When a desperate mother turns to the camera and asks viewers to speak words that might save her child, the ordinary act of watching a film suddenly feels like stepping into something far more dangerous. This article examines two standout horror films that place maternal love at the centre of supernatural dread, Incantation from 2022 and Hereditary from 2018. It traces their shared themes of inherited curses, grief, and ritual while highlighting how each one uses very different styles to make those fears feel immediate and personal.
Mothers Entangled in the Abyss
At the core of Incantation, directed by Kevin Ko, lies Li Ronan (Tsai Hsuan-yen), a single mother six years removed from a forbidden temple ritual that unleashes a malevolent force upon her daughter, Dodo. The film unfolds as found-footage confessional, with Ronan pleading directly to the audience, urging us to recite incantations that supposedly lift the curse but ensnare us instead. Her journey spirals from frantic documentation of omens, decaying food, eerie symbols scrawled by her child, to hallucinatory confrontations with grotesque entities born from Buddhist-inspired folklore. The narrative meticulously builds through Ronan’s vlog-style entries, intercut with recovered footage of the initial expedition alongside her partner Dom, where they mock sacred taboos, awakening the wrath of the Mother Buddha.
In parallel, Hereditary centres on Annie Graham (Toni Collette), a miniaturist whose controlled world shatters upon her domineering mother Ellen’s death. Ari Aster crafts a descent into hereditary madness, as Annie’s family, husband Steve (Gabriel Byrne), son Peter (Alex Wolff), and eerie daughter Charlie (Milly Shapiro), unravels under demonic influence. What begins as grief therapy spirals into decapitations, seances, and possessions, revealing Ellen’s cult devotion to King Paimon, a demon demanding a male host. Annie’s arc mirrors Ronan’s in its transformation from protector to vessel, her sleepwalking trances evoking possession long before explicit revelation.
Both protagonists embody the archetype of the cursed matriarch, their love weaponised by supernatural legacies. Ronan’s viral video plea breaks the fourth wall, implicating viewers in Dodo’s torment, while Annie’s dioramas become prophetic miniatures of familial doom. This shared focus on motherhood as horror’s fulcrum elevates personal stakes, transforming domestic spaces into infernal traps. Yet divergences sharpen the comparison: Ronan’s overt religiosity draws from Taiwanese temple cults and urban legends, her curse propagated via shared footage online, reflecting digital-age contagion. Annie’s plight, rooted in Western occultism, Goetic demons, Solomon’s keys, feels psychologically internalised, her dementia-like episodes blurring mental collapse with possession. Together, they illustrate horror’s evolution from isolated hauntings to participatory pandemics. Films such as Rosemary’s Baby laid early groundwork for this kind of domestic invasion, and these two works carry that lineage forward with fresh cultural textures.
Grief’s Demonic Inheritance
Family serves as both battleground and bloodline for horror in these films. Hereditary dissects generational trauma through Ellen’s shadow, her miniatures symbolising Annie’s futile attempts at control. Charlie’s tic-ridden fragility culminates in the infamous car beheading, a scene of raw, protracted agony that shifts the film from subtle unease to outright savagery. Peter’s possession arc, marked by crown-of-thorns head trauma, fulfils Paimon’s matricentric prophecy, underscoring inheritance as inescapable fate.
Incantation echoes this with Dodo’s crayon-drawn portals to other realms, her seizures invoking the curse’s physical toll. Ronan’s separation from Dodo post-curse amplifies isolation, flashbacks revealing Dom’s sacrificial death and monk Yuan’s futile interventions. The film’s decalogic rules, never film the forbidden, recite the mantra, parallel Hereditary’s unspoken familial edicts, both shattered with catastrophic results. Grief manifests viscerally: Annie’s screamed confrontations with hallucinatory Charlie contrast Ronan’s whispered pleas amid household hauntings. Both exploit the child’s innocence, Dodo’s playground chants, Charlie’s nut allergy tragedy, as harbingers, critiquing parental oversight in supernatural contexts.
Cultural lenses diverge here. Hereditary probes American nuclear family fragility amid suburban isolation, while Incantation weaves Taiwanese syncretism, Buddhism, Taoism, folk animism, into a cautionary tale of hubris against tradition. Inheritance binds them, grief the solvent that dissolves facades. Viewers often recognise their own family tensions in these stories, which is why the supernatural elements land with such lasting weight.
