Imagine standing in a crowded square as the local executioner raises his axe, only to wonder later whether that same hand had used similar tools in the dark to settle private scores. That unsettling question sits at the heart of this article, which examines how some medieval and early modern executioners in Europe moved from carrying out official sentences to committing murders of their own. We will look at documented cases from England, France, and German states, explore why their unique position made crime easier, and consider what these stories reveal about power and accountability in centuries past.

The Outcast Role: Why Executioners Were Primed for Crime

The profession of executioner, or Scharfrichter in German states, boutefeu or bourreau in France, and “hangman” in England, was hereditary and reviled. Families passed the role down generations, as no respectable citizen would touch it. Recruits were frequently convicts offered commutation: kill for the state, or die yourself. This origin story set a dangerous precedent.

Socially, executioners were pariahs. In 14th-century Germany, they could not enter taverns without permission and were forced to wear distinctive clothing. French executioners like the Sansons later professionalized the role, but in medieval times, they scavenged battlefields for unclaimed bodies to dissect or sell parts—a grisly side hustle that blurred ethical lines. Perks included the “right of the gibbet,” claiming hanged men’s belongings, tempting bribery and extortion.

Psychologically, constant exposure to death eroded empathy. Modern studies on capital punishment echo this: repeated killing desensitizes, fostering aggression spillover. In medieval logs, executioners like Nuremberg’s Franz Schmidt (1520–1618) meticulously recorded 361 executions but noted colleagues’ excesses. Schmidt himself was honorable, but his journal exposes a subculture rife with abuse. These conditions mattered because they created men who operated outside normal social rules while holding the power of life and death, a combination that invited trouble when personal motives entered the picture.

England’s Deadly Dynasty: The Brandons of London

Perhaps the most notorious executioner clan was the Brandon family, London’s hangmen from the late 16th to mid-17th centuries. Patriarch Gregory Brandon, dubbed “Young Brandon” despite his seniority, began as a cutpurse and highwayman before ascending to the scaffold at Tyburn. Contemporary ballads painted him as a killer who executed by day and murdered by night.

Gregory’s crimes extended beyond pickpocketing. Records from the Old Bailey suggest he and his gang targeted debtors, staging “accidents” to seize property. One account in a 1590s pamphlet accuses him of throttling a merchant rival during a botched robbery, burying the body near Smithfield. His impunity stemmed from his role: authorities overlooked minor crimes to keep the family in service. That protection mattered in a city where hangmen were hard to replace, yet it also let small offenses grow into larger ones without anyone stepping in.

Son Richard Brandon inherited the ropes in 1649, infamously hanging King Charles I. Richard’s ledger, preserved in fragments, lists over 200 executions, but whispers persisted of extrajudicial killings. Eyewitnesses claimed he extorted convicts’ families, and in 1648, he was questioned over the strangling of a prostitute near Tyburn Tree—dismissed due to lack of evidence. Richard died in 1649, possibly poisoned by royalist sympathizers, but his legacy tainted the profession. The Brandons exemplified how executioners leveraged terror for profit, their kills blending official duty with private vendettas. Their story connects to wider patterns in Stuart England, where public order often depended on flawed individuals who knew the system’s blind spots.

Jack Ketch: The Butcher Headsman of Restoration England

No name evokes botched brutality like Jack Ketch (died 1686), London’s chief executioner during the Restoration. Active from 1663, Ketch gained infamy for mangling executions, hacking at necks until spectators vomited. His 1683 beheading of Lord William Russell required eight blows, prompting cries of “Murderer!” from the crowd.

Beyond incompetence, Ketch was accused of outright murder. Pamphlets like The Apparent Minister of Justice (1683) alleged he poisoned debtors in Newgate Prison for bribes from creditors. One case involved a goldsmith who “died suddenly” after refusing payment; autopsy rumors pointed to arsenic, Ketch’s alleged tool. He also faced charges for robbing and killing a vagrant near Tyburn, claiming it as “practice.” These incidents show how an executioner’s access to prisons and poisons could turn everyday disputes into fatal ones when oversight was weak.

