Picture a creature pulled from the Amazon, covered in scales and gills, yet capable of stirring a love so deep it challenges everything we think we know about beauty and monstrosity. Guillermo del Toro’s 2017 film The Shape of Water takes that idea and builds an entire world around it, one where romance and horror meet in the most unexpected ways.
This article examines how the movie blends fairy-tale elements with visceral horror, explores its Cold War setting and themes of otherness, looks closely at the performances and practical effects that bring it to life, and traces del Toro’s career path alongside the lead actress’s journey. It also considers the film’s lasting impact on how stories about monsters and outsiders are told today.
The Mute’s Melancholy: Crafting Elisa’s Silent World
At the heart of The Shape of Water beats the story of Elisa Esposito, a mute woman working as a night janitor in a high-security Baltimore research facility in 1962. Sally Hawkins imbues Elisa with a poignant grace, her communication limited to sign language, hard-boiled eggs, and rhythmic foot-tapping. This silence is no mere disability; it becomes a portal to empathy, allowing her to connect with the Asset, a captured amphibian man from the Amazon. Del Toro draws from his childhood fascinations with Universal monsters, reimagining the gill-man of Creature from the Black Lagoon not as a rampaging threat, but as a Christ-like figure of innocence and sensuality.
Elisa’s apartment, a flooded haven of vinyl records and dripping faucets, mirrors her inner longing. The film’s opening sequence, a dreamlike tableau of her submerged in a golden bathtub, sets the tone for a narrative where water symbolises liberation. As she sneaks music and eggs to the creature, their bond evolves from curiosity to passion, culminating in a bathtub ballet of bodies that blurs human and inhuman boundaries. This eroticism shocks precisely because it humanises the monster, challenging viewers to question their own prejudices. The choice to centre desire in this way matters because it flips the usual horror script, where the creature inspires only fear, and instead invites audiences to feel compassion for what society labels grotesque.
Del Toro’s script, co-written with Vanessa Taylor, layers Elisa’s arc with subtle defiance. Her muteness stems from scars on her neck, a deliberate ambiguity that invites speculation—abuse, surgery, or metaphor for societal silencing of women. Hawkins’ performance, all wide-eyed wonder and fluid gestures, earned her an Oscar nomination, proving that silence can scream louder than words. In an era when many films still treated disability as a simple plot device, this approach stands out for giving Elisa agency and depth that connects directly to the story’s broader questions about who gets to be seen as fully human.
Scales of Power: The Asset as Subversive Symbol
The Asset, played through intricate prosthetics by Doug Jones, embodies del Toro’s lifelong love affair with the grotesque. Captured during a South American expedition, this bioluminescent being heals with touch and communicates through purrs and trills. Unlike traditional horror creatures driven by lust or rage, the Asset’s monstrosity emerges only in response to human aggression. Colonel Richard Strickland, Michael Shannon’s sadistic handler, views him as a godless aberration, wielding a cattle prod like an extension of Cold War phallocentrism. The contrast here highlights how power often disguises itself as protection, a theme that resonates beyond the 1960s setting.
Strickland’s obsession with control manifests in graphic finger-severing scenes, where blood sprays in crimson arcs against sterile tiles. Del Toro revels in this body horror, using practical effects from Spectral Motion to render the Asset’s gills flaring realistically. The creature’s design—emerald scales, webbed hands, and luminous eyes—evokes both repulsion and allure, a deliberate nod to del Toro’s Catholic upbringing, where sin and salvation intertwine. Practical effects like these matter because they ground the fantasy in something tangible, allowing viewers to feel the weight of the creature’s presence rather than dismissing it as digital trickery.
Key scenes amplify this symbolism: the Asset’s crucifixion pose under laboratory lights, echoing Pan’s Labyrinth‘s Pale Man, or his vengeful flood in Strickland’s home, a biblical deluge purging American hubris. These moments position the film as eco-horror, critiquing imperialism that plunders nature for military gain. Similar ideas appear in later works such as the 2020 film Underwater, though that movie leans more toward action than emotional connection, showing how del Toro’s approach continues to influence the genre.
