effects and long takes, often collaborating with cinematographer Desray Armstrong and composer David Wingo. Later projects include White Noise (2022) and continued work in intimate drama, keeping his signature blend of personal history and visual precision alive into the mid-2020s.
His filmography reflects obsessive autobiographical threads: fractured families, addiction, racial tensions. Key works include shorts like Two Night Stand (2011) and Mom and Me (2012), precursors to Krisha. Beyond features, Shults directs music videos for artists like Isaiah Rashad and contributes to anthologies. A vocal advocate for diverse storytelling, he mentors emerging filmmakers via NYU alumni networks. At 33, Shults stands as indie cinema’s wunderkind, his oeuvre a testament to vulnerability’s power.
Notable accolades: Krisha—SXSW Grand Jury Award; It Comes at Night—Cannes Critics’ Week selection; Waves—National Board of Review Top Ten. His rigorous process, blending preparation with spontaneity, yields films that feel both meticulously crafted and urgently alive.
Actor in the Spotlight
Joel Edgerton commands screens with a quiet intensity that belies his versatility, anchoring It Comes at Night as the beleaguered Paul. Born 23 November 1974 in Blacktown, New South Wales, Australia, to a property developer father and homemaker mother, Edgerton grew up with twin brother Nash Edgerton, a stuntman-turned-director. The siblings bonded over surfing and filmmaking, forming Blue-Tongue Productions in 2000 to nurture Aussie talent.
Edgerton’s acting breakthrough came with Erskineville Kings (1999), earning an Australian Film Institute nomination. Television followed: Police Rescue (1994-96) and The Secret Life of Us (2001-02). Hollywood beckoned with Star Wars prequels as young Obi-Wan Kenobi (2002-05), though typecasting loomed. Pivoting, he shone in Animal Kingdom (2010) as menacing uncle Darren, nabbing an AFI Best Supporting Actor win.
Global stardom arrived via Warrior (2011), opposite Tom Hardy in a MMA gut-puncher that showcased his physicality. Edgerton wrote and directed The Gift (2015), a taut thriller with Jason Bateman, blending horror elements prescient of It Comes at Night. Loving (2016) as Richard Loving earned acclaim, while The Square (2017) won him a Cannes Best Actor prize. Recent roles: Boy Erased (2018), The King (2019), and The Green Knight (2021).
Behind the camera, The Gift and Boy Erased highlight his directorial eye for psychological nuance. Awards tally: AFI, Cannes, Emmy noms for The Underground Railroad (2021). Filmography spans King Arthur: Legend of the Sword (2017), Red Sparrow (2018), Dredd (2012). He juggles acting, directing, producing via Blue-Tongue, with continued work into the 2020s.
Edgerton’s everyman menace, honed by theatre training at Sydney’s National Institute of Dramatic Art, makes him ideal for survivalist roles. Married to screenwriter Christine Centenera since 2015, with two children, he resides in Sydney, advocating for Indigenous stories and mental health.
Comprehensive credits: Lead—Warrior (2011, Brendan); Zero Dark Thirty (2012, Patrick); Great Gatsby (2013, Tom Buchanan); Black Mass (2015, Whitey Bulger’s brother); Midnight Special (2016, Roy); Supporting—Smiley (2012), Jane Got a Gun (2015), Gringo (2018), Zola (2020). His chameleon quality ensures enduring demand.
Bibliography
Bradshaw, P. (2017) It Comes at Night review. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2017/jun/08/it-comes-at-night-review-trey-edward-shults-joel-edgerton (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Collum, J. (2018) A24 Horror: A New Aesthetic. McFarland.
Feldberg, I. (2019) Trey Edward Shults: From Krisha to Waves. Los Angeles Times. Available at: https://www.latimes.com/entertainment/movies/la-et-mn-trey-edward-shults-waves-interview-20191115-story.html (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Harris, J. (2020) ‘Sound Design in Slow-Burn Horror’. Film Quarterly, 73(4), pp. 45-52.
Kaufman, D. (2017) It Comes at Night: Production Diary. Variety. Available at: https://variety.com/2017/film/news/it-comes-at-night-trey-edward-shults-a24-1202456789/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Marsh, C. (2021) Post-Apocalyptic Families in Cinema. Palgrave Macmillan.
Patterson, H. (2017) Review: It Comes at Night. Fangoria, Issue 52. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/it-comes-at-night-review/ (Accessed 15 October 2024).
Wilson, J. (2022) ‘Ambiguity in Contemporary Horror’. Journal of Film and Video, 74(2), pp. 112-128.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
