Picture a lone white van cutting through the damp Scottish countryside, its driver scanning for the next willing stranger. That single image from Jonathan Glazer’s Under the Skin captures something primal about how horror can hide in plain human longing. This article examines two landmark films that turned the alien woman into a predator who uses attraction as her weapon, comparing their very different styles while tracing what they reveal about sexuality, vulnerability, and the unknown across three decades of cinema.
From cosmic voids to earthly bedrooms, alien women prowl as humanity’s most intimate nightmares.
Jonathan Glazer’s Under the Skin (2013) and Roger Donaldson’s Species (1995) stand as haunting bookends to a peculiar subgenre of horror: the feminine alien predator. Both films centre on extraterrestrial females who infiltrate human society through seduction, only to reveal their monstrous hunger beneath a veneer of allure. This comparison peels back layers of sexuality, otherness, and predation to uncover why these stories continue to unsettle.
Both films weaponise female sexuality as a tool of alien predation, contrasting intimate seduction with visceral horror. Under the Skin‘s minimalist arthouse dread diverges sharply from Species‘ mainstream sci-fi spectacle, highlighting evolving genre aesthetics. Through their predatory heroines, the movies probe deep anxieties about femininity, vulnerability, and the unknown.
Enigmatic Arrivals from the Stars
In Under the Skin, Scarlett Johansson embodies an unnamed alien entity traversing the stark landscapes of Scotland. She drives a white van, luring isolated men into an abandoned, black-pool-filled house where they are stripped, submerged, and harvested for their flesh. The film opens with abstract cosmic imagery, Mica Levi’s screeching violin score establishing an immediate sense of alienation. Glazer’s narrative eschews exposition; we witness the alien’s methodical hunt, her human guise cracking only in fleeting moments of curiosity or distress. This sparse approach forces viewers into her inscrutable perspective, mirroring the disorientation of encountering the truly other.
Contrast this with Species, where Natasha Henstridge’s Sil emerges from a government experiment gone awry. A hybrid of human DNA and alien genetics, Sil matures from child to voluptuous adult in days, her rapid evolution a ticking bomb. Scientists, led by Ben Kingsley and Forest Whitaker, pursue her as she flees across America, seducing and slaughtering to propagate. The film’s prologue sets a clinical tone, with Michael Madsen’s Dan Smithson voicing ethical qualms over the hybrid’s creation. Where Glazer opts for poetic ambiguity, Donaldson delivers a pulpy thriller packed with chases, explosions, and creature-feature gore.
Both arrivals underscore the alien feminine as an invasive force. In Under the Skin, the protagonist’s van prowls urban fringes, preying on the marginalised—truckers, hitchhikers, the lonely. Her selections evoke class commentary, targeting those society overlooks. Sil, meanwhile, infiltrates affluent spaces, her beauty granting access to trains, bars, and bedrooms. Yet both exploit male desire; the alien woman’s body becomes a trojan horse for horror, inverting traditional monster narratives where females are victims. These choices matter because they force audiences to confront how easily desire overrides caution, a tension that has echoed through horror since the earliest femme fatale figures in 1940s film noir.
Their physical forms amplify this inversion. Johansson’s alien mimics human perfection—pale skin, red lips—yet moves with uncanny stiffness, her black eyes voids of empathy. Hidden cameras capture real encounters, lending authenticity to her predatory gaze. Henstridge’s Sil blends supermodel allure with latent monstrosity; her transformations reveal tentacles, spines, and acidic blood, practical effects by Steve Johnson pulsing with 1990s excess. These designs root the terror in the body, the feminine form as both invitation and trap. Similar bodily unease appears in later works such as Annihilation, yet Glazer and Donaldson remain distinctive for anchoring the horror so directly in everyday sexual encounters.
Sexuality Unleashed: The Predator’s Lure
Seduction drives both films’ horror engines. In Under the Skin, encounters unfold in ritualistic slow motion: men follow the alien into the void-like pool, shedding clothes as if entering a black mirror. The act is not consummated but implied, her voice—soft, repetitive—coaxing surrender. One pivotal scene sees a man hesitate, questioning her nudity; she drowns him anyway, her efficiency chilling. This desexualises the erotic, turning attraction into mechanical harvest, a critique of transactional male gaze.
Species revels in explicitness. Sil’s first kill follows a flirtatious train encounter; she drags a man into shadows, her body morphing mid-coitus into lethal frenzy. Later, she seduces Josh Charles’s Preston, only to impale him when interrupted. These moments blend Alien-esque xenomorph horror with erotic thriller tropes, her hybrid nature embodying unchecked female desire. Donaldson’s script, by Dennis Feldman, draws from Eve fantasies—Sil as Pandora, her beauty unleashing apocalypse.
