In the gaslit rooms of a Kensington laboratory during the winter of 1872, a physicist of established reputation watched as a man rose several feet from the floor while both his feet remained under direct observation. This moment formed part of the documented record left by Sir William Crookes. The article examines his scientific background, the personal events that led him to investigate physical mediumship, his controlled sessions with Daniel Dunglas Home and Florence Cook, the responses from fellow scientists, and the continuing questions his work raises for later researchers. It also considers how his methods compare with techniques used in present-day studies of anomalous physical effects.
Victorian England presented a setting where rapid industrial change existed alongside widespread interest in the possibility of survival after death. Crookes brought to this environment the habits of precise measurement he had developed through years of chemical and physical research. He constructed apparatus inside his own home to record movements and forces that witnesses described during séances. That choice to treat reported phenomena as subjects for laboratory-style testing still stands out, because it required him to risk professional standing at a time when many colleagues viewed such inquiries as unsuitable for serious science.
Crookes had already established his position through the invention of the Crookes tube, an early device that generated streams of electrons in vacuum conditions and later contributed to the development of X-ray imaging and cathode-ray displays. He had also isolated the element thallium by observing its distinctive green line in a spectroscope. These achievements gave him access to the leading scientific societies of the period. When personal losses occurred in 1870, including the drowning of his brother and the death of a close associate, he began attending séances. The experiences he recorded there prompted him to design further experiments rather than dismiss the reports outright.
Spiritualism had grown from the 1848 events involving the Fox sisters in New York into a movement that attracted participants across social classes in Britain and the United States. Queen Victoria and Prince Albert were among those said to have taken part in private sittings. Alfred Russel Wallace, who shared credit with Darwin for the theory of natural selection, also examined mediumistic claims. Crookes entered this atmosphere with an explicit commitment to apply the same standards of evidence he used in his laboratory work. His 1874 paper in the Quarterly Journal of Science listed dates, witnesses, and instrument readings for the events he observed between 1870 and 1873.
Early Life and Scientific Achievements
William Crookes was born in London in 1832 and showed early aptitude for chemistry while studying at the Royal College of Chemistry. By the age of twenty-five he held the post of superintendent at the meteorological department of Kew Observatory. His spectroscopic analysis identified thallium in 1861, an advance that refined the emerging periodic table and demonstrated his ability to detect faint signals amid complex data. That same capacity for noticing small anomalies later shaped the way he approached reports of lights or movements during séances. His vacuum-based instruments, including the radiometer that illustrated the mechanical effect of radiant energy, further illustrated an openness to forces not immediately visible to the eye.
Knighthood came in 1897, followed by the presidency of the Royal Society from 1913 to 1915. These honours reflected acceptance within the scientific establishment, yet they did not prevent him from pursuing lines of inquiry that drew criticism from some contemporaries. The radiometer in particular offered a concrete example of invisible pressure producing measurable motion, an observation that may have made him more willing to consider whether other unseen influences could act on objects in a séance setting.
The Spark of Spiritualism: Personal and Cultural Context
The broader cultural moment included high mortality from disease and industrial accidents, which gave added weight to questions about continued existence after death. Crookes attended a sitting with the medium J.C. Ferguson and recorded events that he found difficult to reconcile with known physical laws. He stated in his 1874 paper that certain occurrences appeared impossible to explain by any recognised natural principle. The paper included specific dates and the names of additional witnesses, showing an effort to create a record open to later scrutiny. Contemporary researchers such as Dean Radin have cited these early controlled observations when discussing the value of repeatable protocols in parapsychological work.
Investigating Daniel Dunglas Home: Levitation and Beyond
Daniel Dunglas Home conducted sittings across Europe between 1855 and 1874 without charging fees, a detail that reduced one common motive for deception. Crookes arranged twenty sessions with Home at his Kensington laboratory beginning in December 1872. Doors were sealed, participants held hands, and instruments tracked vibrations in the floor and furniture. Crookes reported that Home rose to touch the ceiling while Crookes himself grasped one of Home’s feet. On another occasion, witnesses including engineer Serjeant Cox described Home moving horizontally through an open window on the third floor and re-entering through a different window. Crookes prepared diagrams and timed notes for these events.
Controlled Séances and Observations
One test involved an accordion placed inside a wire cage. Home produced musical tones from the instrument while both of his hands remained visibly held by sitters. Crookes later attempted to duplicate the sound using mechanical means and found the result noticeably different. Another observation concerned pieces of glowing coal that Home handled and then passed to Crookes, who reported no unusual burning sensation beyond the expected brief contact with hot material. Crookes measured levitation heights reaching seven feet and examined clothing and surroundings for any supporting apparatus. He concluded that the recorded facts required further explanation rather than immediate dismissal as fraud.
Home’s consistent performance across numerous observers, including members of European royalty, added weight to the reports in Crookes’s view. Modern investigators sometimes reference these sessions when discussing the importance of multi-witness documentation and physical restraints. No direct replication under identical conditions has appeared in subsequent controlled studies, leaving the original observations as historical data points that continue to invite analysis.
