In a remote house where every sound carries weight, a single red door stands between safety and the unknown, pulling viewers into a story that questions what we fear most when the world falls apart.
This article takes a close look at Trey Edward Shults’ 2017 film It Comes at Night, tracing its story, the choices behind its making, the performances that anchor it, and the way its quiet tension still resonates years later. We will examine how the movie builds dread without relying on typical horror tropes, why its focus on human behavior sets it apart, and what it reveals about trust during times of crisis.
Joel Edgerton’s haunted gaze in It Comes at Night (2017) captures the essence of dread that lingers long after the credits roll, a film that transforms a remote house into a pressure cooker of suspicion and survival.
The film’s relentless ambiguity forces viewers to confront their own fears of the unknown in an apocalyptic world. Family dynamics fracture under the weight of paranoia, revealing the fragility of trust in extremis. Trey Edward Shults’ intimate direction blends psychological horror with stark realism, echoing real-world anxieties about contagion and division.
The Quarantined Nightmare Unfolds
In It Comes at Night, director Trey Edward Shults plunges us into a world ravaged by an unnamed plague, where the primary survivors are Paul (Joel Edgerton), his wife Sarah (Carmen Ejogo), and their teenage son Travis (Kelvin Harrison Jr.). They barricade themselves in a boarded-up house deep in the woods, adhering to strict rules: never open the red door without checking, always wear a mask outside, and burn any infected body immediately. The narrative begins with Paul’s mercy killing of his own infected father, a ritualistic burial that sets the tone of grim necessity. Travis, restless in this enforced isolation, patrols the property at night, his dreams invaded by visions of black ooze and familial betrayal.
The arrival of Will (Christopher Abbott), a desperate stranger with his own wife Kim (Riley Keough) and young son Andrew, shatters their solitude. Paul captures Will trespassing for water, and after tense negotiations, the families agree to share the house under uneasy truce. Meals become minefields of veiled accusations, sleeping arrangements breed resentment, and a shared dog heightens territorial instincts. Shults withholds the nature of the blight, refusing to show infected hordes or grotesque mutations, which amplifies the terror through implication. Every creak in the night, every unspoken glance, builds a suffocating atmosphere where the real contagion spreads through doubt.
The plot spirals when Andrew falls ill after a midnight escapade with Travis. Symptoms mirror the plague: fever, black sores, violent convulsions. Accusations fly. Did Travis infect him out of jealousy? Did Will bring the disease? Paul’s rules harden into tyranny, culminating in a hallucinatory climax where boundaries of reality blur. Travis awakens to carnage, his family decimated, stumbling into the forest alone. The red door, once a symbol of security, swings open to an uncertain void, leaving audiences to ponder if the ‘it’ that comes at night was ever external.
Paranoia as the True Plague
At its core, It Comes at Night dissects paranoia as an infectious force more lethal than any virus. Shults draws from post-9/11 anxieties and the 2014 Ebola outbreak, where fear of outsiders morphed into xenophobia. Paul’s fortress mentality mirrors societal bunkers, from gated communities to border walls, where protection devolves into prejudice. The film’s confined setting, a single house with recurring motifs like the red door and a gnarled tree, functions as a microcosm of fractured America, where scarcity breeds suspicion.
Travis embodies the generational chasm. His erotic dreams of Kim expose adolescent turmoil amid apocalypse, blending desire with destruction. A pivotal scene where he spies on the couple’s intimacy through a cracked door fuses voyeurism with violation, foreshadowing the privacy erosions that doom them. Shults employs Dutch angles and tight close-ups to distort perception, making viewers complicit in the surveillance. Sound design masterfully weaponises silence. Distant howls and laboured breaths punctuate the quiet, mimicking the auditory hallucinations of isolation.
Class undertones simmer beneath the surface. Paul, a former teacher with survivalist preparations, views Will, a scrappy everyman, as a threat to his resources. Their bartering over chickens and water reveals power imbalances, echoing historical land disputes and resource wars. Yet Shults avoids didacticism, letting ambiguity invite multiple readings. Is Paul a prudent patriarch or a control freak? Will an opportunist or a genuine refugee? This moral greyness elevates the film beyond survival schlock. Similar questions appear in later works like His House from 2020, which also uses confined spaces to explore how crisis exposes deeper social fractures.