Yet divergences reveal cultural shifts. Released amid 1990s AIDS anxieties and post-feminist debates, Species frames Sil’s sexuality as viral contagion, her promiscuity a public health menace. Glazer’s 2013 vision, influenced by post-9/11 isolation, portrays seduction as existential void; the alien’s curiosity peaks when she touches a disfigured man, sparing him, hinting at emergent humanity. Johansson’s performance layers blankness with micro-expressions, humanising the monster without softening her predation. The contrast shows how each era projects its own fears onto the same basic premise of the seductive outsider.
Thematic overlap emerges in male vulnerability. Both films dismantle bravado: victims in Under the Skin strip vulnerably, echoing Adam’s fall; Sil’s lovers confront their expendability. This predatory femininity challenges phallocentric horror, where women scream—here, they consume. Viewers are left to consider how rarely cinema allows female characters to occupy the role of active threat without immediate punishment.
Gazes of the Abyss: Cinematography and Mise-en-Scène
Glazer’s visuals haunt through abstraction. Daniel Landin’s cinematography favours long takes and natural light, Scotland’s misty moors and Glasgow’s grey tenements framing the alien’s isolation. The black pool sequence, shot with submerged cameras, distorts flesh into eerie geometry, symbolising devouring femininity. Compositional symmetry—endless roads, empty rooms—evokes cosmic indifference, the alien adrift in human mundanity.
Donaldson’s Species, shot by cinematographer Andrzej Bartkowiak, pulses with kinetic energy. Sweeping helicopter shots chase Sil through deserts and cities, while claustrophobic lab scenes heighten paranoia. Key kills employ Dutch angles and rapid cuts, her transformations lit in garish greens and reds, evoking The Thing. Practical sets—crumbling warehouses, neon-lit motels—ground the spectacle in tangible dread. The visual languages differ sharply, yet both succeed in making the audience complicit in watching the hunt unfold.
Both manipulate the gaze. In Under the Skin, subjective shots immerse us in the alien’s hunt, blurring predator and voyeur. Species shifts perspectives—scientists’ surveillance, victims’ desire—creating multifaceted paranoia. These techniques amplify alien otherness, the feminine form refracted through male fears of engulfment. As explored further at Dyerbolical, such formal choices often determine whether a horror film lingers in memory or fades into standard genre fare.
Mise-en-scène details enrich symbolism. Johansson’s fur coat in Under the Skin signifies disguise, shed in vulnerability; Sil’s flowing dresses accentuate lethal grace. Environments reflect prey: industrial voids for the working class in Glazer’s film, urban excess for Species‘ middle America.
Soundscapes of Seduction and Slaughter
Mica Levi’s score for Under the Skin is a masterclass in auditory horror—discordant strings screech like insect exoskeletons, pulsing electronics mimic heartbeats devolving into static. Silence dominates hunts, broken by the alien’s monotone queries, heightening tension. This sound design immerses, making flesh-stripping scenes palpably visceral without gore.
Species leans on Christopher Young’s bombastic orchestra—swelling synths for seductions, metallic stings for kills. Sound effects amplify transformations: wet snaps, hisses, echoing roars. The score bridges Jaws-style suspense with erotic pulses, underscoring Sil’s dual nature.
Audio reinforces thematic predation. Levi’s score dehumanises, Young’s humanises the alien’s allure, reflecting arthouse vs blockbuster sensibilities. Both unsettle through sonic invasion, mirroring the feminine predators’ infiltration. The lasting impact of these sound choices can be heard in later atmospheric horror scores that favour unease over conventional cues.
Monstrous Transformations: Special Effects Breakdown
Under the Skin shuns effects for implication. Flesh-harvesting uses practical prosthetics—cadavers flayed by off-screen assistants—but core horror lies in suggestion. Johansson’s digital deconstruction in the finale, body collapsing into swarm, blends CGI minimalism with body horror, evoking Cronenbergian mutation without excess.
Species showcases 1990s pinnacle: Steve Johnson’s Creature Effects crafted Sil’s full-body suits, tentacles coiling realistically via pneumatics. Acid blood melts flesh with hydraulic squirts; death scenes feature animatronic heads exploding in practical glory. Budget ($35 million) allowed Alec Gillis and Tom Woodruff Jr.’s ADI contributions, influencing Alien Resurrection.
Effects evolution mirrors genre: Glazer’s restraint prioritises psychological impact, Donaldson’s visceral displays cater to spectacle. Both achieve iconic femininity—beautiful until burst. Contemporary audiences raised on digital effects often rediscover the tactile power of these practical sequences when revisiting the originals.
Legacy of the Femme Fatale from Beyond
Species spawned sequels, cementing Sil as B-movie icon, influencing hybrid horrors like Jennifer’s Body. Under the Skin, critically lauded, inspired arthouse sci-fi like Annihilation. Together, they trace predatory femininity from 90s excess to modern minimalism, enduring in discussions of gender and monstrosity.
Production tales add lustre: Glazer shot covertly with non-actors; Donaldson battled MPAA cuts. These films persist, challenging viewers to confront desire’s dark underbelly. Their influence continues to surface in newer releases that blend erotic tension with body horror, keeping the conversation alive well into the 2020s.