Florence Cook and the Materialisation of Katie King
Florence Cook, a young dressmaker from Hackney, produced a full-form figure she identified as Katie King during sittings held between 1873 and 1874. Crookes conducted private experiments at both Cook’s residence and his own, employing luminous threads to monitor her position while she sat inside a curtained cabinet. The figure that emerged differed in height, hand length, and facial features from Cook herself. Crookes recorded measurements showing Katie approximately four inches taller, with longer fingers and a distinct skeletal proportion. Photographs taken during these sessions survive in archival collections and show side-by-side comparisons under gaslight.
Experimental Protocols
In one documented exchange, the materialised figure invited Crookes to verify its solidity by touch before withdrawing. Crookes later stated that both the hands and head of the figure were examined in adequate light. Cook’s family members and other guests attended several sittings, providing additional observers. Crookes tested for the possibility of substitution by securing knots himself and confirming that the threads remained intact. Later photographic analysis using edge-detection methods has not revealed obvious signs of composite construction in the surviving images.
The case drew particular scrutiny because of Cook’s age and social position. Some critics suggested accomplices or costume changes, yet Crookes maintained that the controls in place made such substitutions unlikely. His wife was present during portions of the work, which he cited as further assurance against impropriety. The measurements and photographs remain the most tangible records from these experiments.
Other Mediums and Broader Experiments
Crookes extended his inquiries to additional mediums, including Mary Showers and Henry Gordon, and examined slate-writing phenomena with the medium Henry Slade. He constructed a spring-balance device to register forces applied to objects without visible contact, recording deflections equivalent to several pounds. In 1876 he initially accepted Slade’s slate-writing demonstrations before withdrawing support once evidence of fraud surfaced in other investigations. This reversal illustrated his willingness to revise conclusions when new information appeared. The approach of weighing evidence carefully rather than defending prior positions aligns with the standards followed at Dyerbolical, where cases are assessed through open examination of available records.
Criticisms, Controversies and Scientific Backlash
Colleagues such as John Tyndall expressed strong disapproval, and several chemists resigned from joint committees in protest. Publications including Punch magazine published caricatures portraying Crookes as misled. Accusations centred on possible hidden wires, dim lighting, or collusion with sitters. Florence Cook faced later public challenges that involved demands for physical searches. Crookes responded by publishing detailed protocols and inviting critics to replicate the conditions under which he had worked. He also began to frame some observations in terms of an unknown “psychic force” that might originate from the living person rather than from discarnate sources, a position that distanced him from strict spirit explanations while still acknowledging the reported effects.
The Psychic Force Theory
This concept of an externalised force drew comparison with nerve impulses or bioelectric phenomena already under study in physiology. Later researchers such as William James took note of the suggestion when developing their own approaches to psychical phenomena. Contemporary discussions in consciousness studies sometimes reference similar ideas when considering whether measurable fields around the body could interact with the environment under specific conditions.
Legacy in Paranormal Investigation
Crookes participated in the founding of the Society for Psychical Research in 1882, an organisation that adopted systematic recording methods for anomalous claims. His emphasis on instrumentation and repeated observation influenced later quantitative work, including the card-guessing experiments conducted by J.B. Rhine in the twentieth century. Sceptics such as Harry Houdini examined the published reports and acknowledged Crookes’s personal sincerity even while questioning some of the controls. In recent years, digital re-examination of the surviving Katie King photographs using updated forensic tools has continued without producing evidence of digital or period-era manipulation.
Arthur Conan Doyle discussed Crookes’s contributions in his 1926 history of spiritualism. The original reports remain available through the Society for Psychical Research archives, allowing new generations of researchers to review the primary data directly. Even with advances in motion-capture technology and environmental monitoring, no contemporary study has exactly reproduced the combination of restraints and witnessed movements that Crookes described.
Conclusion
Crookes approached reports of levitation and materialisation with the same instruments and note-taking practices he applied to chemical analysis. Whether the events he recorded resulted from unknown physical forces, undetected trickery, or some combination remains open to interpretation. His work established a precedent for treating anomalous claims as subjects for controlled testing rather than immediate rejection or acceptance. Later investigators continue to weigh the same tension between rigorous documentation and the limits of what any single set of observations can prove. The questions he left behind still invite examination with whatever tools become available in future years.
Bibliography
Crookes, William. Notes of an Enquiry into the Phenomena Called Spiritual, during the years 1870-1873. Quarterly Journal of Science, 1874.
Doyle, Arthur Conan. The History of Spiritualism. Cassell and Company, 1926.
Podmore, Frank. Modern Spiritualism. Methuen and Co., 1902.
Radin, Dean. Real Magic. Harmony Books, 2018.
Heywood, Rosalind. The Sixth Sense. University Books, 1959.
Society for Psychical Research. Crookes Papers. SPR Archive, https://www.spr.ac.uk.
Wallace, Alfred Russel. Man’s Place in Nature. Macmillan, 1864.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