Cinematography’s Claustrophobic Grip
Shults, cinematographer on his debut Krisha, wields the camera like a scalpel. Long takes roam the house’s dim corridors, lit by flickering lanterns that cast elongated shadows, evoking The Shining‘s Overlook Hotel but stripped of supernatural excess. The Steadicam glides through rooms, invading personal space and blurring safe havens into traps. Night sequences plunge into near-blackness, forcing reliance on inference, a technique honed from Shults’ music video background. These visual decisions matter because they place the audience inside the characters’ limited perspective, turning ordinary rooms into sources of unease.
Colour palette favours desaturated greens and browns, punctuated by the arterial red door, a nod to The Shining‘s blood elevators but symbolising forbidden knowledge. Compositional symmetry fractures as tensions rise. Early family portraits give way to asymmetrical groupings, visually manifesting discord. Rain-lashed windows reflect distorted faces, merging inner turmoil with external chaos. These choices not only heighten immersion but underscore themes of perceptual unreliability, a technique that has influenced directors working in the same intimate horror vein since the film’s release.
Sound and Silence: The Auditory Assault
Soundscape reigns supreme in It Comes at Night, composed by Brian McOmber with diegetic emphasis. Footsteps echo hollowly on wooden floors, breaths rasp through masks, doors groan like dying beasts. The score minimalism, sparse piano stabs and dissonant drones, amplifies ambient horrors, drawing from Under the Skin‘s industrial unease. Travis’ nightmares feature throbbing heartbeats and gurgling fluids, bleeding into waking life to erode sanity.
A key sequence, the midnight dog attack, relies solely on guttural snarls and frantic panting, unseen violence inferred from reactions. This restraint contrasts blockbuster apocalypses, proving less is more in psychological terror. Shults’ Atlanta upbringing, amid Southern gothic traditions, infuses folklore-like whispers, where the unseen ‘it’ evokes childhood boogeymen. The approach feels especially relevant after years of real-world isolation during the COVID-19 pandemic, when many recognised the same creeping dread from empty streets and uncertain news.
Family Under Siege: Bonds and Betrayals
Interfamilial rifts form the emotional core. Paul and Sarah’s marriage strains under his authoritarianism. Her pragmatic mercy contrasts his rigidity. Travis, caught between loyalty and rebellion, navigates Oedipal tensions, his bond with Paul tested by accusations. The interloping family introduces mirrors. Will and Kim’s tenderness highlights Paul’s dysfunction. Andrew’s innocence serves as a reminder of lost futures.
Shults explores paternal legacy. Paul teaching Travis to kill the dog parallels his own father’s euthanisation, a cycle of inherited violence. Gender roles invert subtly. Sarah handles medical duties, Kim forages boldly. Yet machismo prevails, culminating in Paul and Will’s fatal confrontation, fists replacing words in primal regression. These moments show how crisis strips away civility and forces people to confront the limits of their own decency.
Legacy of Ambiguity in Horror
Released amid The Walking Dead fatigue, It Comes at Night revitalised apocalyptic horror by subverting expectations. No zombies, no heroes, just human frailty. Its box office underperformance belies critical acclaim, influencing films like Saint Maud or His House in intimate dread. Streaming revivals on platforms like Netflix cemented its cult status, sparking endless forums debating endings. As explored further at Dyerbolical, the film’s refusal to provide easy answers continues to shape conversations about what horror can achieve when it focuses on people rather than monsters.
Production hurdles shaped its rawness. Shot in 25 days on Super 16mm for grainy tactility, Shults funded via Krisha‘s Sundance buzz. Improvised dialogues lent authenticity, cast chemistry forged in rehearsal isolation mirroring the plot. A24’s marketing teased monsters, subverting to psychological punch, alienating some but rewarding patient viewers. Recent reappraisals in 2024 and 2025 have noted how the story anticipates the trust breakdowns seen during global health crises, giving the film added weight today.
Effects and Realism: No Gore, All Gut Punch
Special effects prioritise practicality over CGI. Infections manifest via subtle makeup, veins blackening, eyes glazing, avoiding excess for plausibility. The dog’s demise uses practical animatronics, convulsions achieved through puppeteering for visceral impact. Dream sequences employ practical fog and practical lighting to evoke miasmic dread, budget constraints birthing ingenuity.
This grounded approach amplifies horror. No hordes mean threats feel personal, intimate. Shults consulted virologists for symptom accuracy, grounding fantasy in pandemic realism prescient of COVID-19 lockdowns. The technique demonstrates why restraint often creates more lasting unease than elaborate spectacle, a lesson many filmmakers have taken to heart in the years since.