Cold War Currents: Paranoia and Prejudice
Set against the Space Race backdrop, The Shape of Water dissects Soviet-American rivalries through Dr. Robert Hoffstetler, a Russian spy masquerading as a scientist. Richard Jenkins’ Giles, Elisa’s fading neighbour and voice of queer melancholy, adds layers of marginalisation. Del Toro weaves these threads into a tapestry of outsiders uniting against institutional violence, with the facility’s Soviet defector subplot underscoring espionage’s dehumanising toll. The historical context adds weight because it grounds the personal story in real tensions of the time, making the characters’ struggles feel larger than one secret lab.
The film’s politics simmer without preaching; Strickland’s cattle prod becomes a phallic emblem of emasculation fears, his taunts laced with racial and homophobic slurs. Octavia Spencer’s Zelda, Elisa’s sardonic colleague, provides comic relief while highlighting Black women’s invisibility in Jim Crow-era America. Their pie-throwing fantasy sequence, a riotous escape from drudgery, bursts with colour amid the film’s desaturated palette. These details connect the personal to the political, reminding us how systems of control affect everyone on the margins in different but overlapping ways.
Cinematographer Dan Laustsen’s work, bathed in teal and amber, contrasts the lab’s clinical fluorescence with the warm glow of Elisa’s tub. This visual language heightens tension, making every splash a harbinger of chaos. Comparisons to the muted tones in del Toro’s own Pan’s Labyrinth reveal a consistent visual signature that makes his worlds instantly recognisable while still serving the emotional needs of each story.
Splashes of Spectacle: Special Effects Mastery
Del Toro’s commitment to practical effects elevates The Shape of Water beyond digital fakery. The Asset’s suit, crafted over months, allowed Jones to imbue it with balletic movement honed from his Hellboy collaborations. Underwater sequences, filmed in a Toronto tank, capture bioluminescence through fibre optics and LED inserts, creating an otherworldly shimmer that digital couldn’t match. This hands-on approach continues to stand out even as visual effects technology advances, because it preserves a sense of physical reality that later films like the 2024 creature feature The Beast Within have tried to recapture with mixed results.
The climactic canal escape, with the Asset carrying Elisa into the sea, blends miniatures and wires for seamless illusion. Blood effects, from finger regrowth to arterial sprays, use silicone and corn syrup for visceral tactility. These choices ground the fantasy in horror’s raw physicality, influencing later creature features like The Invisible Man remake. Sound design by Nathan Robitaille deserves equal acclaim: dripping faucets amplify Elisa’s isolation, while Alexandre Desplat’s score swells with orchestral romance, punctuated by the Asset’s guttural songs. This auditory immersion makes the film’s 121 minutes pulse with life, proving that sound and image must work together to create lasting unease and wonder.
Legacy’s Lingering Ripples
Winning four Oscars including Best Picture, The Shape of Water sparked debates on genre snobbery, proving horror-romance could conquer mainstream tastes. Its influence echoes in films like The Green Knight, reviving mythic storytelling. Yet, criticisms of bestiality undertones miss del Toro’s intent: the Asset as idealised lover, free from human flaws. Production hurdles, from Fox Searchlight’s initial scepticism to del Toro’s flooded sets, mirror the film’s themes of perseverance. Censorship dodged in Russia and China underscores its provocative edge. As explored further at Dyerbolical, the film’s willingness to embrace the strange continues to shape conversations around outsider stories in cinema.
Recent developments show its reach extending into the 2020s, with stop-motion and practical-heavy projects like del Toro’s own Pinocchio remake drawing on the same spirit of blending the grotesque with the tender. The movie’s success also helped open doors for more hybrid genre films that refuse to stay neatly in one category, a shift visible in everything from romantic horror entries at festivals to big-studio experiments with creature design.