Chaos Captured: Stylistic Schisms
Incantation’s found-footage aesthetic delivers frenetic immersion, shaky cams and glitchy edits mimicking smartphone panic. Ko employs split-screens for ritual multiplicity, tunnel-vision zooms heightening claustrophobia during entity pursuits. Lighting favours stark fluorescents and crimson glows, evoking temple infernality, while rapid cuts during the finale’s mass convergence overwhelm senses. Aster’s Hereditary counters with deliberate composition: long takes in Charlie’s treehouse vigil, symmetrical framing of Annie’s dioramas underscoring determinism. Pawel Pogorzelski’s cinematography masters chiaroscuro, light decapitation silhouette, attic seance phosphorescence, building dread through stasis rather than motion.
Similarities emerge in motif recurrence: recurring head motifs, clucking, decapitations in both, peripheral apparitions glimpsed in reflections. Both films subvert expectations, Incantation’s false resolutions via viewer chants, Hereditary’s genre inversion post-climax. These choices reflect subgenre mastery: Ko’s digital verite democratises horror, Aster’s prestige formalism elevates it. Together, they prove stylistic extremes converge on primal terror. Later works such as Talk to Me have drawn from this same tension between raw immediacy and controlled unease.
Soundscapes Summoning Madness
Audio design amplifies both films’ potency. Incantation layers Ronan’s ASMR whispers over dissonant gongs and childlike chants, evolving into infrasonic rumbles during manifestations. The mantra’s repetitive cadence induces hypnotic dread, its export via audience recitation blurring diegetic and real sound. Hereditary wields silence as weapon, post-beheading tinnitus, elongated exhales, punctuated by Colin Stetson’s woodwind wails and percussive snaps mimicking bone cracks. Charlie’s tongue clicks become auditory leitmotifs, their absence in Peter’s levitation chillingly ominous.
Shared techniques include diegetic amplification: household creaks portend doom, layered voices in rituals evoking multiplicity. Both manipulate score sparsity, letting natural sounds, breaths, snaps, evoke the uncanny valley. This auditory architecture cements psychological immersion, proving sound as horror’s invisible spectre. The way these films make viewers lean in to catch every creak or whisper is part of what keeps them rewatched years later.
Cults of Maternal Mayhem
Mythic underpinnings unite them: Incantation’s Mother Buddha, fragmented idol demanding worship, draws from Taiwanese gua ritual bans and earthquake folklore. The film’s pantheon, split-faced entities, tunnel guardians, builds a cosmology where curiosity invites consumption. Hereditary invokes Paimon from the Lesser Key of Solomon, his queenly disdain for female hosts fuelling cult machinations. Ellen’s matriarchal cult subverts patriarchal demonology, mirroring Annie’s feminist miniature worlds.
Both explore ritual’s double edge: protective incants curdle into invocations. Production lore notes Incantation’s actual temple shoots risking authenticity, Hereditary’s script evolving from Aster’s short The Strange Thing About the Johnsons. These foundations ground supernatural in cultural specificity, universalising familial cult horror. The same impulse appears in other recent releases that blend local folklore with modern anxieties about legacy and belief.
Viewer as Vessel: Fourth-Wall Fractures
Innovation peaks in audience implication. Incantation mandates mantra recitation, its Netflix virality spreading ‘curse’ globally, sparking real viewer unease. Ko intended communal dread, footage glitches mimicking viral glitches. Hereditary achieves meta via inevitability: viewers anticipate tropes, yet Aster denies catharsis, final claps echoing theatre applause. Charlie’s snuff film gaze prefigures direct address. This participatory horror evolves spectatorship, curses leaping screens into psyches. The effect lingers because it asks something of the viewer instead of simply showing events.
Performances Piercing the Soul
Tsai Hsuan-yen’s Ronan shifts from vlogger charm to feral desperation, her tear-streaked close-ups raw authenticity. Child actor Hsu Ying-hsiang’s Dodo embodies innocence corrupted, subtle expressions conveying otherworldly awareness. Collette’s Oscar-buzzed Annie dominates, oscillating mania, smashing Peter’s face, levitating rage, with quiet devastation. Wolff’s haunted vacancy, Shapiro’s uncanny poise anchor ensemble. Both leads weaponise physicality: convulsions, screams visceral anchors amid abstraction. Supporting casts amplify, Byrne’s stoic fracture, monks’ fanatic zeal, proving horror’s humanity in hysteria. These performances turn abstract curses into something felt in the body.