The film’s conclusion resists closure, Travis silhouetted against dawn, questioning survival’s worth. Shults affirms horror’s power in unanswered queries, cementing It Comes at Night as a modern parable of division.
Director in the Spotlight
Trey Edward Shults, born in 1989 in Austin, Texas, emerged as a prodigious talent in independent cinema, blending personal introspection with visceral storytelling. Raised in a musically inclined family, his brother is composer Aaron Shults, he gravitated towards filmmaking during high school, shooting skate videos and music clips that honed his visual rhythm. After attending film school sporadically, Shults decamped to New York, working odd jobs while crafting shorts. His breakthrough came with the semi-autobiographical Krisha (2015), a 21-minute tour de force about familial addiction shot in his parents’ house with real relatives, premiering at Sundance where it clinched the Grand Jury Prize.
It Comes at Night (2017) marked his narrative feature debut, expanding Krisha‘s claustrophobia to apocalyptic scales, earning A24 distribution and critical raves for its tension. Shults followed with Waves (2019), a two-part family tragedy exploring grief and redemption through Florida siblings, lauded for its kinetic camerawork and score. It garnered Independent Spirit nominations. Influences span Terrence Malick’s lyricism, Michael Haneke’s rigour, and Gaspar Noé’s subjectivity, fused with hip-hop aesthetics from his video days. His later anthology work and music videos show the same interest in fractured relationships that defined his early features.
Shults’ oeuvre obsesses over dysfunctional kinships, often autobiographical. Krisha drew from his mother’s struggles, Waves from sibling dynamics. He self-finances via grants, champions diverse casts, Kelvin Harrison Jr. in multiple roles, and advocates analogue film. Upcoming projects include a horror-thriller teased in interviews. Filmography highlights include Krisha (2015), It Comes at Night (2017), and Waves (2019). His meticulous prep yields immersive worlds, positioning him as horror’s new auteur.
Actor in the Spotlight
Joel Edgerton, born 23 June 1974 in Blacktown, New South Wales, Australia, embodies everyman intensity with a chameleonic range. Son of a schoolteacher father and property developer mother, he grew up with brothers in Sydney’s suburbs, discovering acting via high school theatre and commercials. Twin brother Nash later collaborated on films. Edgerton trained at Sydney’s National Institute of Dramatic Art (NIDA), debuting in TV’s Police Rescue (1994) and soap Home and Away (1995-1996). Breakthrough came with Erskineville Kings (1999), earning Aussie Film Institute nods.
Hollywood beckoned with Star Wars prequels as young Obi-Wan Kenobi (2002-2005), though typecast initially. Pivots in Warrior (2011) as MMA fighter opposite Tom Hardy showcased physicality, grossing acclaim. Edgerton directed and starred in The Gift (2015), a sleeper hit psychological thriller, and Loving (2016) as civil rights icon Richard Loving, earning Golden Globe noms. Recent turns include Boy Erased (2018), The King (2019), The Green Knight (2021), and Thirteen Lives (2022). Awards include an AACTA for Warrior and an Emmy nomination for Loving. Offscreen, he farms in Australia, produces via Blue Tongue with Nash, and champions indie fare. Edgerton’s Paul channels restrained fury, cementing his horror affinity from The Gift.
Bibliography
Farrell, J. (2017) It Comes at Night: A24’s Paranoia Masterclass. Fangoria, 12 June. Available at: https://www.fangoria.com/it-comes-at-night-review/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Jones, D. (2018) ‘Ambiguity in Contemporary Horror: Shults and the Apocalypse’, Journal of Film and Video, 70(2), pp. 45-62.
Shults, T.E. (2017) Interviewed by D. Erbland. IndieWire, 8 June. Available at: https://www.indiewire.com/features/general/trey-edward-shults-it-comes-at-night-interview-1201845602/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Knee, M. (2019) American Horror Cinema in the 2010s. Edinburgh University Press.
McOmber, B. (2017) Production notes for It Comes at Night. A24 Archives.
Rosenberg, A. (2020) ‘Post-Pandemic Reflections on It Comes at Night’, Sight & Sound, 30(5), pp. 22-25.
Travers, B. (2017) ‘It Comes at Night Review: The Scariest Thing This Year Isn’t What You Think’. Rolling Stone, 9 June. Available at: https://www.rollingstone.com/movies/reviews/it-comes-at-night-review-trey-edward-shults-joel-edgerton-192362/ (Accessed: 15 October 2023).
Erbland, K. (2024) ‘Revisiting It Comes at Night in a Post-Pandemic World’. IndieWire, 15 March.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
