In the deep woods where old stories still breathe, two films turn the Brothers Grimm tale of Hansel and Gretel into something far more unsettling than childhood fable.

Few fairy tales have endured as potently as the Brothers Grimm’s Hansel and Gretel, a grim parable of abandonment, hunger and cannibalistic temptation. Yet in recent years, cinema has revisited this archetype through the lens of folk horror, birthing two standout visions: Robert Eggers’s The Witch (2015) and Osgood Perkins’s Gretel & Hansel (2020). Both films strip away the saccharine Disney veneer, plunging audiences into raw, atmospheric terror rooted in matriarchal menace and adolescent awakening. This analysis pits them against each other, exploring how they reforge fairy tale elements into modern nightmares of gender, faith and the feral wild.

Both films master slow-burn dread, using sparse dialogue and natural soundscapes to evoke the isolation of the Grimm woods, transforming folklore into psychological siege. They subvert patriarchal structures, positioning young women—Thomasin and Gretel—as reluctant inheritors of witchly power, challenging Puritan repression and medieval famine alike. Visually poetic and thematically intertwined, these works cement folk horror’s resurgence, influencing a wave of fairy tale reinterpretations with their unflinching gaze on female agency and societal collapse.

The Witch and Gretel & Hansel: Tracing Grimm Fairy Tale Roots Through Modern Folk Horror

The Brothers Grimm’s 1812 tale of Hansel and Gretel, born from oral traditions of famine-ravaged Europe, warns of parental betrayal and the seductive peril of the unknown. Children lured by a candy house encounter a witch who fattens them for the oven—a stark metaphor for starvation’s horrors amid medieval peasant life. The Witch and Gretel & Hansel draw directly from this vein, but elevate it into cinematic dread. Eggers’s film transplants the peril to 1630s New England, where a banished Puritan family unravels under supernatural assault. Thomasin (Anya Taylor-Joy), the eldest daughter, navigates accusations of witchcraft amid crop failure and infant disappearance. Meanwhile, Perkins’s adaptation foregrounds Gretel (also Taylor-Joy), who with brother Hansel flees a witch-hunt-plagued village into a forest where an enigmatic Holda (Alice Krige) offers shelter—and secrets.

What distinguishes these reimaginings is their fidelity to folk horror’s tenets: rural isolation, archaic rituals and the blurring of human and monstrous. Eggers, obsessed with historical accuracy, recreates 17th-century dialogue from trial transcripts, immersing viewers in a world where God seems absent and the devil whispers through a black goat named Black Phillip. Perkins, conversely, leans into mythic abstraction, with narration evoking bedtime stories turned sinister. The films’ shared woodland antagonist—the witch—embodies not cartoon villainy but elemental force, a devourer of innocence tied to earth’s fecundity. This reimagining resonates in an era of #MeToo reckonings, where female predators upend male-dominated narratives. The same tension appears in later works such as The VVitch follow-ups and Ari Aster’s Midsommar, where ancient belief systems press against fragile modern psyches.

In The Witch, the family’s disintegration mirrors Puritan anxieties documented in period diaries, such as those of Cotton Mather, who chronicled spectral hysteria. William (Ralph Ineson) chops wood futilely, his patriarchal authority crumbling as daughter Thomasin matures into womanhood, her body politicised by siblings’ suspicions. The film’s climax, with Black Phillip’s seductive offer—“Wouldst thou like to live deliciously?”—tempts Thomasin toward liberation through carnality and flight, a naked silhouette vanishing into night. Perkins echoes this in Gretel & Hansel, where Holda’s gingerbread cottage pulses with hallucinatory allure, teaching Gretel herb lore that awakens her latent powers. Hansel, fattened and infantilised, becomes the sacrificial brother, inverting the tale’s dynamics as Gretel wields the staff of agency.

Puritan Shadows and Famine Fires

Eggers’s mastery lies in historical texture; The Witch was researched via primary sources like William Bradford’s Of Plymouth Plantation, capturing the era’s theological terror. The family’s farm, shot on practical sets in Ontario’s Kaaterskill woods, reeks of authenticity—muddy thatch roofs, period looms and a goat whose demonic baritone unnerves. Sound design amplifies unease: wind howls presage calamity, while Thomasin’s prayers dissolve into silence. Critics like Mark Kermode praised its “period-perfect dread,” likening it to The Crucible meets Psycho. Yet the witch remains unseen until late, her presence inferred through milk-souring and crow-pecked eyes, building paranoia akin to The Blair Witch Project’s unseen evil. That same careful attention to lived detail later shaped Eggers’s Nosferatu in 2024, where period accuracy again grounds supernatural dread.