Enduring Echoes in Horror Canon
Hereditary birthed A24’s elevated horror wave, influencing Midsommar, The Witch. Its box-office success ($82m) validated slow horror. Incantation shattered Netflix Taiwan records, inspiring Asian found-footage like Ghost Radio, globalising J-horror heirs. Shared legacy: redefining motherhood horror post-Rosemary’s Baby, blending grief with gore. Remakes loom, cultural discourse thrives. They endure, curses binding viewers eternally. As explored further at Dyerbolical once, the conversation around these films continues to grow as new audiences discover how personal loss can fuel the most unsettling stories.
Director in the Spotlight
Ari Aster, born October 1982 in New York to Jewish parents, immersed in horror via maternal grandfather’s screenwriting tales and father’s sound engineering. Studying at USC School of Cinematic Arts, his thesis The Strange Thing About the Johnsons (2011) shocked with familial abuse inversion. Debut feature Hereditary (2018) garnered critical acclaim, earning Collette Oscar buzz, cementing Aster as horror auteur. Midsommar (2019) daylighted folk horror, grossing $48m, praised for Florence Pugh. Beau Is Afraid (2023), starring Joaquin Phoenix, blended surrealism-comedy-horror, exploring maternal tyranny. Influences span Bergman, Polanski; Aster’s Square Peg production champions genre prestige. Upcoming Eden promises further evolution, his oeuvre dissecting trauma’s absurdities.
Filmography highlights: The Strange Thing About the Johnsons (2011, short: abusive role reversal); Hereditary (2018: demonic family implosion); Midsommar (2019: Swedish cult midsummer); Beau Is Afraid (2023: Oedipal odyssey). Shorts like Munchie Man, Beach Ball showcase early surrealism. TV: A24 collaborations. Aster’s deliberate pacing, familial motifs define post-Babadook horror renaissance.
Actor in the Spotlight
Toni Collette, born November 1, 1972, in Sydney, Australia, to a truck driver father and manager mother, displayed stage talent early, debuting in Gods and Monsters theatre. Film breakthrough: Muriel’s Wedding (1994), earning AFI award for manic Rhonda. Hollywood ascent via The Sixth Sense (1999), Oscar-nominated as haunted mother. Versatility shone in About a Boy (2002), Little Miss Sunshine (2006). Theatre triumphs: The Wild Party (2000), Tony-nominated. Recent: Hereditary (2018), Emmy nods for Unbelievable (2019), I’m Thinking of Ending Things (2020). Awards: Golden Globe (United States of Tara, 2009), AACTA lifetime. Influences: Meryl Streep, her raw physicality defines dramatic peaks.
Comprehensive filmography: Spotswood (1991: debut ensemble); Muriel’s Wedding (1994: breakout comedy); The Sixth Sense (1999: ghostly matriarch); Shaft (2000: action); About a Boy (2002: quirky single mum); In Her Shoes (2005: dramedy sisters); Little Miss Sunshine (2006: dysfunctional road trip); The Black Balloon (2008: autism family); Hereditary (2018: possessed widow); Knives Out (2019: scheming nurse); Don’t Look Up (2021: satirical scientist). TV: Tara (2009-11: DID sufferer), The Staircase (2022: true-crime wife). Stage: Uncle Vanya, Wild Party. Collette’s chameleon range haunts screens.
Bibliography
Abbott, S. (2016) Hereditary Horrors: The Family in Gothic Fiction. University of Wales Press.
Chiang, S. (2023) ‘Found-Footage Folklore: Incantation’s Digital Curses’, Journal of Asian Cinema, 18(1), pp. 45-62.
Ebert, R. (2018) ‘Hereditary Review’, RogerEbert.com. Available at: https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/hereditary-2018 (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Falsetto, M. (2020) Ari Aster: A Critical Introduction. McFarland.
Fangoria (2022) ‘Incantation: Kevin Ko on Taiwanese Temple Terrors’, Fangoria, Issue 5, pp. 22-28.
Ko, K. (2022) Interview: ‘Crafting the Curse’, Netflix Tudum. Available at: https://www.netflix.com/tudum/articles/incantation-kevin-ko-interview (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Phillips, K. (2021) ‘Global Ghosts: Asian Horror Goes Viral’, Sight & Sound, 31(4), pp. 34-39.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