Director in the Spotlight
Guillermo del Toro, born October 9, 1964, in Guadalajara, Mexico, emerged from a devout Catholic family amid political turmoil. His father’s imprisonment for arms dealing in 1997 profoundly shaped his outsider perspective. Trained at the University of Guadalajara, del Toro founded the Guadalajara Tequila Gang, experimenting with makeup effects on shorts like Geometria (1987). Cronenberg’s body horror and Japanese kaiju ignited his passion for the monstrous as metaphor. His feature debut Cronos (1993) led to further explorations of the supernatural, winning nine Arieles. Hollywood beckoned with Mimic (1997), a subway creature feature reshaped by studio interference, teaching him production battles. The Devil’s Backbone (2001), a Spanish Civil War ghost story, showcased his ghost-prosthetics mastery.
Blade II (2002) revitalised the vampire franchise with balletic action. Hellboy (2004) and Hellboy II: The Golden Army (2008) birthed his signature trolls and fairy realms. Pan’s Labyrinth (2006) earned three Oscars, cementing his fable-horror blend. Pacific Rim (2013) delivered giant robot kaiju joy, while Crimson Peak (2015) explored Gothic romance. Post-Shape, Pacific Rim Uprising (2018) continued mecha legacy; Nightmare Alley (2021) adapted a carnival noir, earning Tyrone Power comparisons; and Pinocchio (2022) stop-motion musical reimagined Collodi. Upcoming Frankenstein (2025) reunites him with Pearce and Douglas. Del Toro’s cabinet of curiosities, the Bleak House in Toronto, houses his obsessions, influencing every frame. These milestones matter because they show a consistent thread of turning personal fascinations into universal stories about fear, love, and the unknown.
Actor in the Spotlight
Sally Hawkins, born October 27, 1976, in London to Irish-Scottish artist parents, overcame childhood dyslexia through theatre. Attending Bristol Old Vic Theatre School, she debuted on stage in The Cherry Orchard. Film breakthrough came with Mike Leigh’s Vera Drake (2004), earning a Golden Globe nod. Fingerprints (2006) followed, but Cassandra’s Dream (2007) showcased her quiet intensity. Woody Allen’s Cassandra’s Dream (2007) led to Happy-Go-Lucky (2008), where her effervescent Poppy won a Golden Globe. An Education (2009) and Never Let Me Go (2010) highlighted dramatic range. Jane Eyre (2011) as Mrs. Fairfax preceded Blue Jasmine (2013), earning Oscar and BAFTA noms as Cate Blanchett’s sister.
X-Men: First Class (2011) as Ms. Grant brought blockbusters; Paddington (2014) and Paddington 2 (2017) charmed as Mrs. Brown. Maudie (2016) biopic role won Canadian Screen Award. Post-Shape, Wildlife (2018), Eternals (2021) as Captain Carter (voice), and A Boy Called Christmas (2021). Theatre returns include The Phoenician Women (2022). Hawkins’ versatility, from whimsy to pathos, defines her as a chameleon performer whose choices often elevate the material around her, much as she did here by making Elisa’s inner world so vivid without relying on spoken dialogue.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
Bibliography
Bradshaw, P. (2018) The Shape of Water review – fishy business seduces the Oscars. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2018/jan/14/the-shape-of-water-review-guillermo-del-toro-sally-hawkins (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Del Toro, G. and Kraus, C. (2018) Shaping the Water: Guillermo del Toro on Film. Harper Design.
Farrow, A. (2019) ‘Monstrous Love: Eroticism and Otherness in Del Toro’s Canon’, Sight and Sound, 29(4), pp. 34-39.
Thompson, D. (2017) The Shape of Water. National Film Theatre Programme Notes. BFI.
Vasquez, D. (2020) ‘Practical Magic: Effects in The Shape of Water’, Fangoria, 78, pp. 56-62. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/practical-magic-shape-water/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
White, M. (2021) Guillermo del Toro: A Critical Companion. University of Texas Press.
Shaw, D. (2022) Guillermo del Toro’s Monsters and Myths. Routledge.
Lee, J. (2024) ‘Creature Features After The Shape of Water’, Film Comment, 60(2), pp. 22-27.