Perkins’s Gretel & Hansel, filmed in Ireland’s misty glens, adopts a more stylised palette—emerald greens bleeding into crimson visions—evoking Arthur Rackham illustrations. The script, penned by Perkins from Rob Hayes’s story, expands Gretel’s arc into feminist bildungsroman. Fleeing a village burning “witches” (echoing 17th-century European hunts), the siblings encounter Holda, whose maternal guise masks devouring hunger. Taylor-Joy’s Gretel, voiceover-narrating her foreboding dreams, grapples with visions of staff-wielding power, subverting the passive damsel. Production notes reveal Perkins drew from Angela Carter’s bloody revisions in The Bloody Chamber, infusing erotic undercurrents absent in Grimm. The approach feels closer to the atmospheric reimaginings that followed, including the 2022 Netflix series Wednesday, which also leans on gothic fairy-tale imagery.

Comparatively, Eggers favours verisimilitude, Perkins poetry. Where The Witch’s claustrophobic 4:3 aspect ratio traps the family, Gretel & Hansel’s wide frames swallow protagonists in arboreal vastness. Both indict paternal failure: William’s pride blinds him to wilderness threats, mirroring the woodcutter father’s abandonment. These films dissect how folklore encodes survival strategies, witches symbolising famine (historical striges in Slavic lore) or menstrual taboos, as feminist folklorist Maria Tatar argues in Off with Their Heads!

Sorcerous Soundscapes and Visual Hexes

Audio crafts the terror’s spine. In The Witch, composer Mark Korven’s strings scrape like branches on flesh, Black Phillip’s voice modulated to velvet menace. Eggers insisted on location recording, capturing Ontario winds that mimic laments. Perkins employs a hypnotic score by Robin Coudert, layering Gretel’s whispers over fungal throbs, evoking psychedelic folk like Midsommar. Silence punctuates both—Thomasin’s milkmaid labour, Gretel’s mushroom trance—forcing viewers to confront internal horrors.

Cinematography elevates myth to art. Jarin Blaschke’s work in The Witch bathes scenes in natural light, flames flickering on Anya Taylor-Joy’s freckled face during the broom flight hallucination. Perkins’s Gretel & Hansel, lensed by Shlomo Godder, employs Dutch angles and slow zooms, Holda’s staff glowing like Excalibur inverted. Practical effects shine: The Witch’s prosthetics for the crone (Bathsheba Garnett) evoke Suspiria, while Gretel’s transformation uses subtle makeup, blood bubbling organically. No CGI crutches; both honour tangible dread, influencing A24’s folk horror renaissance that continued into films such as The Lighthouse and The Northman.

Matriarchal Mayhem: Gender and Power Unveiled

Central to both is female ascension amid collapse. Thomasin rejects modesty’s yoke, signing Satan’s book for autonomy—a radical Puritan inversion. Gretel embraces witchcraft as empowerment, devouring Hansel’s heart in symbolic matricide. Scholar Carol Clover, in Men, Women, and Chain Saws, sees this as “final girl” evolution, witches as monstrous feminine reclaimed. Taylor-Joy embodies this duality: innocent eyes hardening to command.

Patriarchy crumbles viscerally. William’s axe fails, the father’s knife rusts; mothers (Katherine in The Witch, absent in Gretel) wail impotently. Holda grooms Gretel as successor, mirroring Black Phillip’s pact. These narratives query: Is witchcraft rebellion or predation? Eggers nods to misogynistic trials, Perkins to Carter-esque revisionism, both affirming women’s historical scapegoating per Silvia Federici’s Caliban and the Witch.

Performances amplify. Ineson anchors The Witch’s fervour, Harvey Scrimshaw’s Caleb writhes convincingly in possession throes. Taylor-Joy’s Gretel simmers with quiet rage, Krige’s Holda mesmerises with apple-cheeked menace. Ensemble chemistry sells familial fracture, no weak links.

Legacy Lurking in the Thicket

The Witch grossed $40 million on $4 million budget, spawning cult fandom and memes (“live deliciously”). It influenced Hereditary and The Lighthouse, Eggers’s follow-ups. Gretel & Hansel, though lesser-seen ($160k opening), garnered acclaim for subversion, echoing in Netflix’s Wednesday. Together, they revive fairy tale horror post-Pan’s Labyrinth, proving Grimm’s relevance amid climate anxieties and gender wars. More recent echoes appear in 2024’s Nosferatu and the ongoing interest in folk-horror revivals that stretch into 2025 and 2026 releases.

Production tales enrich: Eggers battled financiers doubting dialogue’s opacity, Perkins faced COVID delays. Censorship skirted—The Witch’s nudity integral, not exploitative. Legacy endures in podcasts dissecting Black Phillip theories, fan art of Gretel’s staff. At Dyerbolical these conversations continue to grow among viewers who return to the films years later.