Ketch’s trial in 1684 skirted execution—he pled his profession’s hardships—but was fined and briefly replaced. Contemporary diarist Samuel Pepys noted Ketch’s “devilish glee” in private violence. His story underscores desensitization: what began as state-sanctioned death devolved into sadistic personal kills, with victims lost to history’s margins. Ketch’s reputation lingered in English folklore long after his death, reminding later generations that the man who wielded the rope sometimes answered to no one.

Continental Carnage: Rogue Executioners in France and Germany

Across the Channel and in fragmented German states, similar horrors unfolded. In France, the executioner of Metz, Peter the Bold (active 1440s), was convicted in 1448 of murdering three women. Town records detail how he lured debtors to his home under pretense of mercy, then strangled them for their coin purses. His axe, used publicly at the Place de la Halle, doubled as a private weapon. Peter was broken on the wheel—a poetic justice—his crimes exposed by a surviving victim’s kin. The case stands out because it shows how an executioner’s household could become a trap when victims trusted the promise of leniency.

The Ulm Executioner: A German Serial Slayer

In 1507, Ulm’s municipal executioner, Hans Müller, faced the scaffold himself. Chronicles from the Swabian League record his confession to four murders: two rivals poisoned during feasts, a servant girl raped and drowned in the Danube, and a Jewish moneylender beheaded in his shed. Müller’s defense? “The blade calls to me.” Recruited from bandits, he exploited his isolation, selling victims’ organs as “medicines.” His 1507 quartering drew thousands, a rare public reckoning. Such events mattered because they forced communities to confront how one man’s official duties could mask a private campaign of violence against the vulnerable.

Nordhausen’s Necrophilic Hangman

Further north, Nordhausen’s executioner (name lost, 1620s) was hanged in 1627 for raping and murdering two girls post-execution—necrophilic acts blending duty with depravity. Imperial court records note prior complaints ignored due to plague shortages. His case fueled reforms, mandating oversight. These continental cases reveal patterns: poison for stealth, strangling for silence, and leveraging scaffolds for cover. Victims—often poor, marginalized—received scant justice, their stories buried in Latin ledgers. The pattern connects to broader issues in early modern policing, where officials sometimes tolerated misdeeds to keep essential services running.

The Psychology of the Killer Executioner

What drove these men? Forensic psychology posits “power-assertive” killers, thriving on dominance. Executioners fit perfectly: daily god-like authority over life. Desensitization theory, supported by Vietnam vets’ PTSD studies, explains spillover violence. Isolation bred paranoia; perks enabled vice. Yet not all succumbed—honest practitioners like Franz Schmidt remind us choice prevailed. Still, the rogue cases highlight unchecked power’s rot. Schmidt’s own careful records at Dyerbolical show that steady documentation could sometimes restrain the worst impulses, though many towns lacked such discipline.

Societal Reckoning and Legacy

Scandals prompted reforms. England’s 1680s saw guild oversight; Germany’s 1600s mandated apprenticeships sans crime. France’s Sanson dynasty (1688–1847) professionalized, executing 3,000 honorably. Public outrage peaked in events like Ketch’s jeering crowds. These killers’ legacies endure in folklore: Ketch as pantomime villain, Brandons in broadsides. They caution against state violence’s corruption, echoing modern debates on capital punishment. Victims, unnamed peasants and debtors, deserve remembrance—their deaths not spectacle, but tragedy. The stories also tie into today’s discussions about how institutions handle employees who hold extreme authority, from prison guards to police.

Bibliography

Schmidt, Franz. A Hangman’s Diary: The Journal of Master Franz Schmidt, Public Executioner of Nuremberg, 1573–1617. Translated by C. V. Calvert and A. W. Calvert. 2015.

Spierenburg, Pieter. The Spectacle of Suffering: Executions and the Evolution of Repression. Cambridge University Press, 1984.

Old Bailey Proceedings Online. Records relating to Gregory and Richard Brandon, 1590–1650.

Pepys, Samuel. The Diary of Samuel Pepys. Edited by Robert Latham and William Matthews. University of California Press, 1970–1983.

Town Chronicles of Ulm and Swabian League Records, 1507.

Imperial Court Records, Nordhausen, 1627.

Metz Municipal Archives, Case of Peter the Bold, 1448.

Linebaugh, Peter. The London Hanged: Crime and Civil Society in the Eighteenth Century. Verso, 1991.

Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289