Director in the Spotlight: Jonathan Glazer
Jonathan Glazer, born 26 March 1965 in London, emerged from advertising’s glossy world before conquering cinema. Educating at Nottingham Trent Polytechnic and London’s Royal College of Art, he directed iconic ads for Guinness and Levi’s, honing visual storytelling. His feature debut Sexy Beast (2000) garnered BAFTA acclaim, its sun-baked tension launching Ben Kingsley’s comeback as crime boss Don Logan.
Glazer’s oeuvre blends thriller and existential dread. Birth (2004) probed grief through Nicole Kidman’s encounter with a boy claiming to be her reincarnated husband, earning Oscar nods for its ice-rink centrepiece. Under the Skin (2013), adapted from Michel Faber’s novel, marked his horror pivot, using hidden cameras for authenticity. Levi’s score and Landin’s images secured awards, cementing Glazer’s reputation as visionary stylist.
Influenced by Nic Roeg and Stanley Kubrick, Glazer favours ambiguity. His 2014 Channel 4 ad Liberty mourned Margaret Thatcher obliquely. Latest, The Zone of Interest (2023), sound-designs Auschwitz domesticity adjacent to Sandra Hüller’s family life, netting Oscar for Best International Feature and six more, including Direction nods.
Filmography highlights: Sexy Beast (2000)—Ray Winstone’s retiree tormented by Kingsley; Birth (2004)—Kidman’s widow haunted; Under the Skin (2013)—Johansson’s alien huntress; The Zone of Interest (2023)—banal evil in Nazi home. Documentaries like Inside Rwanda (2006) underscore his ethical lens. Glazer remains selective, each film a precision scalpel dissecting humanity.
Actor in the Spotlight: Scarlett Johansson
Scarlett Johansson, born 22 November 1984 in New York City to a Danish-Jewish mother and New York-born father, displayed prodigy early. Manhattan theatre training led to film at age eight: North (1994) opposite Elijah Wood, then Just Cause (1995) with Sean Connery. Breakthrough arrived with Sofia Coppola’s Lost in Translation (2003), her wistful Charlotte earning BAFTA and MTV nods alongside Bill Murray.
Johansson’s versatility spans indie to blockbuster. Ghost World (2001) showcased deadpan as Enid; Girl with a Pearl Earring (2003) period poise opposite Colin Firth. Marvel cemented stardom: Black Widow in Iron Man 2 (2010), anchoring Avengers series through Black Widow (2021), grossing billions despite lawsuit over contract.
Horror gravitates her gifts: Under the Skin (2013) physicalised alien detachment; Her (2013) voiced seductive OS. Awards tally Golden Globe for Jojo Rabbit (2019) supporting, Tony for A View from the Bridge (2010). Producing via These Pictures, she backed Rough Night (2017).
Comprehensive filmography: The Horse Whisperer (1998)—debut lead; Ghost World (2001)—rebel teen; Lost in Translation (2003)—lonely expat; Match Point (2005)—Woody Allen femme fatale; The Prestige (2006)—magician’s muse; Vicky Cristina Barcelona (2008)—Penelope Cruz rival; Iron Man 2 (2010)—Natasha Romanoff intro; The Avengers (2012)—team assembler; Under the Skin (2013)—predatory alien; Lucy (2014)—evolving superhuman; Avengers: Endgame (2019)—heroic sacrifice; Marriage Story (2019)—Oscar-nominated divorcee; Black Widow (2021)—solo origin. Theatre: The Seagull (2008). Johansson embodies chameleonic allure, from cosmic hunter to blockbuster anchor.
Craving deeper dives into horror’s shadows? Subscribe to NecroTimes for weekly terrors delivered straight to your inbox.
Bibliography
Bradshaw, P. (2014) Under the Skin review. The Guardian. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/film/2014/mar/09/under-the-skin-review (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Clover, C. J. (1992) Men, Women, and Chain Saws: Gender in the Modern Horror Film. Princeton University Press.
Glazer, J. (2014) Interview: Making Under the Skin. Sight and Sound, May.
Grant, B. K. (ed.) (2004) Planks of Reason: Essays on the Horror Film. Scarecrow Press.
Henstridge, N. (1995) Species press junket. Fangoria, Issue 148.
Levi, M. (2014) Composing for Under the Skin. The Quietus. Available at: https://thequietus.com/articles/16542-mica-levi-interview-under-the-skin (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Newman, K. (1995) Species review. Empire. Available at: https://www.empireonline.com/movies/reviews/species-review (Accessed: 15 October 2024).
Williams, L. (1991) Hard Core: Power, Pleasure, and the ‘Frenzy of the Visible’. University of California Press.
Got thoughts? Drop them below!
For more articles visit us at https://dyerbolical.com.
Join the discussion on X at
https://x.com/dyerbolicaldb
https://x.com/retromoviesdb
https://x.com/ashyslasheedb
Follow all our pages via our X list at
https://x.com/i/lists/1645435624403468289