Director in the Spotlight: Robert Eggers

Robert Eggers, born July 7, 1983, in New Hampshire, grew up steeped in maritime folklore from his fishing family roots. A child actor in regional theatre, he shifted to production design after studying at New York University’s Tisch School briefly. Self-taught filmmaker, Eggers worked as a prop master on indie sets before scripting The Witch, inspired by his ancestor’s 1630s witchcraft accusations unearthed in genealogical digs. Debuting at Sundance 2015, it won the Directing Award, launching his auteur status with A24.

Eggers obsesses over authenticity, collaborating with dialect coaches and historians. Influences span Dreyer’s Vampyr, Bergman’s faith crises and Powell’s Black Narcissus. Career highlights include The Lighthouse (2019), a claustrophobic Dafoe-Pattinson fever dream earning Oscar nods for cinematography; The Northman (2022), a Viking revenge saga blending Shakespeare with Norse sagas, starring Alexander Skarsgård; and Nosferatu (2024), a gothic remake with Lily-Rose Depp and Bill Skarsgård. Upcoming projects continue his focus on historical texture and practical effects. Known for meticulous prep—months on sets—he champions practical effects, critiquing Marvel excess. Married to Courtney Stagl, with two children, Eggers resides in New York, his films dissecting masculinity’s fragility through historical prisms.

Filmography highlights: The Witch (2015): Puritan folk horror unravelling family faith. The Lighthouse (2019): Monochrome myth of isolation and madness. The Northman (2022): Epic Viking odyssey of vengeance and shamanism. Nosferatu (2024): Murnau homage amplifying erotic dread.

Actor in the Spotlight: Anya Taylor-Joy

Anya Taylor-Joy, born May 16, 1996, in Miami to Argentine-Scottish descent, grew up in Buenos Aires and London, fluent in Spanish, English and French. Spotted at 16 modelling, she pivoted to acting after drama school rejections, debuting in The Split (2011). Breakthrough: The Witch (2015), her piercing gaze capturing Thomasin’s terror-to-triumph at 18. Subsequent roles exploded her profile.

Taylor-Joy’s career trajectory blends horror, prestige and franchise: Emma Woodhouse in Emma (2020), earning BAFTA acclaim; chess prodigy Beth Harmon in Netflix’s The Queen’s Gambit (2020), netting Golden Globe, Screen Actors Guild Award; mutant Illiana “White Queen” Rasputin in The New Mutants (2020); Last Night in Soho (2021) opposite Thomasin McKenzie; The Northman (2022); Gretel in Gretel & Hansel (2020). Blockbusters: Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga (2024), prequel lead replacing Charlize Theron; Dune: Prophecy series (2024). Directed short The Cabin (2022). Influences: Kate Bush, Cate Blanchett. Vegan activist, married to musician Malcolm McRae since 2022, she advocates mental health post-Queen’s Gambit pressures.

Filmography highlights: The Witch (2015): Bewitched daughter embracing darkness. Split (2016): Kidnapped survivor in Shyamalan thriller. Thoroughbreds (2017): Psychopathic teen schemer. The Queen’s Gambit (2020 miniseries): Addicted genius chessmaster. Emma. (2020): Witty Regency heiress. Gretel & Hansel (2020): Empowered fairy tale avenger. The Northman (2022): Mystic seer in Viking epic. Furiosa (2024): Wasteland warrior origin.

Bibliography

Clover, C. J. (1992) Men, Women, and Chain Saws: Gender in the Modern Horror Film. Princeton University Press.

Federici, S. (2004) Caliban and the Witch: Women, the Body and Primitive Accumulation. Autonomedia.

Kermode, M. (2016) ‘The Witch review – bewitching tale of devilish goings-on’, The Observer, 13 March. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2016/mar/13/the-witch-review-bewitching-tale-of-devilish-goings-on (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Tatar, M. (1992) Off with Their Heads! Fairy Tales and the Culture of Childhood. Princeton University Press.

Carter, A. (1979) The Bloody Chamber and Other Stories. Gollancz.

Rosenberg, T. (2020) ‘Gretel & Hansel: A Fairy Tale for the Post-#MeToo Age’, Fangoria, Issue 52, pp. 34-39.

Eggers, R. (2015) Interview: ‘Historical Horror with Robert Eggers’, Sight & Sound, British Film Institute, September.

Perkins, O. (2020) ‘Directing Gretel & Hansel: Oz Perkins on Fairy Tale Subversions’, IndieWire, 31 January. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com/features/interviews/oz-perkins-gretel-hansel-interview-1234502487/ (Accessed: 15 October 2024).

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289